TLDR
Authentic Italian gelato & tiramisu standout. Great for unique chocolates, hearty breads, and quality meats.
Details
Eataly Caffe in Manhattan offers a delightful Italian culinary experience, with users praising its house-brand chocolate and hearty sliced bread [1]. The tiramisu is a standout, often cited as the best non-restaurant version available in NYC [2], [3], [4]. Beyond desserts, Eataly is a go-to for authentic Italian gelato, with the Savor Gelato al Momento receiving high accolades [5], [6], [7], and is also a reliable source for high-quality meats and fresh mushrooms [8], [9], [10].
Food Overview
Eataly Caffe is celebrated for its authentic Italian gelato, with the Savor Gelato al Momento being a particular highlight for its texture and flavor [1], [2], [3]. The tiramisu is frequently recommended as the best non-restaurant option in NYC [4], [5], [6]. For those seeking other treats, their house-brand chocolate and chocolate chip cookies are also well-regarded [7]. The marketplace offers hearty sliced bread [8] and a consistent selection of fresh mushrooms, though these can be seasonal and pricey [9], [10], [11]. Eataly is also noted as a top source for high-quality meats like heritage breed chicken and lamb [12], [13]. However, some patrons find the pizza to be average and overpriced [14], [15], [16].
Highlights / Recommended
"Eataly's tiramisu is frequently highlighted as a must-try, often considered the best non-restaurant version in NYC [1], [2], [3]. The authentic Italian gelato, particularly the Savor Gelato al Momento, also receives high praise [4], [5], [6]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •tiramisu(3)
Customer Sentiment
Customers rave about Eataly's authentic Italian gelato and tiramisu, often calling it the best they've had outside of a restaurant [1], [2], [3]. While many appreciate the variety of high-quality Italian foods, some find certain items like pizza to be overpriced for the quality [4].
Caveats
While Eataly is praised for many items, some customers find their pizza to be average and overpriced [1], [2], [3]. Fresh mushrooms, like porcini, can be seasonal and expensive [4], [5], and one user reported a negative experience with a butcher regarding lamb tenderloin availability [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EATALY CAFFE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where To Buy Fresh Morels In The City Preferably
"The original poster mentioned Eataly as a place that sometimes has morels but noted the quality was sometimes old."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user found the pizza at Eataly to be completely average for the price charged."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This commenter stated that Eataly charges $9 for a plain slice of pizza and higher for toppings."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user simply listed 'Slices at Eataly' as an example of overpriced pizza."
NegativeFrom post: Rotisserieroasted Chicken
"Eataly's rotisserie chicken is rated 9/10 and costs $15."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Buy Porcini
"This commenter mentioned seeing fresh porcini mushrooms at Eataly, but noted they are seasonal, expensive, and have lost flavor due to travel from Italy."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Buy Porcini
"The commenter stated that Eataly is the most consistent place for fresh mushrooms, though it is pricey. They prefer fresh over dried mushrooms."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Buy Porcini
"The commenter suggested Eataly as a place to find porcini mushrooms, noting they usually have a wide variety."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Get Chicken
"Eataly was recommended as a place to buy Snowdance Farms heritage breed chicken, which the user considers the best they've found in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: I Need Some Lamb That Tastes Like Lamb
"The commenter identifies Eataly as their go-to for lamb in the local market."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Highly recommends the Savor Gelato al Momento with Carpigiani at Eataly Flatiron's pizza restaurant, calling it the best gelato with the best texture and closest to authentic gelato from Bologna."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"States that the gelato at Eataly is as authentic Italian as they have had in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Mentions Eataly's new gelato franchise as very good."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get More Than 4 Or 5 Raviolis
"Eataly is suggested for buying fresh handmade ravioli as a splurge, noting it's cheaper than restaurant prices, and they also offer premade sauce."
PositiveFrom post: Lamb Tenderloin
"The user inquired about the availability of lamb tenderloin at Eataly and received a negative reaction from the butcher."
NegativeFrom post: Rate My Itinerary
"Recommends Eataly for its variety of Italian food options, including restaurants and a marketplace."
PositiveFrom post: Best Tiramisu In Manhattan
"Eataly's takeout tiramisu is a solid choice and a good value for the large size."
PositiveFrom post: Best Tiramisu In Manhattan
"Recommended Eataly as a place to get tiramisu."
PositiveFrom post: Three Nights And Three Different Cuisines Where
"Eating at the high tops at Eataly Flatiron is suggested for good wine and solid food."
Neutral