TLDR
Vast Italian marketplace with high-quality artisanal goods and authentic desserts. A go-to for specialty ingredients, though prepared hot foods can be pricey.
Details
Eataly is a expansive Italian marketplace and dining destination offering everything from premium grocery items to sit-down meals [7]. Shoppers frequently praise the high-quality selection of fresh ingredients, including heritage breed poultry, lamb, and a wide variety of seasonal mushrooms [18], [20], [21]. While the marketplace is celebrated for its authentic artisanal products like gelato and tiramisu, some diners find the prepared food items, particularly the pizza, to be overpriced for the value provided [9], [15], [23].
Food Overview
This venue excels in its selection of fresh, high-quality groceries including heritage chicken, lamb, and a consistent, albeit expensive, range of mushrooms [18], [19], [21]. Dessert offerings are highly regarded, with many users citing the tiramisu as a top choice in the city and the artisanal gelato as exceptionally authentic [2], [8], [14], [15]. Conversely, prepared items such as pizza are frequently criticized as being average in quality and overpriced [23], [24], [25].
Highlights / Recommended
"The tiramisu and gelato are highly recommended by customers for their quality and authenticity [2], [14], [15]. Additionally, the rotisserie chicken is well-regarded for being both delicious and reasonably priced [27]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •tiramisu(3)
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is positive regarding the quality of marketplace products and desserts like tiramisu and gelato [2], [14], [15], though some patrons report disappointment with the pricing of prepared hot foods like pizza and sandwiches [23], [26]. Occasional service issues at the counters have also been noted [17].
Caveats
Prepared hot food items, specifically pizza and sandwiches, are often cited as being overpriced and providing mediocre value for the cost [23], [26]. Fresh seasonal items may also vary in quality depending on the time of year [19].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EATALY CAFFE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Decently Priced Lunch Options Around Rockefeller
"Sandwiches are $16, which is exactly the price point the OP wanted to avoid."
NegativeFrom post: Decently Priced Lunch Options Around Rockefeller
"Short recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Buy Fresh Morels In The City Preferably
"The original poster mentioned Eataly as a place that sometimes has morels but noted the quality was sometimes old."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user found the pizza at Eataly to be completely average for the price charged."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This commenter stated that Eataly charges $9 for a plain slice of pizza and higher for toppings."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user simply listed 'Slices at Eataly' as an example of overpriced pizza."
NegativeFrom post: Rotisserieroasted Chicken
"Eataly's rotisserie chicken is rated 9/10 and costs $15."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Buy Porcini
"This commenter mentioned seeing fresh porcini mushrooms at Eataly, but noted they are seasonal, expensive, and have lost flavor due to travel from Italy."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Buy Porcini
"The commenter stated that Eataly is the most consistent place for fresh mushrooms, though it is pricey. They prefer fresh over dried mushrooms."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Buy Porcini
"The commenter suggested Eataly as a place to find porcini mushrooms, noting they usually have a wide variety."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Get Chicken
"Eataly was recommended as a place to buy Snowdance Farms heritage breed chicken, which the user considers the best they've found in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: I Need Some Lamb That Tastes Like Lamb
"The commenter identifies Eataly as their go-to for lamb in the local market."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Highly recommends the Savor Gelato al Momento with Carpigiani at Eataly Flatiron's pizza restaurant, calling it the best gelato with the best texture and closest to authentic gelato from Bologna."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"States that the gelato at Eataly is as authentic Italian as they have had in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Mentions Eataly's new gelato franchise as very good."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get More Than 4 Or 5 Raviolis
"Eataly is suggested for buying fresh handmade ravioli as a splurge, noting it's cheaper than restaurant prices, and they also offer premade sauce."
PositiveFrom post: Lamb Tenderloin
"The user inquired about the availability of lamb tenderloin at Eataly and received a negative reaction from the butcher."
NegativeFrom post: Rate My Itinerary
"Recommends Eataly for its variety of Italian food options, including restaurants and a marketplace."
PositiveFrom post: Best Tiramisu In Manhattan
"Eataly's takeout tiramisu is a solid choice and a good value for the large size."
PositiveFrom post: Best Tiramisu In Manhattan
"Recommended Eataly as a place to get tiramisu."
Positive