Authentic Italian marketplace & dining. Must-try tiramisu, gelato, and fresh pasta. Your one-stop shop for Italian delights.
Eataly Caffe offers a vibrant Italian culinary experience, blending a marketplace with dining options. It's a go-to spot for those seeking authentic Italian flavors, from artisanal breads and fresh pasta to exceptional desserts like tiramisu and gelato. While some find it can be pricey, the quality and variety of Italian goods make it a standout destination for food enthusiasts.
Eataly Caffe boasts a wide array of Italian food, including fresh pasta like ravioli, artisanal breads, and high-quality meats and produce. Desserts are a particular strong suit, with the tiramisu and gelato receiving widespread acclaim for their authenticity and flavor. While most feedback is positive, some find certain items, like the bread, to be less sweet than expected.
"Tiramisu, gelato, fresh ravioli, and artisanal breads are frequently recommended by customers. The chocolate mousse and cookies also receive positive mentions."
Customers generally praise the authentic Italian offerings, with tiramisu, gelato, and fresh pasta being frequently highlighted as excellent choices. Some note that prices can be on the higher side, but the quality justifies the cost for many.
Important Note
Some customers find Eataly's offerings, particularly bread, to be less sweet than anticipated, and prices can be on the higher side.
"This commenter mentioned seeing fresh porcini mushrooms at Eataly, but noted they are seasonal, expensive, and have lost flavor due to travel from Italy."
Neutral"The commenter stated that Eataly is the most consistent place for fresh mushrooms, though it is pricey. They prefer fresh over dried mushrooms."
Positive"The commenter suggested Eataly as a place to find porcini mushrooms, noting they usually have a wide variety."
Positive"Eataly was recommended as a place to buy Snowdance Farms heritage breed chicken, which the user considers the best they've found in NYC."
Positive"The commenter identifies Eataly as their go-to for lamb in the local market."
Positive"Highly recommends the Savor Gelato al Momento with Carpigiani at Eataly Flatiron's pizza restaurant, calling it the best gelato with the best texture and closest to authentic gelato from Bologna."
Positive"States that the gelato at Eataly is as authentic Italian as they have had in NYC."
Positive"Mentions Eataly's new gelato franchise as very good."
Positive"Eataly is suggested for buying fresh handmade ravioli as a splurge, noting it's cheaper than restaurant prices, and they also offer premade sauce."
Positive"The user inquired about the availability of lamb tenderloin at Eataly and received a negative reaction from the butcher."
Negative"Recommends Eataly for its variety of Italian food options, including restaurants and a marketplace."
Positive"Eataly's takeout tiramisu is a solid choice and a good value for the large size."
Positive"Recommended Eataly as a place to get tiramisu."
Positive"Eating at the high tops at Eataly Flatiron is suggested for good wine and solid food."
Neutral"This user liked the chocolate chip cookie from Eataly."
Positive"This user mentioned that Eataly's chocolate mousse is also quite good."
Positive"This user also recommended Eataly's Tiramisu."
Positive"This user found Eataly's tiramisu to be the best non-restaurant tiramisu they've had in NYC, despite generally finding Eataly items overpriced and average."
Positive"This user recommended Eataly's Tiramisu as a good option."
Positive
