Details
This Brooklyn-based spot offers a classic American burger experience, with many patrons praising their shakes and fries. While some consider it a top-tier smash burger joint, others find it to be a decent, albeit pricey, alternative to other popular burger chains [1]. The "Hot Mess" burger and jerk fries are frequently highlighted as must-tries for first-time visitors [1].
Food Overview
The restaurant is primarily known for its burgers and shakes, with many recommending the "Hot Mess" burger and jerk fries [1]. Some diners find the burgers to be among the best in the city, while others feel they are decent but not exceptional, and occasionally overcooked [1]. The shakes also receive praise, though some found them disappointing [1]. Fries, including yam fries, are generally well-regarded [1]. One commenter noted the use of beef tallow for frying [1].
The "Hot Mess" burger and jerk fries are frequently recommended, with some considering them a standout [1].
Customer feedback is mixed, with many enjoying the burgers and shakes, though some find the prices high and the quality inconsistent compared to other city favorites [1].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01hot mess2 mentions
Caveats
Some diners find the restaurant to be pricey, and a few have experienced issues with burger texture or fries being stale [1]. One commenter felt the patties in promotional photos looked dry [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Anytime Im Around Brooklyn Or Harlem I Have To
"The commenter finds Harlem Shake great but sometimes the burger can be overcooked and items pricey, though they praise the unique yam fries."
PositiveFrom post: Anytime Im Around Brooklyn Or Harlem I Have To
"The commenter found the food at Harlem Shake to look incredible and thanked the original poster for sharing."
PositiveFrom post: Anytime Im Around Brooklyn Or Harlem I Have To
"While considering smashburgers generally 'mid', the commenter enjoys the 'Hot Mess' with jerk fries from Harlem Shake occasionally."
NeutralFrom post: Anytime Im Around Brooklyn Or Harlem I Have To
"The commenter finds Harlem Shake decent but disagrees with it being the best smash burger in the city, as many places offer double patties."
NeutralFrom post: Anytime Im Around Brooklyn Or Harlem I Have To
"The commenter believes Shake Shack is better than Harlem Shake."
Negative