Lively Med/Am spot known for brunch & breakfast. Some say it lost its charm, others love the vibe & solid food. Great for people-watching!
This vibrant Mediterranean and American eatery, with roots on Lafayette Street, offers a popular brunch and breakfast menu. While some patrons recall a charm that may have diminished with expansion, others praise it as a go-to spot for a lively atmosphere and solid, unadventurous food that appeals to a younger crowd. It's often recommended for its people-watching opportunities from sidewalk seating, though opinions on its overall culinary merit are divided.
The cuisine is described as Mediterranean, Israeli, and American, with a strong emphasis on brunch and breakfast. While some users recommend specific dishes and find the food solid and reasonably priced, others consider it mediocre, not particularly special, and overpriced for the quality.
"The kale salad with salmon was specifically praised for its crispy salmon and addictive tangy dressing, described as reasonably priced for the area."
Customer sentiment is mixed. Some find it to be a great, lively spot with solid food, especially for brunch, while others criticize it as over-hyped, mediocre, and overpriced, particularly after expansion.
Important Note
Opinions are divided, with some users finding the food mediocre and overpriced, while others praise its value and atmosphere. The original location's charm might have diminished with expansion.
"This restaurant was recommended as a spot that could accommodate a large group for brunch."
Neutral"The user mentions hearing positive things about Jacks Wife Freda for brunch."
Positive"This commenter agreed that Jack's Wife Frieda isn't outrageously expensive, but still found it to be subpar."
Negative"This user downplayed the negative aspects of Jack's Wife Frieda, suggesting it's not extreme enough to be a top contender for a bad restaurant."
Neutral"This user stated they liked the salads from Spring Street Natural, even though they don't typically eat salads."
Positive"This commenter listed several other notable restaurants that used to be in the area, recalling fond memories of dining there in the early 2000s."
Positive"This user reiterated their negative view of Jack's Wife Frieda, citing meh food and high prices, and comparing it unfavorably to Bite restaurant nearby."
Negative"This user expressed happiness that Spring Street Natural was mentioned, reminiscing about its quality."
Positive"This commenter offered a counterpoint to the previous defense, suggesting that if Jack's Wife Frieda truly did what it does well, it would be more successful."
Negative"This user defended Jack's Wife Frieda, suggesting it's misunderstood and would be better received if positioned as an upscale diner with a unique menu."
Positive"This commenter described Jack's Wife Frieda as 'mid' and suggested the block it's on could be called 'midtown' due to its perceived lack of quality."
Negative"This commenter had a positive experience at Jack's Wife Frieda for a late lunch, finding the food good and the service pleasant due to it not being busy."
Positive"This user recommended Jack's Wife Frieda on Spring Street, contrasting it negatively with the previously mentioned Spring Street Natural."
Negative"This user has never had a problem getting a table at Jack's Wife Freda on Carmine Street."
Neutral"Jack's wife Freda is recommended for sit-down dining."
Positive"Jack's Wife Freda was suggested as an alternative if the user is considering Soho, noting it offers great people-watching from its sidewalk seating."
Positive"This user agreed with the previous comment, stating the food at Jack's Wife Freda is very average and not comparable to a diner."
Negative"This user agreed that the food at Jack's Wife Freda is mediocre, questioning its popularity."
Negative"Jack's Wife Freda in SoHo is recommended for its great outdoor seating and is good for just a drink or coffee, though the food was noted as not being particularly special."
Neutral"Jack wife Freda is mentioned."
Neutral
