Next.js logo

LUCIA PIZZA

Last Updated: ~1 month ago

Phone: (718) 313-0999

Address: 2201 AVENUE X 11235

TLDR

A top-tier Brooklyn pizza joint w/ classic & unique slices like Grandma & Vodka Grandma. A must-try for pizza lovers!

Sentiment Overview(Based on 20 Reddit comments)

80% Positive20% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo
Next.js logo

Tags

italian 12italian-american 5american 5pizza 19slice 3View All

Neighborhoods

Sheepshead Bay

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

This Brooklyn pizzeria is a standout for its exceptional pizza, with many recommending it as a top-tier option in NYC. Patrons rave about their classic Grandma slice and unique options like the Vodka Grandma and Caramelle Piccanti. It's a destination for pizza lovers seeking quality pies, with some even making special trips to enjoy their offerings.

Food Overview

This establishment is celebrated for its outstanding pizza, drawing comparisons to other top pizza spots in the city. The Grandma slice and its variations, such as the Vodka Grandma and Caramelle Piccanti, are particularly recommended and lauded for their flavor and quality.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Grandma slice, Vodka Grandma slice, and Caramelle Piccanti are highly recommended, offering both classic and unique flavor profiles."

Customer Sentiment

Customers highly praise this pizzeria for its excellent pizza, often considering it among the best in NYC. Specific slices like the Grandma and Vodka Grandma are frequently recommended.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

A user recommends Lucia as a superior pizza option in South Brooklyn, even when compared to highly regarded places like Di Fara.
This comment places Lucia among the 'new gen' pizza spots that are excelling in the current NYC pizza scene, highlighting its relevance and quality.
A commenter specifically recommends the Clam pie from Lucia, noting they make special trips to get it, indicating it's a standout dish.
Lucia Pizza of Avenue X is mentioned and ranked favorably, with the commenter placing it above other well-known pizza establishments like NY Pizza Suprema, L'industrie, Joe's, and Scarr's.
Lucia is suggested as an excellent pizza option, and its proximity to the poster's accommodation was also noted as a positive factor.

Recent Mentions

From post: Visiting Nyc After 14 Years Looking For A Great

"The original poster found Lucia to be a great option for pizza and noted its proximity to their accommodation."

Positive
Jan 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Visiting Nyc After 14 Years Looking For A Great

"Lucia is suggested as an excellent pizza option and is noted as being close to where the original poster is staying."

Positive
Jan 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: 1st Time In Usa And Nyc

"Lucia of Avenue X was listed as a recommended pizza spot, to be visited after Joe's and NY Pizza Suprema, alongside Cellos."

Positive
Nov 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Any Great Pizzerias In Brooklyn With A Decent

"The user listed Lucia as a pizzeria option in Brooklyn."

Positive
Nov 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Place To Buy Caviar For Athome Consumption

"While discussing Olma in Sheepshead Bay, this user mentions that one can also get a slice of pizza at Lucia's across the street."

Neutral
Sep 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: 40 Year Nyc Resident Here Are My Brooklyn

"The author identifies this as their go-to spot for a slice of pizza in South Brooklyn."

Positive
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Under The Radar Pizza In Manhattan

"Lucia of Avenue X is recommended as a favorite in Brooklyn, with a Soho location also mentioned."

Positive
Aug 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Favorite Pizzas Ive Tried In Manhattan

"Lucia of Avenue X in Manhattan is recommended as a pizza place to try."

Positive
Aug 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Any Good For 3 Nights Heres What I Come Up With

"The commenter implies Lucia is a better pizza option than Ceres, indicating a positive opinion."

Positive
Jun 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: Any Good For 3 Nights Heres What I Come Up With

"The commenter mentions Lucia of X, noting its Brooklyn origins as an old-school pizza shop, implying quality."

Neutral
Jun 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: If You Could Only Pick One Restaurant In

"lchen34 recommends Lucia’s in Flushing for the best old school NYC plain pizza slice."

Positive
May 1, 2025View Comment →

From post: Favorite Slice Spot For The Best Of Both Worlds

"Recommends Lucia Pizzeria located on Avenue X."

Positive
Apr 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Fave Slice In Each Borough

"Recommends Lucia for pizza in Manhattan."

Positive
Apr 3, 2025View Comment →

From post: New Personal Top 5 Contender

"The commenter notes that Diamond Slice looks like Lucia pizza."

Neutral
Apr 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: New Personal Top 5 Contender

"The commenter mentions Lucia as one of the 'new gen' pizza spots doing it right in the current NYC pizza scene."

Positive
Apr 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Psa The Dumbo Lb Location Is In Fact Up To Snuff

"User recommends Lucia as a better pizza option in South Brooklyn compared to the original Di Fara if making a special trip."

Positive
Mar 31, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Pizza Is The Best Out Of All These Options

"Lucia Pizza Of Avenue X is ranked better than NY Pizza Suprema, L'industrie, Joe's and Scarr's."

Positive
Mar 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Very Specific Dishes Looking For

"only spots with good clam pizza I know/have heard of are probably Andrew Bellucci's Pizzeria (Astoria) or Lucia's (Ave X location only which is a pain to get to) but I don't think either is New Haven style unless I'm mistaken."

Neutral
Mar 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Your Travel List Pizza Bagels Dumplings Tacos

"A commenter highly recommends Lucia Pizza, stating they specifically make detours on Fridays to get the Clam pie."

Positive
Feb 27, 2025View Comment →