TLDR
Authentic old-school Italian in Marine Park. Red sauce, live music, sophisticated vibe. A true taste of traditional NYC Italian.
Details
Michael's of Brooklyn is a highly regarded, old-school Italian restaurant in Marine Park, known for its authentic, homemade-style Italian cuisine and welcoming atmosphere. It's a sophisticated spot that attracts a discerning clientele who appreciate the classic red sauce experience, complete with live music and martinis [1]. The restaurant is particularly praised for its standout dishes like the Veal Chop Parmesan and a delicious baked and burnt rigatoni, offering a taste of traditional New York Italian dining.
Food Overview
Michael's of Brooklyn excels in classic Italian-American fare, particularly noted for its red sauce dishes and homemade style. The Veal Chop Parmesan is described as a 'wonder,' and the baked and burnt rigatoni is a highly recommended pasta dish. The restaurant also offers fantastic vodka sauce, with one user specifically calling out their Rigatoni Baked n Burnt style. Fried lobster is also mentioned as an unreal dish [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"Standout dishes include the Veal Chop Parmesan and the baked and burnt rigatoni. The restaurant is also praised for its vodka sauce and its fried lobster is described as 'unreal' [1]."
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise Michael's of Brooklyn for its authentic, homemade-style Italian food and old-school atmosphere, often highlighting dishes like the Veal Chop Parmesan and baked rigatoni as exceptional. While some note it's a long trip from Midtown, the overall sentiment is highly positive, with many considering it a top choice for traditional Italian dining.
Caveats
The restaurant is noted to be quite a long trip from Midtown and requires more travel than some other options, though diners find it well worth the journey.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MICHAEL'S RESTAURANT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Chicken Parmesean In Nyc Recommendation
"Michael's of Brooklyn is an old-school restaurant with great chicken parmesan and delicious baked and burnt rigatoni, though it is quite out of the way."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go As Your Last Meal In Nyc
"Michael's of Brooklyn is mentioned as a highly regarded classic red sauce/white table cloth restaurant in deep South Brooklyn, suitable for special occasions."
PositiveFrom post: I Need A Nice Seafood Place To Bring My Mom For
"Michael's on Ave R was recommended, with a specific mention of their fried lobster being unreal."
PositiveFrom post: Spumoni Dessert Location
"Michaels of Brooklyn is mentioned as being similar to L&B Spumoni Gardens."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations
"This user listed Michael's of Brooklyn as a good option for old-school Italian."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations
"This user recommended Michael's of Brooklyn for its old-school New York Italian vibe and crowd, stating reservations are not impossible to get."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations
"This user recommended Michael's of Brooklyn for its real NY vibe and attention it receives online."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Go For The Comfort Foods You Grew Up
"In response to a request for Italian-American spots in Brooklyn, Michaels of Brooklyn was listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's of Brooklyn is considered extremely good but a long journey for a visitor."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's of Brooklyn is highly praised for its food, especially the veal chop parmesan, but is acknowledged as a long trip from Midtown."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's is recommended as a good choice."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's of Brooklyn is noted for being very welcoming and good to children."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's of Brooklyn is loved for its old-school atmosphere with Sinatra playing and the owner's friendliness. Their homemade sauce is also highly praised."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's in Marine Park, Brooklyn, is presented as the best option for an authentic, homemade-style Italian meal with few tourists."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Michael's of Brooklyn is considered the best authentic option for an old-school vibe, although it requires more travel than Bamonte's."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"This commenter questions why Michael's of Brooklyn hasn't been recommended more, suggesting it's an excellent choice."
PositiveFrom post: Eats Near Rockaway
"This establishment in Marine Park is described as legitimate old-school Italian and is also within a 20-30 minute drive."
PositiveFrom post: Spicy Rigatoni Vodka
"The author's favorite vodka sauce comes from Michael's on Avenue R, specifically mentioning their Rigatoni Baked n Burnt style as being what the original poster is looking for."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Good Red Sauce Joints In Nyc
"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."
Neutral