Next.js logo

MICHAEL'S RESTAURANT

Last Updated: 1 day ago

Phone: (718) 998-7851

Address: 2929 AVENUE R 11229

TLDR

Old-school Italian dining with a classic ambiance, perfect for a timeless meal.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 7 Reddit comments)

71% Positive14% Neutral14% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 5italian-american 4View All

Neighborhoods

Sheepshead Bay

Details

This Brooklyn Italian restaurant offers a classic, old-school dining experience, often recommended for its traditional Italian-American cuisine. It's described as an "old school neighborhood place" with a "class" ambiance, making it a go-to for those seeking a timeless Italian meal. While many praise its authenticity, one reviewer found the food bland, though they did note the sauce had a good flavor.

Food Overview

This Italian restaurant is lauded for its classic dishes and old-school charm, with customers frequently recommending it. One diner found the food to be bland, although they noted the sauce was flavorful.

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive view of this establishment, often recommending it for its classic Italian-American fare and old-school ambiance. However, one review noted the food could be bland despite a flavorful sauce.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This commenter considers Michael's of Brooklyn in Marine Park to be the best restaurant, highlighting its old-school, white tablecloth ambiance over trendy spots.
This commenter lists Michael's of Brooklyn as their top recommendation for Italian restaurants in Brooklyn.
One review found the visual appeal of Michael's of Brooklyn to be nice, but considered the food bland, noting that the sauce was "hopped up."
This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint, drawing parallels to Bamonte's.
This user recommends Michael's of Brooklyn as a classic Italian dining option.
Michael's of Brooklyn is mentioned as an old-school neighborhood Italian restaurant option.

Recent Mentions

From post: What Are Some Good Red Sauce Joints In Nyc

"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."

Neutral
Aug 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Memorable Italian Restaurant

"Michael's of Brooklyn in Marine Park is considered the best restaurant by the user, offering an old-school, white tablecloth ambiance rather than a trendy one."

Positive
Jun 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Brother Wants To Eat Like Tony Soprano In

"The commenter recommends Michael's of Brooklyn, calling it "class.""

Positive
May 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Brother Wants To Eat Like Tony Soprano In

"The commenter lists Michael's of Brooklyn as the top recommendation for Italian restaurants in Brooklyn."

Positive
May 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Unpretentious Classic Italians Pasta Or Pizza

"Found Michael's of Brooklyn to be a nice spot visually, but considered the food bland despite the sauce being 'hopped up'."

Negative
May 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Unpretentious Classic Italians Pasta Or Pizza

"Recommends Michael's of Brooklyn as an Italian dining option."

Positive
May 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where To Take Parents 2nd Time In Nyc

"Go to Don Peppe in Queens, Bamonte's or Michael's Of Brooklyn. Italian food. Old school neighborhood places."

Positive
Mar 23, 2025View Comment →