Legendary roast beef sandwiches & shakes w/ a retro vibe. A classic NYC cheap eat.
This Brooklyn institution has been serving up classic American fare since 1971, and it's famous for its legendary roast beef sandwich. It's a no-frills spot where you can grab a satisfying meal without breaking the bank, and it's a favorite for a reason.
This restaurant is renowned for its roast beef sandwiches, often described as a classic NYC bite. Customers also enjoy their cottage fries and shakes. While most feedback is positive, some compare it unfavorably to other roast beef sandwiches from different regions.
"The roast beef sandwich is a highly recommended item, often praised for its value and taste. Additionally, customers suggest trying the cheezburger, cottage fries, corn fritters, and their signature orangade or lemonade."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards this establishment, often citing it as a nostalgic and reliable spot for good, affordable American food.
Important Note
Some customers feel the prices have increased over time, and there are mixed opinions when comparing their roast beef sandwiches to specific regional styles like North Shore beef.
"Suggests going to Roll n Roaster."
Positive"This commenter stated that Roll n Roaster is worth a wait, but it's typically no more than 10 minutes. They also mentioned the cheese fries and lemonade as a good snack for traffic."
Positive"This user mentioned Roll n Roaster as a place they occasionally wait for, noting that the wait is usually not too long, about 10 minutes maximum."
Positive"The reviewer is addicted to the cheeseburgers and orangade at RollN Roasters, noting it hasn't changed since the 80s."
Positive"RollN Roasters looks great and offers a good American experience."
Positive"RollN Roasters is suggested as a good American dining experience."
Positive"The user emphatically states Roll N Roaster is their last meal choice, hands down."
Positive"In a comparison with Salt Hank, the commenter dismisses the idea that Roll n Roaster is a similar establishment, particularly regarding pricing."
Neutral"This user stated they would frequent Roll N Roaster with their family instead of waiting in line for trendy, expensive sandwiches, preferring value and accessibility."
Positive"The user comments on the general increase in food prices, specifically mentioning that Roll n Roaster is now $9 for a roast beef sandwich but still a good option."
Neutral"This user argued that Roll N Roaster serves a $8.25 roast beef sandwich that is world-class, questioning the value of more expensive options with different bread and no side au jus."
Positive"This commenter suggested that Roll N Roaster's $8.25 roast beef sandwich should score higher than Salt Hanks on Google Maps if it's to be considered a better value."
Negative"The commenter notes that Roll'n Roaster used to be nice and cheap but has become expensive, although a $9 roast beef sandwich is still considered hard to beat."
Neutral"This commenter expresses strong positive sentiment for Roll N Roaster."
Positive"This commenter recommends Roll N Roaster, suggesting it is about a 10-minute drive from Coney Island and that it is nostalgic and fun, likely to be enjoyed by kids."
Positive"A Boston transplant expresses disappointment at not finding a North Shore beef in NYC after a year and a half, noting that Roll 'n' Roaster is the "closest" but still "very very far" from the real thing."
Negative"The commenter feels that Brooklyn roast beef, likely referring to Roll 'n' Roaster, seems "a little.. insipid" compared to the North Shore beef."
Negative"The commenter believes Roll 'n' Roaster has the "closest style of roast beef in cook and slice" to the Massachusetts North Shore beef places like Kelly's or Nick's."
Neutral"The user confirms that Roll 'n' Roaster is the closest to the North Shore beef experience and makes a "damn fine roast beef sandwich," but clarifies it's not a "3 way" (the specific NSB style)."
Positive
