TLDR
Retro 1971 institution in Sheepshead Bay famous for roast beef, signature 'cheez' sauce, and standout milkshakes. A true nostalgic American fast-food experience.
Details
An iconic Sheepshead Bay institution, this retro American spot has been serving roast beef sandwiches since 1971 [1]. While many cherish the nostalgic atmosphere and classic diner fare, opinions on the signature roast beef vary, with some finding it tender and others citing issues with texture and flavor [2], [3]. Beyond the main event, the menu offers various American comfort foods and acclaimed milkshakes [4], [5].
Food Overview
This institution specializes in fast-food style roast beef sandwiches, frequently customized with their signature 'cheez' sauce [1], [2]. While the cottage fries with 'cheez' and milkshakes are highly regarded by many patrons [5], [6], the roast beef itself is polarizing, with reports ranging from tender to dry and stringy [3]. Pizza is explicitly not recommended [2].
Caveats
Some diners have reported that the roast beef can be inconsistent, sometimes arriving dry, stringy, or chewy [3]. Additionally, visitors should be aware that some users have noted issues with stale bread [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ROLL-N-ROASTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Red Hook Tavern Burger Overhyped Steak Tartare
"Often cited for its specific cottage fries and cheez toppings, with strong nostalgia."
PositiveFrom post: Best Diners In Nyc Preferably Old School Style
"Recommended."
PositiveFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user criticizes the restaurant, calling it local fast food slop."
NegativeFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user agrees the beef was stringy and nearly inedible, and notes the turkey is superior."
NegativeFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user notes that their recent experiences have not been great, specifically citing chewy roast beef."
Negative