Iconic Brooklyn spot for legendary roast beef sandwiches and a nostalgic dining experience.
Roll-N-Roaster is a beloved Brooklyn institution that has been serving its legendary roast beef sandwiches since 1971. These sandwiches, featuring thinly sliced beef on kaiser rolls and often topped with a distinctive 'cheez' sauce, are celebrated for their classic taste and affordability. It's a nostalgic spot that offers a great value, making it a go-to for many.
The restaurant is renowned for its roast beef sandwiches, particularly the $8.45 version served on kaiser rolls with a signature 'cheez' sauce. While many consider it a classic and a great value, some find it to be an
"The standout recommendation is the roast beef sandwich, particularly with the signature 'cheez' sauce. The cheezeburger and corn fritters are also mentioned positively."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Roll-N-Roaster, often recalling nostalgic experiences and praising the value and taste of their roast beef sandwiches.
Important Note
While generally praised for value, some customers note that prices have increased, though the $9 roast beef sandwich is still considered a good deal by many. There's also a discussion about its similarity to, or deviation from, the authentic North Shore beef sandwich.
"In a comparison with Salt Hank, the commenter dismisses the idea that Roll n Roaster is a similar establishment, particularly regarding pricing."
Neutral"This user stated they would frequent Roll N Roaster with their family instead of waiting in line for trendy, expensive sandwiches, preferring value and accessibility."
Positive"The user comments on the general increase in food prices, specifically mentioning that Roll n Roaster is now $9 for a roast beef sandwich but still a good option."
Neutral"This user argued that Roll N Roaster serves a $8.25 roast beef sandwich that is world-class, questioning the value of more expensive options with different bread and no side au jus."
Positive"This commenter suggested that Roll N Roaster's $8.25 roast beef sandwich should score higher than Salt Hanks on Google Maps if it's to be considered a better value."
Negative"The commenter notes that Roll'n Roaster used to be nice and cheap but has become expensive, although a $9 roast beef sandwich is still considered hard to beat."
Neutral"This commenter expresses strong positive sentiment for Roll N Roaster."
Positive"This commenter recommends Roll N Roaster, suggesting it is about a 10-minute drive from Coney Island and that it is nostalgic and fun, likely to be enjoyed by kids."
Positive"A Boston transplant expresses disappointment at not finding a North Shore beef in NYC after a year and a half, noting that Roll 'n' Roaster is the "closest" but still "very very far" from the real thing."
Negative"The commenter feels that Brooklyn roast beef, likely referring to Roll 'n' Roaster, seems "a little.. insipid" compared to the North Shore beef."
Negative"The commenter believes Roll 'n' Roaster has the "closest style of roast beef in cook and slice" to the Massachusetts North Shore beef places like Kelly's or Nick's."
Neutral"The user confirms that Roll 'n' Roaster is the closest to the North Shore beef experience and makes a "damn fine roast beef sandwich," but clarifies it's not a "3 way" (the specific NSB style)."
Positive"While acknowledging Roll 'n' Roaster is "good," the commenter states it's "nothing at all like a North Shore beef.""
Neutral"The commenter suggests Roll 'n' Roaster as the nearest analogue to a North Shore beef sandwich in NYC, though notes it's "not really the same.""
Neutral"Roll 'n' Roaster is mentioned as the closest option for a North Shore beef, and the commenter considers it "worth the trip.""
Positive"Roll N' Roaster in Sheepshead Bay is recommended as an off-the-beaten-path spot worth visiting."
Neutral"Suggests trying corn fritters and a half unsweetened tea/half lemonade drink at Roll n Roaster, implying these are good items."
Positive"Recommends getting the cheezburger at Roll N' Roaster in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, particularly on a summer day to enjoy their orange formica atrium."
Positive"States Roll n Roaster is a classic and they loved going there as a kid, indicating a positive and nostalgic view of the restaurant."
Positive"Recommends Roll n Roaster for their roast beef sandwich and a side of choice, implying it's a good option for a meal."
Positive
