TLDR
Iconic retro diner known for legendary roast beef sandwiches & 'cheez' sauce. A must-try NYC fast-food experience that hasn't changed since the 80s.
Details
Roll-N-Roaster is a beloved Brooklyn institution, renowned for its classic American fast-food style roast beef sandwiches and retro diner ambiance. Since 1971, it has offered a nostalgic dining experience with customizable sandwiches, milkshakes, and onion rings, all served in a unique setting with chandeliers and Formica booths [1], [2]. While prices have increased, the roast beef sandwich remains a highly regarded value, especially when enhanced with their signature 'cheez' sauce [2], [3].
Food Overview
Roll N Roaster is celebrated for its fast-food style roast beef sandwiches, often praised for their value and customizable 'cheez' sauce [2], [3]. Other recommended items include milkshakes and cheese fries [2], [4]. However, pizza is explicitly not recommended [2], and while some find the roast beef exceptional, others have noted it can be dry or lacking flavor compared to other local establishments [5].
Caveats
One user noted that the bread at Roll n Roaster tends to go stale [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ROLL-N-ROASTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user stated that Roll-n-Roaster's vanilla milkshake is the best in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user had a really good B&W milkshake at Roll-n-Roasters over the weekend."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Rock n Roaster is mentioned as a place people go on beach days, along with L&B."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Comparing Rock n Roaster to Brennan & Carr, the commenter found RnR's roast beef to be nice and tender but lacking flavor and seasoning in the gravy. They preferred Brennan & Carr."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"The commenter prefers Rock n Roaster for its simplicity, noting it's usually just bread, slices of beef, and a bit of sauce. They also like their wings without sauce. Brennan and Carr is described as saltier, and John Deli as different but good."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Rock n Roaster is described as a beloved local fast food joint, worth trying once but not necessarily a reason to go out of the way. The commenter found the roast beef dry and lacking flavor in broth, and preferred John Deli."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"One commenter simply stated that Roll n Roaster is better than Brennan and Carr."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"After a visit to Brennan and Carr, the commenter considered trying Rock N Roller for comparison."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"The roast beef sandwich from Roll n Roaster is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Where Is The Best Nyc French Dip
"Roll n Roaster is suggested as a contender in the discussion for best French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favorite On The Way Spot
"This commenter criticizes Roll n Roaster, stating that their bread goes stale."
NegativeFrom post: Your Favorite On The Way Spot
"During the summer, the commenter stops at Roll n Roaster in Sheepshead Bay on their bike route from Williamsburg to Jacob Riis beach, noting they offer free water with a bike helmet."
PositiveFrom post: Im Looking For The Cheesiest Cheeseburger In Nyc
"Recommended for its 'cheez' option, suggesting to ask for extra cheese to make the burger very cheesy."
PositiveFrom post: French Dip Or Roast Beef Recommendations In
"This user stated they prefer orangeade."
NeutralFrom post: French Dip Or Roast Beef Recommendations In
"This user mentioned enjoying cheese fries and lemonade from Roll N Roaster, even while sitting in traffic."
PositiveFrom post: French Dip Or Roast Beef Recommendations In
"This user suggested going to Roll N Roaster and eating the food on a bench with a view of the bay."
PositiveFrom post: Gushing Positivity Post
"The commenter mentions enjoying cheese fries and burgers at Roll N Roaster as part of a trip that included visiting farmers markets."
PositiveFrom post: Nonchain Birthday Freebies
"This establishment was mentioned as a potential location for birthday freebies. No specific details about the freebie were provided."
NeutralFrom post: I Put The Nyts 57 Best Nyc Sandwiches Into A
"The commenter expressed excitement that Roll N Roaster was mentioned in the list."
PositiveFrom post: Roast Beef Sandwich Like Cussers In Boston No
"This establishment is suggested as another option for good roast beef sandwiches."
Positive