TLDR
Iconic double-dipped roast beef sammie, drenched in au jus. A messy, brothy behemoth that's a true NYC institution.
Details
A Brooklyn institution, Brennan & Carr is renowned for its iconic double-dipped roast beef sandwich, drenched in au jus [1]. While some find it to be an overrated or simply okay sandwich, many praise its unique, decades-old broth and flavorful experience. It's considered a must-try for an authentic NYC roast beef experience, though debates continue comparing it to other establishments like Roll n Roaster.
Food Overview
Brennan & Carr is celebrated for its signature double-dipped roast beef sandwich, generously soaked in au jus, creating a unique and messy culinary experience. While this sandwich is a standout for many, some find it overrated. The restaurant is also mentioned for its exceptionally cheesy burgers and has been a subject of comparison with other popular roast beef and French dip spots, with opinions varying on which reigns supreme [1].
Caveats
Some recent reviews mention issues with cold meat and slow service, which contrasts with earlier positive experiences. There is also a debate about whether the roast beef sandwich is served cold or hot, with clarification that it is served hot. One user also noted that cash is required.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BRENNAN & CARR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter recommended Brennan and Carr for a sandwich, humorously noting that it's served by a waiter in a suit and tie."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Comparing a recent visit to Brennan & Carr with Roll n Roaster, the former was found to be much better. The roast beef at B&C was nice and tender, whereas RnR's lacked flavor and seasoning. The commenter plans to return to B&C on future trips to Coney Island."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A brief comment suggests a specific way to enjoy the food, 'You gotta slop it up'."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A recent visit this week was also described as terrible."
NegativeFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Comparing Brennan and Carr to Roll n Roaster and John Deli, Brennan and Carr's roast beef was noted as saltier but still good. The commenter prefers Roll n Roaster for its simplicity."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"There's a general observation that restaurants featured in the NYT series can be hit or miss, often being decent family-owned establishments."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A recent visit to Brennan and Carr was disappointing. The beef was cold and the service was very slow, despite the restaurant being nearly empty. However, previous visits had been better."
NegativeFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A visit about a month ago found the roast beef sandwich unimpressive and only fine for a one-time try. The commenter planned to try Rock N Roller in comparison."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"One commenter stated that Brennan and Carr 'sucks'."
NegativeFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"Responding to a query about cold meat, this user clarified that Brennan & Carr is an old spot, possibly propped up by nostalgia, and that the experience of cold meat is not normal but the spot is old."
NeutralFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"Brennan & Carr is praised with a crown emoji, indicating it's a top choice for French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"This user inquired if it's normal for Brennan & Carr's French Dip meat to be served cold, as they experienced this issue."
NegativeFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"Brennan & Carr is recommended for its French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"This user inquired if the request to 'delete this' for Brennan & Carr was an attempt to keep the place a secret."
NeutralFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"A user jokingly asked to 'delete this' in response to a mention of Brennan & Carr, perhaps implying it's a well-kept secret."
NeutralFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"This user states that Brennan & Carr is the 'only correct answer' for French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Wheres The Best French Dip In Brooklyn Manhattan
"Brennan & Carr is recommended as a top choice for French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"This establishment in Sheepshead Bay is mentioned as a place for a beef sandwich."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"Brennan & Carr is recommended, specifically for their double-dipped sandwich with cheese and onions."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go As Your Last Meal In Nyc
"The commenter recommends the double roast beef sandwich with cheese and extra onions, double dipped, with a side of fried onion rings and corn fritters from Brennan & Carr."
Positive