TLDR
Historic Brooklyn institution serving legendary double-dipped roast beef sandwiches since 1938. Famous for its flavorful, broth-soaked comfort food and old-school charm.
Instagram Posts References
Brennan & Carr is highlighted as a long-standing Brooklyn institution, operating from the same location since 1938. The establishment is praised for its legendary roast beef sandwiches, particularly the 'double-dipped' style, which includes cheese and onions, and is noted for its juiciness. The video also showcases their delicious blueberry pie, described as homemade and steaming, alongside fries. The restaurant's building itself is considered special and legendary, possessing a unique charm that evokes a simpler time.
Details
Since 1938, this Brooklyn institution has served as a legendary destination for American comfort food [1]. It is most famous for its signature roast beef sandwich, which is uniquely prepared by double-dipping the entire sandwich into a vat of savory au jus [2]. While the restaurant is frequently celebrated for its consistent, historic charm and tender beef [3], [4], some diners have reported inconsistent experiences with service and food temperature [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American deli fare, headlined by a roast beef sandwich that is notoriously double-dipped in au jus for maximum flavor [2]. While many diners laud the beef for being tender and flavorful [4], others find the pre-made sandwiches can arrive lukewarm [5]. The menu also features sides like corn fritters and onion rings [6], and desserts such as steaming, homemade blueberry pie served with ice cream [1].
The signature roast beef sandwich is highly recommended, especially when ordered double-dipped with cheese and onions [6], [7]. Customers also suggest pairing the sandwich with sides like fried onion rings and corn fritters [6].
Customer feedback is often divided; long-time fans praise the restaurant as a consistent, nostalgic institution [3], [4], while recent visitors have noted disappointment regarding lukewarm food and sluggish service [5].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01roast beef sandwich10 mentions
- 02roast beef4 mentions
- 03french dip3 mentions
- 04onion rings2 mentions
- 05gargiulo burger2 mentions
- 06fries2 mentions
Caveats
The restaurant is a cash-only establishment [3], and some diners find the location inconvenient or the food inconsistent in temperature [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BRENNAN & CARR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Red Hook Tavern Burger Overhyped Steak Tartare
"Known for roast beef, preferred by some over other similar establishments."
PositiveFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user explains the sandwich is pre-made and relies on gravy for heat."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user likes the restaurant for the nostalgia and the bragging rights, noting the sandwich is good but not life-changing."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user had a great tasting meal, but the bottom bun was cold."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user thought it was fine, but prefers the original roast beef."
Neutral