Iconic double-dipped roast beef sandwiches that are a messy, brothy delight. A true Brooklyn classic w/ cheese fries & onion rings.
A Brooklyn institution since 1937, Brennan & Carr is a must-visit for anyone craving an authentic roast beef sandwich experience. Their signature double-dipped sandwich, a 'brothy behemoth,' is prepared by immersing the entire sandwich in rich au jus, creating a messy yet incredibly flavorful bite. Beyond the iconic roast beef, they also offer delicious cheese fries, onion rings, and a Gargiulo burger, all served in a classic, no-frills setting.
The star of the show is the double-dipped roast beef sandwich, where the entire sandwich is soaked in au jus. Other popular items include cheese fries, onion rings, and the Gargiulo burger. While most feedback is highly positive, some note that the roast beef is served hot, not cold, and one commenter found it to be just 'okay'.
"The signature double-dipped roast beef sandwich is a must-try, along with cheese fries and onion rings. The Gargiulo burger is also frequently recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Brennan & Carr for its classic, no-frills roast beef sandwiches and delicious sides, with many considering it a must-visit institution.
Important Note
The roast beef sandwich is served hot, not cold. Some users find the trip deep into Brooklyn to be a consideration.
"This establishment in Sheepshead Bay is mentioned as a place for a beef sandwich."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is recommended, specifically for their double-dipped sandwich with cheese and onions."
Positive"The commenter recommends the double roast beef sandwich with cheese and extra onions, double dipped, with a side of fried onion rings and corn fritters from Brennan & Carr."
Positive"This commenter expresses surprise that Brennan & Carr wasn't mentioned earlier, indicating it's a highly regarded French Dip spot."
Positive"Brennan & Carr's French Dip is noted as being reasonably priced."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is recommended for French Dip."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is recommended as having the best dipped sandwich in the Tristate area."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is a Brooklyn institution that has stood the test of time and is highly recommended for French Dip. Cash is required."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is called an institution and the favorite for French Dip in all Five Boroughs, highly recommended."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is listed as one of the recommended places for French Dip."
Positive"Mentioned as a place that will 'douse it in cheese,' indicating it's a good option for a very cheesy burger."
Positive"Confirms that Brennan & Carr is a recommended spot."
Positive"Brennan & Carr is mentioned as a place with a good French Dip, though it is considered too far away by the commenter."
Positive"This user clarified that Brennan and Carr serves hot roast beef sandwiches, not French dips."
Neutral"This user shared an anecdote about traveling to Philadelphia for cheesesteaks, implying a similar dedication might be needed for Brennan and Carr."
Neutral"This user asked if traveling to Brennan and Carr is worthwhile."
Neutral"This user reacted negatively to the Arby's comparison for Brennan and Carr."
Negative"This user made a joke comparing Brennan and Carr to the original Arby's."
Negative"This user recommended Brennan and Carr in Brooklyn for an authentic NYC roast beef experience, suggesting a view of 'some Brooklynites'."
Positive"This user described Brennan and Carr as a place to go for roast beef, with a view of Nostrand Avenue, and questioned if the trip was worth it."
Neutral
