TLDR
A legendary, decades-old institution famous for its unique, "double-dipped" roast beef sandwiches that are soaked to perfection in rich au jus.
Instagram Posts References
Brennan & Carr is highlighted as a long-standing Brooklyn institution, operating from the same location since 1938. The establishment is praised for its legendary roast beef sandwiches, particularly the 'double-dipped' style, which includes cheese and onions, and is noted for its juiciness. The video also showcases their delicious blueberry pie, described as homemade and steaming, alongside fries. The restaurant's building itself is considered special and legendary, possessing a unique charm that evokes a simpler time.
Details
Since 1938, this Brooklyn institution has been serving legendary, brothy roast beef sandwiches that define old-school NYC comfort [1]. The signature experience involves a "double-dipped" sandwich that is soaked in flavorful au jus for a messy, deeply satisfying bite [1]. While many view it as a must-visit destination for an authentic experience, recent feedback has been mixed, with some diners noting inconsistencies in food temperature and service speed [2].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American comfort food, anchored by the iconic roast beef sandwich, which is often served with cheese and onions [1]. While the double-dipped roast beef is the standout favorite for many, some diners prefer it plain or have noted inconsistencies with meat temperature [2]. Recommended sides include fried onion rings and corn fritters [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BRENNAN & CARR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user explains the sandwich is pre-made and relies on gravy for heat."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user likes the restaurant for the nostalgia and the bragging rights, noting the sandwich is good but not life-changing."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user had a great tasting meal, but the bottom bun was cold."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user thought it was fine, but prefers the original roast beef."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user questions why the roast beef is often served lukewarm."
NegativeFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user feels the restaurant is overrated and prefers Roll n Roaster."
NegativeFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user describes a terrible experience with cold food, poor service, and missing items."
NegativeFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user feels the burger added to the sandwich didn't taste like much."
NegativeFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user believes the roast beef sandwich does not need a burger patty, noting that the bread is hard but softens with the au jus."
NeutralFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"The user feels the vibe is underwhelming but the sandwich is tasty and cheap."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats Kong Sihk Tong Karakatta Hamburger
"Considered a solid institution for roast beef, known for consistency in their classic sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"Listed as an old-school recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter recommended Brennan and Carr for a sandwich, humorously noting that it's served by a waiter in a suit and tie."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Comparing a recent visit to Brennan & Carr with Roll n Roaster, the former was found to be much better. The roast beef at B&C was nice and tender, whereas RnR's lacked flavor and seasoning. The commenter plans to return to B&C on future trips to Coney Island."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A brief comment suggests a specific way to enjoy the food, 'You gotta slop it up'."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A recent visit this week was also described as terrible."
NegativeFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"Comparing Brennan and Carr to Roll n Roaster and John Deli, Brennan and Carr's roast beef was noted as saltier but still good. The commenter prefers Roll n Roaster for its simplicity."
PositiveFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"There's a general observation that restaurants featured in the NYT series can be hit or miss, often being decent family-owned establishments."
NeutralFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A recent visit to Brennan and Carr was disappointing. The beef was cold and the service was very slow, despite the restaurant being nearly empty. However, previous visits had been better."
NegativeFrom post: Brennan And Carr We Do Things The Old Way Nyt
"A visit about a month ago found the roast beef sandwich unimpressive and only fine for a one-time try. The commenter planned to try Rock N Roller in comparison."
Neutral