Iconic Brooklyn seafood & red sauce Italian. Think vibrant vibes & heaping plates of calamari, baked clams, and shrimp scampi. A true taste of classic NYC.
This classic Italian-American seafood spot in Brooklyn is a long-standing favorite, often described as the 'motherland' for seafood lovers. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and generous portions, it offers a quintessential New York dining experience, particularly for those seeking red sauce Italian dishes and fresh seafood.
This restaurant specializes in Italian-American seafood, with a strong emphasis on classic dishes like fried calamari, baked clams, linguine with clam sauce, and shrimp scampi. While many rave about the quality and generous portions, some recent reviews mention a dip in consistency, making it a bit of a 'hit or miss' experience for some.
"Highly recommended dishes include the fried calamari (often noted with a spicy sauce), baked clams, linguine with clam sauce, shrimp scampi, and scungilli. Lobster fra diavolo is also mentioned as being exceptional."
Customers generally praise this restaurant for its classic Italian-American seafood and lively atmosphere, though some recent feedback suggests a decline in consistency and quality.
Important Note
Some recent customer feedback suggests that the quality and consistency of the food can be variable, with some experiences being disappointing.
"Randazzo's in Sheepshead Bay is suggested for those wanting to go on an 'expedition'."
Positive"The commenter suggested Randazzo's."
Neutral"Randazzo's in Sheepshead Bay is recommended as worth the hike for red sauce Italian."
Positive"Randazzo's in Sheepshead Bay is recommended, alongside L&B Spumoni's on-site restaurant, for red sauce Italian."
Positive"Randazzo's in Sheepshead Bay is called the 'OG' for red sauce Italian."
Positive"The lobster fra diavolo at Randazzo's is described as 'insane.'"
Positive"The user states that Randazzo's also has a great scungilli dish."
Positive"Randazzo's clam bar is listed as one of several potential recommendations for a large party."
Positive"This user recommended Randazzo's for baked clams and linguine with clam sauce, in response to a request for places similar to Don Pepe's."
Positive"In addition to the shrimp scampi, other recommended dishes at Randazzo's include baked clams, mixed seafood with hot sauce, burnt chicken, and fried zucchini."
Positive"The shrimp scampi at Randazzo's is considered top-tier by this user."
Positive"This user recommends Randazzo's Clam Bar."
Positive"Randazzo's is added to the list of potential dining options."
Positive"Randazzo's in Sheepshead Bay is mentioned as a place that visiting family members have enjoyed."
Positive"This commenter mentioned making a trek to Randazzo's for their last meal when they moved away some years ago."
Positive"This user recommended Randazzo's for its low-key Italian/seafood vibe and great food, suggesting it would be a good choice if the girlfriend enjoys such places."
Positive"This user listed Randazzo's Clam Bar as a recommendation."
Positive"This commenter simply recommends Randazzo’s located in Sheepshead Bay."
Neutral"Randazzo's was enthusiastically recommended for its fried calamari."
Positive"Randazzo's in Sheepshead Bay was recommended for its fried calamari."
Positive
