TLDR
Prized for its bagels. A go-to for breakfast, known for fluffy textures & great spreads. A solid choice if the bagel is your priority.
Instagram Posts References
The user had breakfast at Bagel Pub, a first-time visit, and was delighted with their choices. They started with an 'excellent' iced coffee. For bagels, they ordered a pumpernickel bagel with scallion cream cheese and a salt bagel featuring bacon, egg, cheese, and avocado. Both bagels were described as 'fluffy', and the bacon in the sandwich was noted for its crispiness. The user thoroughly enjoyed both items.
Bagel Pub provides gluten-free bagel options and is noted for its cozy seating, offering a comfortable environment for customers.
Details
This bagel shop is a beloved spot for those prioritizing a great bagel. While some find the fillings or overall experience 'middle of the road,' the bagels themselves are frequently praised for their quality and texture. It's a go-to for many looking for a solid breakfast or a satisfying bagel sandwich.
Food Overview
The bagels are the star here, with many praising their fluffy texture and quality. Specific mentions include the 'Super Nova' limited edition bagel, which was a hit. While the bagels themselves are highly regarded, one comment suggested the BEC ingredients were 'super middle of the road.' Spreads and salmon are also noted as excellent.
Caveats
One user had a negative experience, noting the interior was 'wasn't that nice' and didn't match their memory. Another comment suggested the BEC ingredients were 'super middle of the road,' implying the focus should be solely on the bagel itself.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BAGEL PUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"This user had a negative experience with Bagel Pub, stating they hated them."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"This user believes Bagel Pub is underrated."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"This commenter was impressed by Bagel Pub bagels they tried at an event and plans to try them again."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"This user states that Bagel Pub is the best bagel shop in the city, in their opinion."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"This commenter suggests the Bagel Pub as a good option that is not far from Tompkins Square Bagels, though they are unsure about delivery."
PositiveFrom post: Rent Out Bagel Spot For Brunch Nyc
"Bagel pub in Park Slope was suggested, with the user wondering if they might rent out their backyard space for an event."
NeutralFrom post: What Is That One Bagel Place With Like 40
"This commenter briefly suggested Bagel Pub."
NeutralFrom post: Croissant Or Bagel Recommendations Not In Lower
"Bagel Pub is listed as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: 60 Hours In Nyc V 012026
"The author reiterated that Bagel Pub is excellent, particularly praising their spreads and salmon, even though they prefer the bread texture of Apollo bagels."
PositiveFrom post: 60 Hours In Nyc V 012026
"This commenter stated that Bagel Pub is 'so fucking good'."
PositiveFrom post: 60 Hours In Nyc V 012026
"The author tried the 'Super Nova' limited edition bagel and loved it, declaring it their favorite overall bagel. However, they prefer the bread of Apollo bagels."
PositiveFrom post: Need Help Finding This Bagel Shop
"The original poster jeda18 stated that "the bagel pub" is not the place they were looking for, noting it "wasn't that nice inside" and its interior did not match their memory."
NegativeFrom post: Need Help Finding This Bagel Shop
"User calebnf suggested "the bagel pub on 7th Ave" as a possibility for the described bagel shop."
NeutralFrom post: Moved To Greenwich Village Need Suggestions For
"Bagel Pub was recommended as the commenter's "favorite bagels in the area," indicating high satisfaction with their bagel offerings."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Current Go To Breakfast Spot In Nyc
"This establishment is listed as a go-to breakfast spot, along with Terrace Diner."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc With My 8yearold Looking For The Best
"This establishment is recommended for bagels, particularly due to its seating availability and less waiting time, which is beneficial for families with children."
PositiveFrom post: Really Sorry For The Dumb Question
"This user suggests trying Bagel Pub for a BEC bagel, especially if the bagel itself is the priority over the BEC ingredients. They describe the bagels as "super middle of the road.""
Neutral