Next.js logo

OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW

Updated

Phone: (716) 208-5003

Address: 66 MADISON AVENUE 10016

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Best cheesesteaks in NYC? This spot's got Philly flavor & authentic sandwiches. A must-try for a true taste of PA.

Reddit Sentiment for OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW(based on 4 Reddit opinions)

75% Positive25% Neutral

Tags

american 4philly 2cheesesteak 3View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

This Manhattan spot offers a taste of Philadelphia with its highly-regarded cheesesteaks and other classic sandwiches. Reviewers rave about the authentic flavors and quality ingredients, making it a standout choice for those craving a true Philly experience. From their signature cheesesteaks to roasted pork sandwiches, the food is consistently praised for its deliciousness.

Food Overview

This restaurant is celebrated for its authentic cheesesteaks, with many considering it the best in NYC. Other popular items include roasted pork sandwiches. The food is consistently praised for its flavor and quality, making it a top choice for classic Philly fare.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers highly recommend the cheesesteaks and roasted pork sandwiches."

Customer Sentiment

Customers highly recommend this restaurant, frequently praising it as the best cheesesteak spot they've found in NYC. Feedback highlights the authentic flavors and quality of their sandwiches.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW

Best Philly-cheese steak spots?
A commenter identifies this restaurant as the best cheesesteak spot they've found in NYC, noting its convenient location and delivery service.
Philly folk where the hoagies at?
This commenter specifically recommends the restaurant for both its cheesesteak and roasted pork sandwiches.
Soft pretzel near Penn Station?
In a discussion about pretzels, this restaurant is suggested as a place to get a Philly-style pretzel, with a suggestion to add cheese whiz.
Grown man with the palate of a 9 year old
A commenter recommends this restaurant as a good option if someone likes cheesesteaks.
Best Philly-cheese steak spots?
In a comparison of cheesesteak spots, this restaurant's offerings were ranked as equal to another popular spot and superior to a third.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Soft Pretzel Near Penn Station

"This commenter suggests getting the Philly pretzel from Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew and adding cheese whiz."

Positive
May 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Soft Pretzel Near Penn Station

"The commenter believes Philly-style pretzels are doughier than German ones and travel well, suggesting Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew. They also mention Zaro's Bakery in Penn Station as a potentially better option for pretzels than the German restaurant."

Neutral
May 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Soft Pretzel Near Penn Station

"This commenter expresses a strong desire to help the original poster find the best pretzel, even offering to try both mentioned options personally."

Positive
May 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Philly Folk Where The Hoagies At

"This commenter recommends Olde City Cheesesteaks for their cheesesteak and roasted pork sandwiches."

Positive
Sep 21, 2025View Comment →