TLDR
Authentic SoCal-style burritos and tacos in the heart of Chelsea. Chewy flour tortillas and a killer salsa bar make this a go-to for generous, flavor-packed street food.
Reddit Sentiment for TAQUERIA BY EL PRIETO NYC(based on 8 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Taqueria by El Prieto is highlighted as a go-to spot in NYC for authentic Mexican street food. The restaurant offers a wide array of flavorful dishes, from various tacos like fish and al pastor, to cheesy quesadillas and hearty burritos. Patrons can enjoy options like guacamole, chips, and various salsas, along with custom-made tortas, mulitas, and tostadas. The vibrant atmosphere with neon signs and a counter-service setup reflects a casual and inviting dining experience. The menu features items such as Breakfast Burritos, Tacos (Asada, Chorizo, Chicken, Mushroom, Cactus, Shrimp), Tortas, Quesadillas, Mulitas, Tostadas, Burritos, and Fries, with diverse drink options including Horchata and Jamaica. The pricing is noted as being affordable, encouraging customers to try multiple items without overspending.
Taqueria By El Prieto is highlighted for its broad appeal, offering a variety of Mexican dishes such as burritos, tortas, loaded fries, and quesadillas. The chorizo breakfast burrito is particularly noted for being simple, tasty, and affordable at $6.10, making it an ideal all-day option. The restaurant boasts a vast and delicious salsa bar with options ranging from mildly spicy to very spicy. Among the recommended items is an off-menu shrimp taco, which the reviewer highly favors. Other mentioned dishes include chicken loaded fries and an adobada quesadilla, underscoring the restaurant's diverse offerings.
Will Hartman reviews Taqueria By El Prieto, a San Diego-based taqueria, finding their burritos and quesadillas to be the standout items. While tacos are criticized for too much guacamole, the reviewer suggests it's a solid lunch option in Chelsea.
Details
Bringing a slice of Southern California to Manhattan, this spot specializes in chewy flour tortillas and bold Mexican street food [1]. While it serves as a reliable lunch option with a vibrant atmosphere, some critics suggest the hype may occasionally outweigh the reality of the experience [1]. Diners can expect generous portions [7] and a standout salsa and pickle bar that enhances the meal [1].
Food Overview
The menu highlights diverse Mexican staples, including highly recommended pork adobada burritos [1], flavorful fish tacos [2], and cheesy quesadillas [1], [2]. While the torta is praised for its soft bread and juicy meat [1], the carne asada fries often fall short due to issues with ingredient quality [1], [4]. Customers also rave about the vast, flavorful salsa bar [3], which provides a necessary acidic balance to the heartier dishes [1].
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is mixed to positive, with many diners appreciating the generous portions [7] and authentic taste reminiscent of San Diego [4]. However, some visitors find certain items inconsistent, specifically noting concerns about soggy fries [4] or overly heavy toppings on tacos [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TAQUERIA BY EL PRIETO NYC
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Tacos From A Tijuanaborn Owner With La Roots Is
"The commenter identifies this establishment as offering generous portion sizes compared to others in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Is There Anywhere In The City Where Carne Asada
"This user recommended El Prieto on 28th St. Between 6 & 7 ave in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Is There Anywhere In The City Where Carne Asada
"This user found Taqueria by El Prieto to be disappointing and gave it a C grade at best."
NegativeFrom post: Is There Anywhere In The City Where Carne Asada
"This user stated that Taqueria by El Prieto is the only place that tastes like San Diego, as they are from there. However, they also noted that their fries can sometimes be soggy."
NeutralFrom post: Is There Anywhere In The City Where Carne Asada
"This user recommended Taqueria by El Prieto."
Positive