CICCI DI CARNE/ELECTRIC PIZZA/PLANT NATION
Updated
Phone: (917) 387-6803
Address: 450 WEST 33 STREET 10001
TLDR
Masterful live-fire Italian cooking meets housemade pasta in a lively, upscale setting. Perfect for those seeking high-quality, market-driven flavors.
Reddit Sentiment for CICCI DI CARNE/ELECTRIC PIZZA/PLANT NATION(based on 78 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The author considers Cisiamo NYC to be one of the city's standout Italian restaurants. They specifically praise the caramelized onion torta, calling it one of the best starters in NYC, with a rich, sweet, and savory flavor profile that is worth ordering every time. The steak was cooked to perfection, and the focaccia was described as impossible to stop eating. The overall dining experience at Cisiamo NYC is highly recommended, with the author planning a return visit.
Ci Siamo is an Italian restaurant located in Manhattan West, emphasizing live-fire cooking and seasonal ingredients. The menu offers a range of Italian dishes, including Rigatoni Alla Gricia and grilled whole trout, showcasing a commitment to fresh, market-sourced components. The restaurant aims to provide a memorable dining experience with its authentic Italian flavors.
Ci Siamo, translating to "Here we are" in Italian, is a highly acclaimed restaurant in New York City. It has received recognition from the Michelin Guide, was listed among The New York Times' Top 100 NYC Restaurants in 2026, and was named Yelp’s #1 Place to Eat in the United States in 2026. The restaurant specializes in live-fire Italian cooking, helmed by James Beard Award nominee Chef Hillary Sterling. The post details a lunch experience with friends, featuring ordered dishes like house focaccia with tomato conserva, escarole with parmigiano, mint & sunchokes, and prosciutto ravioli with zucchini & goat cheese.
Ci Siamo was a featured restaurant for the Food Education Fund's Dine Out program, where students gain practical insights into the restaurant industry. The program connects students with various culinary leaders and environments.
This image shows a selection of cocktails and a menu at 'ci siamo'. The presence of a martini and other drinks suggests a bar or restaurant with a focus on beverages.
Ci Siamo is praised for serving really good Italian food in Manhattan. While reservations can be tough to get a few days in advance, planning a week ahead usually works out. The restaurant specializes in housemade pastas and live-fire cooking, with both the pastas and desserts receiving high marks. A unique perk is the complimentary wine offered in the elevator when heading to the second floor. Overall, it's described as a large and beautiful dining establishment.
Details
Ci Siamo, a critically acclaimed destination helmed by Chef Hillary Sterling, brings elevated live-fire Italian cooking to the heart of Manhattan West [4]. Recognized on the New York Times Top 100 list [1], this spacious establishment offers an impressive menu focused on seasonal ingredients and housemade pastas [3], [5]. While many guests rave about the high-quality cuisine, some diners note that the large, vibrant dining room can become quite loud during peak hours [6], [7].
Food Overview
The menu specializes in authentic Italian flavors, with a strong focus on live-fire techniques and seasonal produce [5]. Standout hits include the highly-praised caramelized onion torta [8], [12], housemade pastas like crab cavatelli [9], [13], and expertly cooked steak [12]. While largely beloved, some diners have reported occasional issues with seasoning, such as dishes being overly salty [14].
Caveats
The restaurant is frequently described as very noisy [6], [7], and the large, modern space may feel impersonal to guests looking for a more intimate dining experience [11].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CICCI DI CARNE/ELECTRIC PIZZA/PLANT NATION
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Balthazar Or Ci Siamo Which Restaurant Should We
"Recommends visiting Ci Siamo specifically for dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Balthazar Or Ci Siamo Which Restaurant Should We
"Praised for excellent service and a standout pasta dish."
PositiveFrom post: Balthazar Or Ci Siamo Which Restaurant Should We
"Considered significantly better than Balthazar."
PositiveFrom post: Balthazar Or Ci Siamo Which Restaurant Should We
"Praises the food as delicious, though notes that it can be crowded and reservations are often necessary."
PositiveFrom post: Balthazar Or Ci Siamo Which Restaurant Should We
"Highly recommended for those who prefer Italian cuisine."
Positive