Next.js logo

TALL POPPY

Updated

Phone: (347) 206-1571

Address: 156 WEST 20 STREET 10011

TLDR

Innovative Chelsea bakery specializing in expertly crafted, laminated pastries and creative, rotating monthly flavor specials.

Reddit Sentiment for TALL POPPY(based on 30 Reddit opinions)

90% Positive7% Neutral3% Negative

Tags

american 6bakery 6french 2croissant 9cinnamon roll 9dessert 6View All

Neighborhoods

Chelsea

Instagram Posts References

The post highlights Tall Poppy NYC, a bakery in New York City. The author raves about their Pandan Coconut Roll, describing its texture as thick, buttery, and soft, with a flavorful pandan filling and sweet coconut frosting. The bakery is presented as a quaint shop located between apartment buildings, with the author recommending it for its delectable rolls and monthly specials.

The post features an in-depth review of Tall Poppy's brown butter chocolate chip cookie, which the reviewer declares a strong contender in her NYC chocolate chip cookie hunt. She notes its unique thick, cookie-cup-like appearance and highlights the generous sprinkling of flaky sea salt. The reviewer describes the cookie's texture as having a crackly sugar crust with a very doughy center, comparing its structure to a desirable mix of other notable cookies like The Petit Chou and Culture Espresso. She particularly appreciates the 'hollowed out edges' for adding textural dimension and keeping it light despite its richness. The flavor profile is lauded for its warm, nutty vanilla notes from the brown butter, which she finds perfectly complemented by the salt. She rates the cookie 4.92/5 and explicitly states that Tall Poppy is her 'favorite bakery in the city.'

The post highlights Tall Poppy NYC's new monthly menu, featuring three innovative croissant specials. The reviewer expresses strong enthusiasm for each item, praising the unique flavor combinations and execution. She notes the perfectly jammy egg in the Chilaquiles croissant, the successful savory combination of the Peach, Brie, and Prosciutto croissant, and the brilliant integration of almond frangipane and jam in the Italian Rainbow Cookie croissant. The cafe is identified as the reviewer's favorite bakery.

Tall Poppy is a bakery that received a visit from the post's author, who helped prepare some of their coconut pandan buns. The author highly praises the collaboration and the exceptional talent behind creating this unique and delicious flavor combination.

This post is a enthusiastic endorsement of Tall Poppy NYC, highlighting it as the reviewer's 'favorite bakery' and showcasing two of its standout pastries: the Pandan Coconut Bun and the Sugar Cookie Almond Croissant. The video takes viewers behind the scenes, demonstrating the meticulous process of crafting the Pandan Coconut Bun, which involves preparing a long sheet of laminated dough, spreading a vibrant green pandan mixture, rolling it, and then cutting it into individual buns. The reviewer expresses immense satisfaction with the bun's texture—tender on the inside and flaky on the outside—and its tropical, warm, and sweet flavor profile, enhanced by a pandan coconut cream cheese frosting. The Sugar Cookie Almond Croissant is also featured, depicted as a visually appealing treat adorned with colorful sprinkles and a rich filling. The overall sentiment towards the bakery and its offerings is overwhelmingly positive, emphasizing the quality and unique flavors.

Tall Poppy, known for its monthly specials, created a mango sticky rice bun that was deemed exceptional. This pastry ingeniously incorporated an entire serving of sticky rice inside a croissant, making it a standout item that 'tops the charts.'

Tall Poppy NYC is collaborating on an exclusive Easter weekend special: a Cadbury Egg Sugar Cookie Almond Croissant. This unique pastry takes their standard sugar cookie almond croissant and loads it with Cadbury eggs and vibrant rainbow sprinkles, making it a festive treat available only from Friday to Monday for Easter. The creator expresses immense satisfaction with the dessert, highlighting the perfect balance of almond and sweet flavors and the joy of the seasonal additions. They also mention that Tall Poppy has a new menu for April, encouraging patrons to visit and explore their offerings.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Tall Poppy
very positive

Bryan Kim reviews Tall Poppy, a Chelsea bakery specializing in expertly puffy croissants with unique fillings, and praises their stand-out plain croissants.

Bryan Kim • Apr 29, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
New York City’s Cinnamon Roll Renaissance

Willa Moore • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Located in Chelsea, this bakery and cafe is celebrated for its expert craftsmanship and innovative approach to laminated pastries [1]. The menu features a rotating selection of creative, limited-edition items that frequently garner enthusiastic recommendations from locals [2], [3]. While most offerings are highly praised for their texture and flavor, some diners find the cinnamon rolls slightly drier compared to mass-market alternatives [4].

Food Overview

This bakery is renowned for its high-quality laminated dough, which is used in a variety of traditional and inventive items [1], [4]. Standout offerings include a brown butter chocolate chip cookie [7], a unique cinnamon roll made with croissant scraps [8], and seasonal croissants featuring creative fillings like pistachio and goat cheese or savory combinations like peach, brie, and prosciutto [1], [3].

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally express high enthusiasm for the quality of the pastries, frequently citing the bakery as a favorite in the city [3], [5]. While the feedback is overwhelmingly positive, there are occasional minor critiques regarding texture consistency [6].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    mango sticky rice bun
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About TALL POPPY

This post discusses the bakery's rotation of unique savory items, including a shakshuka croissant.
A user raves about the brown butter chocolate chip cookie, calling it potentially the best they have had.
A detailed discussion on the bakery's unique, laminated-dough approach to the cinnamon roll.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For The Absolute Best Croissant In Nyc

"Generally well-regarded, though some users note inconsistency in texture."

Positive
Aug 24, 2026View Comment →

From post: Iso Cinnamon Roll Near Murray Hill For My Birthday

"Suggested as a possibility for cinnamon rolls if the location is considered a reasonable walk."

Positive
Jul 24, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would

"The user with a major sweet tooth finds Tall Poppy hits the mark."

Positive
Jul 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Food Ideas For My 6 Yr Old Me Mostly In Manhattan

"Recommended for having some of the best laminated pastries and a fun, rotating monthly menu."

Positive
Jun 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All

"This user found Tall Poppy's cinnamon roll to be drier than Cinnabon."

Negative
Jun 22, 2026View Comment →

Often mentioned with Tall Poppy

More in Chelsea

See all

More American in NYC

See all