Next.js logo

THE ASTARITA

Updated

Phone: (718) 306-8289

Address: 797 5 AVENUE 11232

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Brooklyn's beloved neighborhood pizzeria, a true gem with standout pizza. Enjoyed best in good weather, thanks to ample outdoor seating.

Reddit Sentiment for THE ASTARITA(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

100% Positive

Tags

italian 5pizza 2pizza 5View All

Neighborhoods

Sunset Park

Details

This Brooklyn pizzeria is a neighborhood gem, consistently praised for its quality pizza. It's a spot that locals would deeply miss if they moved away, highlighting its strong community connection and reliable deliciousness. The restaurant is particularly enjoyable during pleasant weather, with an expanded outdoor seating area adding to its appeal.

Food Overview

This establishment is highly recommended for its pizza. It's considered a top-tier spot that holds its own among other respected pizzerias in the city.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers consistently praise the pizza, indicating it's the standout dish and a primary reason for visiting."

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly recommend this pizzeria, praising it as a neighborhood gem and a reliable spot for excellent pizza.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE ASTARITA

if you could only pick one restaurant in NYC what would it be?
This user describes the restaurant as a neighborhood gem that they would truly miss if they moved, indicating a high level of satisfaction and loyalty.
how does takeout work at Lucali?
The restaurant is highlighted as an under-the-radar spot that is especially enjoyable to visit during nice weather, with an increase in outdoor seating.
Outdoor pizza spot?
This comment suggests the restaurant as a solid pizza option, noting its location opposite Green-wood Cemetery.
Besides Corner Store, what's the hottest vibe?
The restaurant is mentioned as a strong contender in the pizza scene, capable of competing with other well-regarded pizza places.
how does takeout work at Lucali?
This comment suggests the restaurant as a good option, placing it in the same category as another noted pizzeria.
favorite sit-in restaurant? (only pizza spots for me)
The user recommends this restaurant as one of several excellent pizza spots in Brooklyn.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: How Does Takeout Work At Lucali

"The user expressed strong affection for asarita, describing it as under-the-radar and particularly enjoyable in nice weather due to increased outdoor seating."

Positive
May 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Does Takeout Work At Lucali

"The user suggested asarita as a good option, alongside F&F Pizzeria."

Positive
May 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: If You Could Only Pick One Restaurant In Nyc What

"The user recommends Astarita as a neighborhood gem that they would miss dearly if they moved."

Positive
Sep 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: If You Could Only Pick One Restaurant In Nyc What

"The user recommends Astarita as a neighborhood gem they would miss if they moved."

Positive
Sep 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Besides Corner Store Whats The Hottest Vibe

"Astarita in Sunset Park is mentioned as holding its own when it comes to pizza quality, alongside Luigi's and Giuseppina's."

Positive
Jun 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Outdoor Pizza Spot

"Astarita, located opposite Green-wood Cemetery, is suggested as a pizza spot."

Positive
May 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Favorite Sitin Restaurant Only Pizza Spots For

"The user recommends Astarita, along with Wheated and Ogliastro, all located in Brooklyn."

Positive
May 15, 2025View Comment →