Authentic Buffalo grub, incl. top-rated wings & classic beef on weck. A must-try for upstate NY flavor.
This Park Slope establishment is a haven for authentic Buffalo-style fare, specializing in dishes like the classic beef on weck sandwich. Beyond sandwiches, it's lauded for its exceptional chicken wings, often cited as some of the best in NYC. Reviewers consistently praise the quality and authenticity of the food, making it a must-visit for those craving a taste of upstate New York.
This restaurant excels in serving authentic upstate and western New York specialties. It is frequently lauded for its exceptional chicken wings, with multiple mentions of them being among the best in NYC. The beef on weck sandwich is also a standout item, drawing praise for its authenticity. One reviewer, however, found the roast beef sandwich to be mediocre, citing issues with the meat preparation and roll.
"The restaurant is highly recommended for its authentic Buffalo-style chicken wings and its classic beef on weck sandwich, both considered standout dishes."
Customers overwhelmingly recommend this spot, highlighting its authentic Buffalo-style offerings, particularly its highly-rated chicken wings and beef on weck sandwiches. While most feedback is positive, one user noted a less-than-ideal experience with the roast beef sandwich.
Important Note
One reviewer found the roast beef sandwich to be mediocre, citing issues with the meat preparation and roll.
"This user recommended Bonnie's Grill in Brooklyn as a place to get chicken wings."
Positive"Following up on a previous review, this user asked if the roast beef at Bonnie's Grill is typically thick and gray, which would indicate it's prepared in a traditional Buffalo style, even if not to their preference."
Neutral"In response to a negative review, this user expressed that their Buffalo-native friend loves Bonnie's Grill and suggested the quality might have changed."
Neutral"This user tried Bonnie's Grill based on a recommendation but found the roast beef sandwich to be mediocre, stating the meat was not rare, not thinly sliced, and the roll was stale."
Negative"This user recommended Bonnie's Grill in Park Slope for a legitimate beef on weck, based on a recommendation from a friend who is from Buffalo."
Positive"Bonnie's Grill is recommended for its really legit wings and various upstate/western NY sandwiches."
Positive"This commenter emphatically recommends Bonnie's Grill in Park Slope, calling it 'incredible' and reiterating that it's worth the drive."
Positive"The original poster stated that Bonnie's Grill has been on their list for a while and they need to make the trip over to try it."
Neutral"This restaurant is listed as one of the best in NYC for wings, alongside Dan and John's and Wingbar. It's also noted for serving authentic upstate/western NY sandwiches."
Positive"Agrees that Bonnie's Grill is a wonderful place with good food."
Positive"Mentions Bonnie's (Korean wings) as one of their favorites."
Positive"Highly recommends Bonnie's Grill in Park Slope, stating it's the best and everything there is good."
Positive"Bonnie's Grill in Park Slope is highly recommended as the best place, with all food being good."
Positive"Bonnie’s Grill is full-on Buffalo-nian and very solid."
Positive"Bonnie's Grill on 5th Ave in Park Slope sells a beef on weck sandwich."
Neutral
