NYC's go-to for unique bagels - think French toast & rainbow! Freshly made daily w/ tons of cream cheese flavors & creative sandwiches.
This East Village institution is a beloved spot for hand-rolled bagels, produced daily in thousands. They're known for a wide array of homemade cream cheese flavors and creative sandwich combinations, including a standout French toast bagel. While generally praised for their quality and unique offerings, some reviews mention higher prices and, in one instance, a report of food poisoning.
This establishment is renowned for its freshly made, hand-rolled bagels, with unique flavors like rainbow and French toast being highlighted. They offer a wide variety of homemade cream cheese flavors and are praised for their breakfast sandwich options. While most feedback is positive, one reviewer reported food poisoning from a bagel with lox, egg, and onions.
"The French toast bagel is a unique and highly recommended item. Breakfast sandwiches, particularly the BEC on a Plain Bagel, are also frequently praised for their taste and quality."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment, praising the quality and variety of bagels and cream cheese. However, some find it to be a bit expensive, and there was one report of food poisoning.
Important Note
One reviewer reported food poisoning from a specific order. Prices may be considered a bit high by some customers.
"After a night out, a commenter visited Tompkins Square Bagel looking rough and without much money. The worker kindly offered them a bagel on the house, and then provided free bagels to take home the following week."
Positive"Tompkins Square Bagels is consistently good, but expect a line and limited seating."
Positive"Tompkins Square Bagels is noted for great bagels with smear and is suggested as a good option for bagel sandwiches, though seating is limited."
Positive"Multiple locations of Tompkins Square Bagels are mentioned as being nearby, including one on 11th and 2nd, one on the northwest corner of Union Square, and the original location off Tompkins Park."
Neutral"Tompkins Square Bagels is recommended as one of the best options close to the original poster's hotel for a breakfast sandwich."
Positive"This establishment is recommended for a breakfast sandwich as an easy and tasty option near Union Square."
Positive"Tompkins Square Bagel offers unique bagel flavors like rainbow and French toast, and its Union Square location provides seating."
Positive
