Last Updated: 26 days ago
Phone: (718) 810-9857
Address: 23 EAST 17 STREET 10003
NYC's top bagel spot w/ creative flavors like rainbow & French toast bagels. Daily fresh, hand-rolled goodness & lots of cream cheese options.
This East Village institution is a haven for bagel enthusiasts, renowned for its daily hand-rolled creations and an impressive array of homemade cream cheese flavors. From classic BECs to adventurous French toast bagels, they offer a diverse menu that caters to various tastes. While generally well-regarded, be prepared for potential lines and a slightly higher price point.
The star here is the bagel, praised for being fresh, hand-rolled daily, and coming in unique flavors like rainbow and French toast. They offer a wide variety of homemade cream cheese options and popular breakfast sandwiches, like the BEC. While most feedback is positive, one reviewer reported food poisoning from a bagel with lox, egg, and onions.
"The BEC on a Plain Bagel is highly recommended with a near-perfect score. Their unique flavors like rainbow and French toast bagels, along with various breakfast sandwiches, are also popular choices."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality and variety of bagels, with many considering them the best in the city. However, some find it a bit pricey and one review mentioned a negative food poisoning experience.
Important Note
Expect lines and potentially limited seating, especially at popular times. One customer reported a negative experience with food poisoning.
"After a night out, a commenter visited Tompkins Square Bagel looking rough and without much money. The worker kindly offered them a bagel on the house, and then provided free bagels to take home the following week."
Positive"Tompkins Square Bagels is consistently good, but expect a line and limited seating."
Positive"Tompkins Square Bagels is noted for great bagels with smear and is suggested as a good option for bagel sandwiches, though seating is limited."
Positive"Multiple locations of Tompkins Square Bagels are mentioned as being nearby, including one on 11th and 2nd, one on the northwest corner of Union Square, and the original location off Tompkins Park."
Neutral"Tompkins Square Bagels is recommended as one of the best options close to the original poster's hotel for a breakfast sandwich."
Positive"This establishment is recommended for a breakfast sandwich as an easy and tasty option near Union Square."
Positive"Tompkins Square Bagel offers unique bagel flavors like rainbow and French toast, and its Union Square location provides seating."
Positive"Commenter endorses Tompkins Square Bagels as a place they would recommend to Manhattan visitors."
Positive"Visitor tried a basic BEC on a Plain bagel at Tompkins Square Bagels and found the bagel texture great and the BEC perfectly cooked (9.9/10), despite panicking with the order."
Positive"Known for their french toast bagel."
Neutral"Nice service but a bit expensive. The reviewer got food poisoning from this restaurant."
Negative"Tompkins Square Bagel , best in the city or anywhere else."
Positive
