Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (718) 810-9857
Address: 23 EAST 17 STREET 10003
NYC's top-tier bagel spot, serving hand-rolled perfection with unique cream cheese flavors. From classic BECs to sweet French toast bagels, it's a must-try.
Nestled in the heart of the East Village, Tompkins Square Bagels has earned a stellar reputation as a premier bagel destination in New York City. This beloved shop is renowned for its commitment to crafting exceptional bagels daily, with thousands of hand-rolled creations emerging from their kitchen each day. Their extensive menu boasts a wide array of homemade cream cheese flavors, perfectly complementing their signature bagels. Whether you're seeking a classic BEC on a plain bagel or adventurous flavors like the French toast bagel, the quality and taste are consistently lauded. While the majority of patrons rave about the fresh ingredients and expert preparation, it's worth noting a singular report of food poisoning and some comments about the pricing being on the higher side. Despite these minor points, Tompkins Square Bagels remains a must-visit for bagel enthusiasts.
Tompkins Square Bagels is highly regarded for its freshly made, hand-rolled bagels, with many considering them the best in NYC. The variety of homemade cream cheese flavors is a significant draw. Popular choices include the French toast bagel and the BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese) on a plain bagel, both receiving high praise for texture and preparation. While most feedback is positive, one customer reported a negative experience with food poisoning after eating a bagel with lox, egg, and onions, and some find the prices slightly elevated.
"The French toast bagel is a unique and highly recommended option. The BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese) on a plain bagel also receives high marks for its texture and preparation."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Tompkins Square Bagels, frequently praising the quality and freshness of their hand-rolled bagels. Many consider them among the best in the city. Specific call-outs include the wide variety of homemade cream cheese flavors and well-executed sandwich combinations. However, one review mentioned a negative experience with food poisoning and another noted the prices as being a bit high.
Important Note
One reviewer reported food poisoning after consuming a bagel with lox, egg, and onions. Some customers also find the prices to be slightly high.
"Tompkins Square Bagel offers unique bagel flavors like rainbow and French toast, and its Union Square location provides seating."
Positive"Commenter endorses Tompkins Square Bagels as a place they would recommend to Manhattan visitors."
Positive"Visitor tried a basic BEC on a Plain bagel at Tompkins Square Bagels and found the bagel texture great and the BEC perfectly cooked (9.9/10), despite panicking with the order."
Positive"Known for their french toast bagel."
Neutral"Nice service but a bit expensive. The reviewer got food poisoning from this restaurant."
Negative"Tompkins Square Bagel , best in the city or anywhere else."
Positive
