TLDR
Highly-rated UWS destination for elevated North Indian classics and standout kebabs, prized for its butter chicken and vibrant, casual atmosphere.
Reddit Sentiment for KEBAB AUR SHARAB(based on 29 Reddit opinions)
Details
Located on the Upper West Side, this restaurant is celebrated for its authentic, high-quality North Indian cuisine and impressive bar program [1], [5]. While many diners consistently rank it among the city's best for standout dishes like butter chicken, others find the pricing to be on the higher end [17], [27]. Although generally well-regarded for a casual yet refined dining experience, some guests have noted inconsistencies in food quality and seasoning, occasionally finding dishes to be overly salty [16], [25].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on North Indian specialties, with the butter chicken frequently cited as the best in the city and the doori kebab highlighted as a must-try [11], [27]. While many enjoy the flavorful, meat-forward offerings, some diners have reported that certain dishes can be too salty or lack the nuanced quality found at other competitive establishments [16], [19], [25].
Caveats
Some visitors have noted that the restaurant is quite expensive, and there have been isolated reports of concerns regarding food seasoning and health inspection transparency [16], [17], [18].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About KEBAB AUR SHARAB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Manhattan Indian Dinner For 10ppl Is Vatan Still
"Suggested as an option for the group dinner."
NeutralFrom post: Trying To Show My Italian Inlaws A Better Version
"Considered one of the best recent options for a wide range of tastes."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Chicken Karahi And Chicken Makhani Spots
"The user believes this spot has the best butter chicken in the city, surpassing Musaafer."
PositiveFrom post: Is Cloves Indian Any Good Visiting Newyork For
"The commenter found the food at Kebab Aur Sharab to be too salty and inquired about other places where salt is not as prominent."
NegativeFrom post: Is Cloves Indian Any Good Visiting Newyork For
"Kebab Aur Sharab is listed as one of several good Indian restaurant options in NYC."
Positive