TLDR
Exceptional North Indian fare featuring standout kebabs and widely praised butter chicken; a favored, casual UWS destination for authentic flavors.
Reddit Sentiment for KEBAB AUR SHARAB(based on 31 Reddit opinions)
Details
Located on the Upper West Side, this establishment has earned a strong reputation for its high-quality North Indian cuisine, with many diners favoring it over other local competitors [1], [2]. While it is frequently praised for its delicious food and casual atmosphere, some patrons find the pricing to be on the higher side [3], [4]. Recent experiences have been mixed, ranging from enthusiastic endorsements of their signature dishes to occasional critiques regarding seasoning and value [5], [6].
Food Overview
The restaurant is best known for its North Indian offerings, with standout mentions for its diverse kebabs, particularly the boti and doori varieties [1], [8]. The butter chicken is frequently cited as a favorite, with some customers calling it the best in the city [9], [10]. While many enjoy the menu, some visitors have found specific dishes to be overly salty or lacking the quality found at similar competitors [6], [7].
Customer Sentiment
Feedback is largely positive, with many guests praising the authentic dishes and friendly service [2], [5]. However, some diners have noted concerns regarding high price points, occasional issues with food seasoning, and inconsistent quality compared to other establishments [6], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About KEBAB AUR SHARAB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Trying To Show My Italian Inlaws A Better Version
"Considered one of the best recent options for a wide range of tastes."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Chicken Karahi And Chicken Makhani Spots
"The user believes this spot has the best butter chicken in the city, surpassing Musaafer."
PositiveFrom post: Is Cloves Indian Any Good Visiting Newyork For
"The commenter found the food at Kebab Aur Sharab to be too salty and inquired about other places where salt is not as prominent."
NegativeFrom post: Is Cloves Indian Any Good Visiting Newyork For
"Kebab Aur Sharab is listed as one of several good Indian restaurant options in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Heading To Nyc And Dont Want To Leave With Regrets
"This commenter highly recommends Kebab aur Sharab on the Upper West Side for excellent Indian food."
PositiveFrom post: Berlinstyle DöNer DüRüM In Nyc
"Kebab House on the Upper West Side is suggested as being close to the desired style, with thin wraps and legit meat."
PositiveFrom post: Best Butter Chicken In Nyc
"The commenter stated that Kebab aur sharab has amazing butter chicken and is the best they've ever had, though they admitted to not having tried many other recommended spots."
PositiveFrom post: Best Butter Chicken In Nyc
"The commenter vouched for Kebab aur sharab as a good option for butter chicken."
PositiveFrom post: Best Butter Chicken In Nyc
"Kebab aur sharab was suggested as a decent option for butter chicken."
PositiveFrom post: Kebab Aur Sharab Vs Gupshap Vs Tamarind Vs
"The commenter mentions that Kebab Aur Sharab, along with Kanyakumari, is available through InKind. They previously frequented Kebab Aur Sharab but stopped after discovering issues with their health inspection grade, citing dishonesty from a bartender about the reason for a 'pending' grade."
NegativeFrom post: Kebab Aur Sharab Vs Gupshap Vs Tamarind Vs
"The commenter was very disappointed with Kebab aur Sharab, describing its taste as bland and as expected from an Indian restaurant on the Upper West Side. They found Tamarind to be only slightly better."
NegativeFrom post: Kebab Aur Sharab Vs Gupshap Vs Tamarind Vs
"The commenter found Kebab Aur Sharab to be very good and Kanyakumari also good, though they were less convinced by it. Both are noted as being quite expensive."
PositiveFrom post: Bungalow Vs Gupshup
"The commenter mentions Kebab aur Sharab, stating that while their lamb dish was delicious, it was not of the same quality as a similar dish at Ishq and was more expensive. They also noted the staff is kind."
NeutralFrom post: Passerine Or Indian Accent For An Anniversary
"Kebab aur Sharab on the UWS is highly recommended as an underrated and favorite nicer Indian spot in NYC, with the doori kebab being a standout dish."
PositiveFrom post: Celebratory Indian Meal
"The user recommends Kabab Aur Sharab as one of their go-to Indian restaurants in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Celebratory Indian Meal
"The user seconded the recommendation for Kebab Aur Sharab, stating that the food was much better than Jazba."
PositiveFrom post: Celebratory Indian Meal
"The user simply lists Kebab Aur Sharab as a suggestion."
NeutralFrom post: Celebratory Indian Meal
"The user suggests Kebab Au Sharab as a good option for Indian cuisine."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Eat On Thanksgiving Day Non Tg Food
"Kabab or Shabab, or any Indian restaurant, is suggested as a potential option for dining on Thanksgiving."
PositiveFrom post: Has Anyone Tried Grup Shup
"This commenter agrees with the recommendation to go to Kebab Aur Sherab, viewing GupShup as an unnecessary attempt to elevate a cuisine that doesn't need it."
Positive