TLDR
Classic, juicy burgers and unique fluffy sidewinder fries at an intimate Hell's Kitchen counter. A go-to spot for affordable, late-night comfort food.
Reddit Sentiment for LOVELY'S OLD FASHIONED(based on 24 Reddit opinions)
Details
Located in the heart of Hell's Kitchen, this intimate 10-seat counter serves up classic American comfort food in a no-frills setting [2]. Visitors frequently praise the establishment for its high-quality, juicy burgers that come at an accessible price point [5], [12], [21]. Beyond the main attraction, guests can enjoy unique, wedge-like sidewinder fries that are celebrated for their fluffy texture [1], [23]. It has become a reliable staple for late-night cravings or a casual lunch in the city [1], [14], [16].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American diner fare, centered primarily around their burgers [2], [6]. The smash-style burgers are often highlighted for their juiciness [12], while the unique 'sidewinder' fries are frequently recommended for their fluffy interior and dipping capability [1], [23]. Other standout items include the patty melt, which is highly regarded among locals [22], though some feedback suggests mixed opinions on the cheese sauce and fries [12].
The burgers are the primary recommendation, with specific praise for the juicy smash-style preparation [12], [21]. Additionally, the wedge-like sidewinder fries are highly recommended for their texture [1], [23].
Overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with many locals and visitors praising the burgers as excellent, juicy, and great value [5], [12], [21]. While the vast majority of diners consider it a must-try spot, taste in specific items like fries and sauce can vary by individual preference [12], [23].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01burger3 mentions
- 02smash burger2 mentions
- 03burgers2 mentions
Caveats
The space is quite intimate with only 10 counter seats, which may lead to limited availability during peak times [1], [23].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LOVELY'S OLD FASHIONED
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Burger Thats Not On The Top Of Everyones
"The commenter describes it as one of their least favorite smash burgers in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Best Burger Thats Not On The Top Of Everyones
"Highlighted as having one of the better patty melts."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burger Thats Not On The Top Of Everyones
"Confirms the location is in Hell's Kitchen and expresses love for the spot."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burger Thats Not On The Top Of Everyones
"Praises the burgers for being excellent and affordable, noting they are open late."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burger Thats Not On The Top Of Everyones
"Mentioned as a recommended spot."
Positive