TLDR
Exquisite, high-end destination in the Fifth Avenue Hotel offering refined French-Italian cuisine within a stunning, chandelier-lit dining room.
Reddit Sentiment for THE FIFTH AVENUE HOTEL & CAFE CARMELLINI(based on 79 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The post features a birthday brunch celebration at Cafe Carmellini, described as a place the author loves to share with friends and family. The author specifically mentions having a 'caviar bump' as part of the celebration. The overall tone suggests a highly positive and memorable dining experience, fitting for a special occasion.
Café Carmellini, opened in 2023, is highlighted as the jewel in Andrew Carmellini's restaurant empire and one of the best places to eat and drink in New York City. This establishment signifies Carmellini's much-anticipated return to fine dining after two decades of success with more casual, buzzy brasseries. The chef is described as being particularly animated about a squab en croute dish he is plating there, indicating a high level of passion and dedication to the restaurant's offerings.
Café Carmellini is highlighted as the flagship fine dining establishment of Andrew Carmellini's NoHo Hospitality Group. The article touches upon Carmellini's pursuit of becoming a "really, really good cook" and his path to founding this notable restaurant.
Details
Located within the elegant Fifth Avenue Hotel, this establishment is a sophisticated, Mediterranean-influenced fine-dining destination that serves as a jewel in the chef's culinary empire [1], [2]. The restaurant is widely lauded for its exquisite, airy dining room, which features beautiful chandeliers and a design that feels both grand and surprisingly comfortable [3], [4]. Guests can expect a high level of attentive, gracious service alongside a menu that balances inventive flair with classic techniques [3], [5].
Food Overview
The kitchen offers a sophisticated, Mediterranean-influenced menu featuring French and Italian-inspired dishes [1], [5]. Standout items include the crab mille-feuille and duck tortellini [5], [6]. While most feedback is glowing, one guest noted a disappointing experience with a specialty collaboration hotdog, suggesting it lacked value [8].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended plates include the crab mille-feuille, the duck duck duck tortellini, and the chicken 'gran sasso' [5], [6], [9]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chicken(2)
- •duck duck duck tortellini(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons consistently praise the restaurant as an ideal choice for special occasions and romantic evenings, citing its beautiful design and gracious service [3], [5], [6]. While the vast majority of experiences are highly positive, some guests have noted the high price point [5], [7].
Caveats
Reservations for dinner can be difficult to secure, though the restaurant is often more accessible for lunch [6], [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE FIFTH AVENUE HOTEL & CAFE CARMELLINI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Good Dinner Recommendations With Mature Eight
"Recommended as an option for a "grown up" dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Best Dinner For Two Including Cocktailswine For
"The restaurant is recommended as part of a list of high-quality dining spots."
PositiveFrom post: Best Dinner For Two Including Cocktailswine For
"The restaurant is suggested as a potential option for the user's dinner."
NeutralFrom post: Team Dinner Near 30th And Broadway 10 People For
"This commenter mentioned Cafe Carmellini for French Italian cuisine."
PositiveFrom post: The Great Nosh A Great Waste Of Money Would Not
"The commenter purchased a $15 hotdog from Cafe Carmellini x La Boite but found it to be small and forgettable, noting that it was missing pickled shallots/veggies despite being sold at full price."
NeutralFrom post: Client Dinner Thank You Which Is Better Crane
"The commenter strongly prefers Cafe Carmellini over Crane Club."
PositiveFrom post: Making An Impression Introducing Friends To Fine
"Cafe Carmellini is nice, and the portrait bar downstairs is very fun."
PositiveFrom post: Im Bored Of Italian Food Italian Restaurant For
"Cafe Carmellini is suggested as a French-Italian option with a beautiful dining room, fitting the request for something beyond standard Italian."
PositiveFrom post: Spacious Restaurants Anywhere In Manhattan Or
"Café Carmellini is listed among suggestions for restaurants with booths, implying a more comfortable and potentially spacious seating arrangement."
NeutralFrom post: Spacious Restaurants Anywhere In Manhattan Or
"Café Carmellini is mentioned as a potentially spacious dining option, though price point might be a consideration."
NeutralFrom post: Best Italian Pasta Spot In Manhattan For Euro
"Cafe Carmellini is mentioned for its Italian-ish focus and fine dining emphasis."
PositiveFrom post: Need A Dinner Tomorrow Night For 6 W
"A user recommended Cafe Carmellini for dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Upscale Spot For Milestone Birthday Celebration
"The original poster is considering Cafe Carmellini, noting that it is located in their hotel. While they initially thought the menu was seafood-heavy, they found a 'chicken for two' dish that looks interesting. The user expressed that the restaurant looks nice."
PositiveFrom post: Upscale Spot For Milestone Birthday Celebration
"This user mentioned 'Carmellini'."
NeutralFrom post: Upscale Spot For Milestone Birthday Celebration
"This user listed Cafe Carmellini as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Swanky Dinner For Moms 70th
"This commenter seconded the recommendation for Cafe Carmellini, noting that the upstairs dining area is semi-private and overlooks the main dining room, and suggesting drinks at Portrait Bar before or after."
PositiveFrom post: Swanky Dinner For Moms 70th
"This commenter recommended Cafe Carmellini, emphasizing its luxurious interiors."
PositiveFrom post: Swanky Dinner For Moms 70th
"Cafe Carmellini was suggested as a potential venue that could accommodate a group of 11 people for a special occasion."
PositiveFrom post: Best Place To Get Fatty Tuna Toro
"This commenter had a surprisingly good chutoro appetizer at Cafe Carmellini, enjoying it so much they ordered a second as an entree, though they did not love other aspects of the meal."
PositiveFrom post: Fine Dining With Shared Couch Image Attachedvery
"Cafe Carmellini is suggested as a restaurant that provides the desired seating arrangement for a date night."
Positive