Last Updated: 3 days ago
Phone: (212) 686-5252
Address: 250 5 AVENUE 10001
Elegant French-Italian fine dining in a gorgeous hotel setting. A top pick for special occasions, boasting creative dishes and a sophisticated atmosphere.
Experience the refined elegance of Cafe Carmellini, nestled within the historic Fifth Avenue Hotel. This upscale establishment blends French and Italian culinary traditions in a sumptuous setting, perfect for special occasions. From expertly crafted seafood to rich pasta dishes, guests can expect a sophisticated dining experience.
Cafe Carmellini offers a refined blend of French and Italian cuisine, with many diners praising its sophisticated dishes and elegant presentation. Standout recommendations include the 'Risotto del Giorno', 'halibut with caviar', and 'snap pea and almond tart'. The 'Oysters à la pomme' and 'Sasso Chicken Fricassée' have received mixed reviews, with some finding the dishes unique and surprisingly good, while others found them to be just 'OK' or dry.
"Highly recommended dishes include the 'Risotto del Giorno', 'halibut with caviar', and 'snap pea and almond tart'. The 'Oysters à la pomme' are noted as an unusual but surprisingly good option."
Overall, customers have a highly positive sentiment towards Cafe Carmellini, frequently recommending it for special occasions due to its beautiful ambiance, excellent food, and sophisticated dining experience.
Important Note
One user reported terrible service, while others noted that while the space is gorgeous, the food and menu might not be exciting for everyone.
"This commenter seconding Cafe Carmellini and highly recommending its hotel bar, The Portrait Bar, for an anniversary. They describe the bar's cocktails and atmosphere as similar to Monkey Bar."
Positive"Cafe Carmellini is listed as a restaurant recommendation for the anniversary dinner."
Neutral"The user believes Café Carmellini does not deserve a spot on the mentioned list."
Negative"Cafe Carmellini is presented as an example of a restaurant offering a better ambiance than the Russian Tea Room."
Positive"The Portrait Bar is downstairs from Cafe Carmellini and offers small dishes, described as great. Cafe Carmellini itself is noted as being very beautiful if one wants to dine upstairs with a more extensive menu."
Positive"Cafe Carmellini was highly praised for its excellent food, beautiful design, and great service, described as Italian/French."
Positive"This commenter recommends Café Carmellini, highlighting its gorgeous space and lovely seasonal menu located in The Fifth Avenue Hotel."
Positive"The user found Cafe Carmellini to be beautiful and thanked the commenter for the recommendation."
Positive"Cafe Carmellini was recommended for its refined atmosphere and service, with a thoughtfully seasonal a la carte menu and elegant interior design perfect for special occasions. The commenter also suggested booking a night at The Fifth Avenue Hotel for bonus points."
Positive"The commenter believes the chicken dish at Cafe Carmellini is very good and would be suitable for bringing a child."
Positive"The commenter is planning to visit Cafe Carmellini soon and is asking for recommendations on what to order."
Neutral"This restaurant was recommended as a fine dining option for a date night in NYC."
Positive"This user agrees with the previous comment about Cafe Carmellini, noting that while the space is gorgeous, the food and menu are not exciting."
Neutral"This user found the space at Cafe Carmellini beautiful and the downstairs Portrait Bar fun, but was not impressed with the menu or food quality, stating it was just 'OK'."
Neutral"Cafe Carmellini is mentioned as a fantastic French/Italian restaurant that is à la carte only and aiming for a Michelin star, with a romantic vibe."
Positive"Cafe Carmellini is consistently excellent and compared favorably to the now-closed Del Posto."
Positive"Had a phenomenal lunch experience at Cafe Carmellini."
Positive"Cafe Carmellini is highly praised for its quality and is noted to be excellent, potentially gunning for a Michelin star."
Positive"Cafe Carmellini is suggested as a dining option."
Positive"This user found the food slightly better at Portale, but preferred the vibe at Cafe Carmellini, noting the excellent service on their wedding night and suggesting a pre-call for special notes."
Positive
