TLDR
Affordable, high-quality burger combos in Hell's Kitchen. Known for casual, low-key vibes and a local cult following.
Details
A go-to spot in Hell's Kitchen, this establishment is widely celebrated for its high-quality burgers and casual, welcoming atmosphere [12]. Diners frequently highlight the excellent value for money in a competitive Midtown location, often pairing their meals with satisfying fries [11], [15]. The community has shown strong support for the owner, frequently recommending it as a premier lunch destination [9], [11].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American classics, with burgers being the undisputed star of the show [1], [11]. Diners highly recommend the burger combos—noted for being "nice and simple" [26]—and the fries, which are frequently described as excellent [11], [21]. Other standout options include the veggie burger combo [27] and their popular ice cream, which is sometimes included in affordable meal deals [2], [24].
The classic burgers are highly recommended [11], [18], as are the fries [21]. The veggie burger combo and the occasional burger-fries-ice cream combo offer great value [24], [27].
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its delicious, consistent food and great value, often citing it as superior to other local burger spots [12], [15]. While the vast majority of feedback is positive, there is rare mention of dissatisfaction with certain menu items, though the fries are consistently lauded [21], [22].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01burger4 mentions
- 02ice cream3 mentions
Caveats
While most items receive high praise, some patrons suggest skipping the hot dogs, preferring to prepare them at home instead [15].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About Cubby's
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Hole In The Wall Restaurants In The Theatre
"A personal recommendation from the owner."
PositiveFrom post: Hello New York Realistic Food Budget Suggestions
"Recommended for their veggie burger combo."
PositiveFrom post: Things We Ate In Nyc When We Remembered To Eat A
"Burgers were ordered from Cubby's on 10th Ave in Hell's Kitchen at the end of a long day. The burgers were described as nice and simple."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burger And Fries
"This user recommended Cubby's in Manhattan, mentioning it alongside Rolo's."
PositiveFrom post: Delirious Owner Returns With A Brand New Combo
"A special offer at Cubby's includes a potential for a free scoop of ice cream with the purchase of the new combo meal."
Positive