Homey burger joint with highly praised BLTs and notable burgers, though some find portions small.
This casual eatery is a go-to spot for many seeking a satisfying burger experience, with particular praise for their BLTs and the toppings on their Cub's Pub burger. While some patrons rave about the quality and affordability, others have noted a decrease in burger size and expressed opinions on the cheese and sauce. Despite some mixed reviews, it remains a popular choice for American comfort food in the Hell's Kitchen area.
The restaurant is known for its burgers and BLTs, with some customers specifically recommending the Cub's Pub burger for its toppings and bun. However, there are recurring criticisms about the burgers potentially shrinking in size, the quality of the cheese, and the sauce on certain preparations. One user found the Sylvester smash burger lacking and not crispy enough. The BLT is specifically mentioned as being good. The restaurant also offers hot dogs, with a mention of a BOGO deal.
"The BLT is specifically mentioned as being good, and the "Cub's Pub" burger is highlighted for its toppings and bun."
Overall, customer sentiment towards this restaurant is mixed, with some praising the burgers and BLTs, while others find the burgers to be too small or are disappointed with certain aspects like the sauce or cheese. There are also comments suggesting that other burger joints in the city might be superior.
Important Note
Some customers feel the burgers have become smaller, and there are varying opinions on the quality of the cheese and sauce. Some reviews suggest that other burger places might be preferred.
"This user dismisses Cubby's as fast food."
Negative"This user criticizes the comparison of Cubby's to Minetta Tavern, calling it blasphemous."
Negative"In response to a query, the author mentions Cubby's as a place with good burgers under $20."
Neutral"The author lists Cubby's as a place with great burgers under $20."
Positive"Cubby's is mentioned as a restaurant located on 10th Avenue and 45th Street."
Neutral"Cubby's is recommended as a homey, good, and affordable burger joint in the Midtown/Times Square area."
Positive"Strongly urges the original poster to go to Cubby’s in Hell’s Kitchen."
Positive"Recommends trying Cubby’s, stating they are 'very good' even though they missed joining the Blackbird burger league."
Positive"User thinks Lovely's is way better than Cubby's."
Positive"Lovely's had too much onion and was too small for the user."
Negative"The user thinks Cubby's is pretty good."
Positive"User sometimes gets BOGO double cheeseburgers from Lovely's on UberEats."
Positive"The user thinks the place is mid but liked their BOGO hotdogs."
Neutral"The user thinks the burger looks more like a slider."
Negative"The user thinks the burgers are getting smaller."
Negative"The user thought the food (burger and shake) was good but experienced unfriendly service and a random charge."
Neutral"The user had the Sylvester smash burger, didn't love the sauce, and thought it could have been crispier."
Negative"User usually chooses Lovely's over Cubby's when in the neighborhood."
Positive"The user thinks the food doesn't look good."
Negative"User likes Cubby's more but Lovely's is closer and open later."
Neutral
