Next.js logo

QUALITY PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (917) 662-5510

Address: 888 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10001

View on Google Maps

TLDR

NY pizza w/ creative twists. Think classic pepperoni & must-try Chicken Bacon Ranch slice – a flavor bomb, though some say it's not traditional.

Reddit Sentiment for QUALITY PIZZA(based on 15 Reddit opinions)

53% Positive33% Neutral13% Negative

Tags

american 8italian 7pizza 10slice 3View All

Neighborhoods

Chelsea

Details

Experience the quintessential New York pizza slice with a twist at this popular spot. While classic pepperoni and simple slices are well-regarded, their unique Chicken Bacon Ranch slice has become a must-try, offering a creamy and flavorful alternative. Be prepared for a potentially divisive experience, as some purists argue that loaded pizzas deviate from traditional NYC style, while others embrace the innovation.

Food Overview

This establishment serves New York-style pizza, with both classic options like pepperoni and more adventurous choices such as the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice. While the Chicken Bacon Ranch is praised for its flavor and ranch, some patrons feel it's not representative of traditional NYC pizza, with others suggesting simpler slices like plain or pepperoni for a more authentic experience.

Highlights / Recommended

The Chicken Bacon Ranch slice is frequently mentioned as a must-try, offering a unique and flavorful experience. Classic pepperoni slices are also a solid choice for those seeking traditional flavors.

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally find the pizza to be good, with a particular highlight being the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice. However, there's a divide among diners regarding whether such inventive toppings align with authentic New York pizza traditions.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About QUALITY PIZZA

Everything I ate in NYC in one week! Visiting from another country!
A user shared their experience trying the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice, noting it was good, especially the ranch, but felt Bleecker Street Pizza had better sauce. Other users debated whether this type of loaded pizza is truly representative of NYC pizza.
Post-trip report! Amazing experience
A user highly praised the white slice at 'Best Pizza' (potentially referring to Quality Pizza), calling it 'bomb' and even returning for another. The discussion also touched upon its location in Williamsburg and the ease of getting a slice.
Everything I ate in NYC in one week! Visiting from another country!
One commenter advised that chicken bacon ranch slices aren't representative of good NYC pizza, suggesting plain, pepperoni, or white slices for a more authentic taste.
In your opinion where is the best pizza bianca in NYC?
In a discussion about the best pizza bianca, a commenter simply stated 'Best Pizza,' possibly referring to Quality Pizza, and another commenter noted it's incredible when fresh.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For Corporate Dinnner Locations In Midtown

"This restaurant is recommended as a good option for a corporate dinner."

Positive
Apr 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For Corporate Dinnner Locations In Midtown

"This restaurant, possibly referring to Quality Meats or Quality Italian, was suggested for a corporate dinner in midtown. It is noted for having semi-private rooms that could accommodate a group of 8-10 people."

Positive
Apr 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For The Best Ny Style Pizza In

"Lists Best Pizza as a pizza place to consider in Williamsburg before Joe's."

Positive
Sep 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Posttrip Report Amazing Experience

"The original poster confirmed Best Pizza is in Williamsburg and noted that there's no line, making it easy to get a slice and find seating."

Positive
Sep 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Posttrip Report Amazing Experience

"This user incorrectly stated that Best Pizza is owned by the same people as Roberta's."

Neutral
Sep 18, 2025View Comment →

More in Chelsea

See all

More American in NYC

See all