Last Updated: 4 months ago
Phone: (917) 662-5510
Address: 888 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10001
Nyc pizza w/ a twist; try the classic slices for authentic flavor, or branch out to creative options like chicken bacon ranch.
Experience classic New York pizza with a modern twist at this popular spot. While some find their more creative slices, like the chicken bacon ranch, to be good, traditionalists suggest sticking to the staples like pepperoni or plain for an authentic taste. It's a go-to for a satisfying slice, especially if you're in the mood for something a bit different or a well-executed classic.
This establishment offers classic New York-style pizza. While the pepperoni and plain slices are well-regarded for their authentic taste, some customers find the more loaded options, like the chicken bacon ranch slice, to be good but not necessarily representative of the quintessential NY pizza experience. Traditionalists recommend sticking to simpler preparations.
"The pepperoni slice and classic plain slices are often recommended for an authentic taste of New York pizza. However, the chicken bacon ranch slice is also mentioned positively for its unique flavor profile."
Customers generally enjoy the pizza, with a split opinion on whether to try the more adventurous toppings or stick to the traditional slices for a more authentic New York experience.
Important Note
Some users suggest that adventurous toppings might detract from the authentic New York pizza experience.
"Lists Best Pizza as a pizza place to consider in Williamsburg before Joe's."
Positive"The original poster confirmed Best Pizza is in Williamsburg and noted that there's no line, making it easy to get a slice and find seating."
Positive"This user incorrectly stated that Best Pizza is owned by the same people as Roberta's."
Neutral"This user simply responded 'Williamsburg' to a query about the location of Best Pizza."
Neutral"A user asked about the location of Best Pizza after being intrigued by the mention of their white slice."
Neutral"The user highly praised the white slice at Best Pizza, calling it 'bomb' and even returning for another slice after visiting another establishment."
Positive"This commenter expressed surprise that 'Best Pizza' isn't more hyped, calling it the greatest slice in NY."
Positive"This commenter stated that 'Best Pizza' is incredible when fresh."
Positive"This commenter simply stated "Best Pizza" likely referring to a place with that name."
Positive"This user suggests that loaded pizzas like chicken bacon ranch are more typical of suburban areas and not representative of simpler, classic NYC pizza."
Negative"This user advises that chicken bacon ranch slices are not representative of good NYC pizza, suggesting plain, pepperoni, tomato, or white slices for an authentic experience."
Negative"This user is unfamiliar with Quality Pizza Co and suggests that the original poster's opinion on NY pizza might not be fully formed after trying only two places."
Neutral"The pizza was good, especially the ranch, but it did not change the user's initial underwhelming impression of NY pizza, and Bleecker Street was thought to have better sauce."
Neutral
