Iconic NYC hot dogs & underrated papaya juice. A classic taste, though some find it a bit tangier than expected.
This classic establishment offers a nostalgic taste of New York City with its iconic hot dogs and refreshing papaya juice. While some may find its flavor profile a bit more tangy than other similar spots, it remains a beloved destination for a quick and satisfying bite. The place has a history dating back to the 1930s, originally as a juice bar, before its popular expansion into hot dogs.
The main draw here is the classic New York-style hot dog, often compared to other famous hot dog joints. The papaya juice is also frequently mentioned as a unique and underrated offering. Some patrons note a tangier flavor profile compared to other establishments, and a few feel the quality has declined over time.
"The hot dogs are a classic choice, and the papaya juice is frequently mentioned as a unique and underrated beverage that complements the meal well."
Customers generally have fond memories of this spot, appreciating its classic hot dogs and unique papaya juice. However, some find the taste has changed over the years or is not as balanced as competitors.
Important Note
Some patrons feel the quality or taste of the hot dogs has changed over the years, and it may be tangier than other similar establishments.
"The author points out that there is only one Papaya King location left in the city, and it is also becoming a rarity."
Negative"The author would prefer to go to Papaya King or similar establishments over a cart hot dog nowadays, noting they still sell square knishes."
Positive"Papaya King is listed as a place with memorable food, and it is implied they might also have curly fries."
Positive"This commenter clarified that the 86th street location is Papaya King and that it is very old but has recently moved to a new location, previously being caddy corner."
Neutral"This user mentioned a newer Papaya King on 86th street."
Neutral"Papaya King was listed among several other restaurant recommendations."
Neutral"Papaya King is listed as a recommended place."
Neutral"This user simply states to go to Papaya King."
Positive"This user mentions Papaya King as one of the 'Papaya' brick-and-mortar purveyors as an alternative to street carts."
Positive"The commenter was surprised to learn that the various 'Papaya King' establishments are not part of a single franchise, but rather many copycats."
Neutral"Explains that the original Papaya King started in the 1930s selling fruit juices before expanding into hot dogs, leading to the name association."
Neutral"The author's previous opinion was that Papaya King's tangier toppings made it less preferred, even at its old location."
Negative"The commenter feels Papaya King used to be much better and is unsure if a change in location or ownership affected the quality, but it's not the same anymore."
Negative"Papaya King is considered less balanced than Gray's Papaya, with a more sour/tangy taste. While still enjoyable, it doesn't quite hit the same spot for the author."
Neutral"The author is choosing Papaya King for hot dogs (preferring it over Nathan's) and praises the underrated papaya juice."
Positive"The user CanadianRedneck69 found that Papaya Hot Dogs (likely referring to Papaya King or similar) didn't live up to the hype."
Negative
