TLDR
Monthly rotating regional wine themes paired with exquisite tasting menus in the historic former Veritas space. Perfect for oenophiles seeking a high-end, immersive culinary tour.
Instagram Posts References
This tasting menu restaurant has not been open lately and its website indicates it is closed for the summer, with plans for an August return.
Vicki Denig explores Saint Urban in Flatiron, a restaurant offering a structured tasting menu experience that treats wine pairings with equal importance to the food.
Sonal Shah reviews Saint Urban, a Flatiron restaurant where the monthly changing menu highlights wine regions, making wine the star of the dining experience. Expect stellar wines paired with thoughtful dishes.
Details
Located in the iconic former Veritas space in Flatiron, this elegant destination centers its fine dining experience around monthly, region-specific wine themes [1], [2]. Guests are treated to thoughtfully curated tasting and prix-fixe menus that mirror the selected region's heritage [1], [3]. While many praise the exceptional wine pairings as a standout feature [1], [2], the experience has faced scrutiny regarding service consistency and overall value relative to its high price point [4], [5].
Food Overview
The cuisine features seasonal, high-end tasting menus designed to complement specific monthly wine regions, with dishes like milk-fed pig, turbot with arroz negro, and roast lamb earning praise for their harmonious flavor profiles [1]. While many diners enjoy these selections, some critics note the food is good but perhaps not exceptional compared to other top-tier New York fine dining options [4].
Customer Sentiment
While initially praised for its exceptional wine program, customer sentiment has become mixed due to reports of inconsistent service and concerns regarding the value proposition of its high-priced tasting menus [4], [5]. Recent feedback has also been impacted by frustrations surrounding unexpected restaurant closures [5].
Caveats
Potential diners should be aware of reports regarding inconsistent service quality and concerns about the restaurant's value relative to its price [4], [5]. Additionally, there have been instances of the restaurant closing unexpectedly without notice to guests with existing reservations [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SAINT URBAN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Does Anyone Know Why Saint Urban Closed For The
"The user noted the restaurant closed unexpectedly during June without canceling existing reservations. They felt the restaurant struggled to gain popularity and was underwhelming relative to its high price point."
NegativeFrom post: Does Anyone Know Why Saint Urban Closed For The
"The customer visited in May for a themed wine event focused on the Beaune region and thoroughly enjoyed their experience, expressing a desire to return."
PositiveFrom post: Saint Urban Are They An Under Radar Gem Or Too
"The user inquired whether Saint Urban's quality might vary depending on the monthly regional focus. They also noted their sommelier was very talkative, potentially indicating inconsistency in service."
NeutralFrom post: Saint Urban Are They An Under Radar Gem Or Too
"This user commented that Saint Urban is likely well-known for its wine selection rather than being an "under the radar" establishment."
NeutralFrom post: Saint Urban Are They An Under Radar Gem Or Too
"This user visited Saint Urban a few months ago and felt it flew under the radar. They experienced sloppy service and a sommelier who didn't explain the wines well, finding the food good but not exceptional compared to other NYC fine dining. They believe the restaurant has potential but didn't meet expectations."
Negative