TLDR
Iconic Flatiron luncheonette serving elite tuna melts, perfected patty melts, and nostalgic deli favorites in an authentic, old-school diner setting.
Instagram Posts References
S&P Lunch is featured as a cozy, diner-style spot offering classic American lunch favorites. The video shows the charming interior with its warm lighting and counter seating. It then highlights two timeless sandwiches: a perfectly grilled tuna melt, oozing with melted cheese and flaky tuna, and a robust Reuben sandwich, packed with pastrami, sauerkraut, and cheese. The emphasis is on traditional, comforting flavors executed with care.
The post details a positive dining experience at S&P Lunch, also known as Eisenberg's, a historic New York City luncheonette established in 1928. The author specifically enjoyed the Turkey Club sandwich, describing it as fantastic. The restaurant is celebrated for its classic diner fare, old-fashioned favorites like chopped olive sandwiches and matzoh brei, and its iconic 24-seater marble lunch counter, which offers a prime view of the kitchen and faster service. The author expresses a desire to return weekly if they lived closer and strongly recommends the spot to anyone visiting NYC.
This post features a classic tuna melt from S&P Lunch in Flatiron. The sandwich appears to be generously filled and served with a pickle spear, embodying a traditional deli experience.
This establishment, referred to as 'S&P lunch', is noted for its classic deli fare. The featured items are a 'Tuna melt' ($17) and 'Matzoh ball soup' ($10), along with 'French fries' ($6). It's presented as a spot for comforting and reasonably priced lunch options.
S&P Lunch, also known as Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop, is highlighted as an old-school classic and a New York City institution in the Flatiron district. The reviewer found the tuna melt to be 'top-tier' with 'perfectly griddled' seeded rye bread and American cheese that melted just right upon biting into it, despite initial appearances. The cherry cola, described as a 'real fountain' soda, was deemed 'the best'. Although fries were unavailable, the potato latkes served as an exceptional replacement, being 'insane' and potentially 'the best latke' the reviewer had ever tasted, noted for its perfect saltiness. Overall, the experience at S&P Lunch was overwhelmingly positive, scratching the reviewer's itch for a classic diner meal.
S&P Lunch, formerly Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop, is highlighted as an iconic and historic New York City deli, praised for its authentic old-school, vintage atmosphere. Patrons can enjoy the classic experience of sitting at the counter and watching their sandwiches being prepared. The restaurant is noted for serving traditional deli fare, including a tuna melt that has garnered significant attention in the local food scene, as well as hearty pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, and egg creams, providing a nostalgic dining experience.
Details
S & P Lunch is a beloved New York City institution that masterfully captures the charm of a historic luncheonette while serving high-quality, modernized comfort food [1], [2]. Visitors flock to the iconic marble lunch counter for standout staples like their celebrated tuna melt, hearty pastrami sandwiches, and exceptional carrot cake [1], [3], [5], [12]. With expanded hours now including dinner service, the menu has grown to feature creative specials like latke-crusted mozzarella sticks and a signature 'big burger' on a potato roll [4], [7], [8].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on elevated deli and American comfort food, with the tuna melt and patty melt frequently cited as benchmarks for these dishes in the city [1], [2], [12], [35]. Highly recommended items include the pastrami, carrot cake, and unique 'latkarella' sticks, while the cottage fries are widely preferred over traditional thin-cut fries [1], [2], [5], [12], [20].
Highlights / Recommended
"The tuna melt and patty melt are considered 'elite' or 'transcendent' by regulars [12], [36], [40], alongside the carrot cake, which is frequently described as life-changing [5], [12]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •tuna melt(21)
- •patty melt(12)
- •burger(5)
- •pastrami reuben(5)
- •pancakes(4)
- •egg cream(3)
- •latkes(3)
- •blt(3)
- •lil shonda(2)
- •cottage fries(2)
- •pastrami(2)
- •shrimp cocktail sandwich(2)
- •latke-crusted mozzarella sticks(2)
- •big burger(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons overwhelmingly consider this a top-tier destination for classic New York City diner fare, frequently praising the food quality as exceptional [5], [6]. While most visitors love the counter-service atmosphere, some have expressed minor confusion regarding the availability of full table service versus bar seating [1], [40].
Caveats
Patrons should be prepared for potential queues, and some diners have noted occasional uncertainty regarding the availability of table service versus counter seating [2], [40].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About S & P LUNCH
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Grilled Cheese In Nyc Grilled Cheese Lover
"Simply suggested as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Brunch At Bubbys In Tribeca I Give It An 810 It
"Recommended as the top spot for no-frills pancakes."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"Considered a perfected classic diner BLT."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"The reviewer notes the BLT is a perfected, classic diner style, though nothing out of the ordinary."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"Recommended as a spot where you can find well-done, high-quality tomato dishes."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Coffee And Lunch Near Chelsea
"The user visits regularly and appreciates the classic atmosphere over newer spots."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Coffee And Lunch Near Chelsea
"Recommended for a lunch spot in the Flatiron district with old-school greasy spoon vibes."
PositiveFrom post: Bangbang Recommendations For Parents Night Out
"Suggested for a bang-bang."
NeutralFrom post: The Absolute Best Weekday Lunch Options In Nyc
"Mentioned as a destination lunch option."
PositiveFrom post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"Suggested in a list of old-school NYC lunch spots."
PositiveFrom post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"Recommended as an old-school spot."
PositiveFrom post: Where Is The Best French Toast In Midtown Or
"The commenter recommends this place for brunch in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Listed S&P as a casual burger spot."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter asserted that S&P Lunch does have waiters."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter clarified that S&P Lunch might have waiters, as they have never eaten anywhere but the bar stools there."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter expressed confusion about whether S&P Lunch has waiters, recalling it having regular table service when it was previously Eisenberg's. They also mentioned difficulty getting to Manhattan for lunch."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter listed S&P Lunch among several other restaurants as potential fits, noting that it might have waiters. They later clarified that they weren't sure if it had waiters as they only ever sat at the bar stools."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter simply suggested S&P Lunch as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Any Typical Americanstyle Breakfast Recommendation
"S&P, located at 5th Ave & 22nd Street, is the former Eisenberg's and is described as a classic American establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user found S&P to make pretty good egg creams, though noted variability in quality and consistency."
Neutral