Iconic old-school deli & luncheonette. Classic Jewish & American comfort food, stacked sandwiches, matzo ball soup, & egg creams. A true NYC foodie experience.
Step into a piece of New York history at S&P Lunch, a classic American deli and luncheonette that has been serving up traditional fare with a touch of greasy charm. From its old-school counter service to its beloved diner classics, it offers a nostalgic taste of the city. Whether you're craving a perfectly stacked pastrami sandwich, a comforting bowl of matzo ball soup, or a creamy egg cream, this spot delivers a quintessential New York deli experience that lives up to the hype.
S&P Lunch excels in classic American and Jewish deli fare. Reviewers rave about the stacked pastrami sandwiches, the 'Lil Shonda' sandwich, and the tuna melt. Other popular items include matzo ball soup, egg creams, and latkes. While one comment mentioned a less-than-ideal distribution of onion on a bagel sandwich, overall feedback on the food is overwhelmingly positive.
"Highly recommended dishes include the pastrami sandwich (especially 'the delight'), the 'Lil Shonda' sandwich, tuna melts, patty melts, latkes, pancakes, and egg creams. The Reuben and 'The Jake' (a chicken cutlet Reuben) are also singled out for praise."
Customers overwhelmingly praise S&P Lunch, highlighting its authentic old-school atmosphere and delicious, classic deli fare. The food is consistently described as excellent, with many dishes recommended.
Important Note
One user mentioned that S&P is 'tasty but skimpy these days,' and another noted that while they love the food, they wish it were a little cheaper for more frequent visits. A user also mentioned that most seating is at the bar.
"This user listed S&P as a place to start for hot dogs."
Positive"This commenter recommends S&P."
Positive"The user mentioned S&P as a place to get latkes and asked for alternatives, but another user recommended S&P for their pancakes, calling them the best."
Positive"S&P is listed by the commenter."
Neutral"The user is asking for latkes and pancakes and has heard S&P is good for latkes, but is open to other suggestions. This comment is not a direct opinion on the restaurant but mentions it in the context of the original post."
Neutral"Mentions S&P as a place to get chicken salad."
Neutral"This user found S&P's carrot cake to have a perfect texture, not gummy like Lloyd's, with a great cake-to-frosting ratio and not too sweet."
Positive"This user called S&P a 'sleeper' recommendation for carrot cake."
Positive"This user recommended S&P as a 'sleeper' choice for carrot cake."
Positive"This user recommended S&P in Manhattan for their carrot cake, stating it's the best they've ever had, noting it's very moist and not gummy like Lloyd's."
Positive"S&P has a breakfast sandwich called 'The Lil' Shonda' that the commenter is eager to try."
Neutral"S&P Lunch was recommended, with specific mentions of their Mel Brooks, Flatiron Delight, Ruben, and Tuna Melt sandwiches."
Positive"S&P was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"S&P is recommended for a tuna melt."
Positive"S&P is mentioned as a place to get a tuna melt."
Positive"This user seconded S&P for a melt, implying it's a good choice."
Positive"This user simply mentioned "S&P"."
Neutral"S&P Lunch is suggested as a place that fits the criteria, although most seating is at the bar."
Positive"This user recommended S&P as a good option in the Flatiron area."
Positive"The commenter recently discovered S&P and can't stop thinking about its special, making it a candidate for a final meal."
Positive
