Classic NY deli vibes w/ top-tier pastrami & fluffy pancakes.
S&P Lunch, formerly Eisenberg's, is a beloved New York City institution that honors the classic luncheonette tradition. It offers a nostalgic dining experience with a menu featuring expertly crafted sandwiches, particularly their pastrami on rye and BLTs, alongside highly-rated pancakes and tuna melts. The diner ambiance, complete with counter seating and cherry lime rickeys, makes it a must-visit for a quintessential New York meal.
S&P Lunch is celebrated for its classic American diner and Jewish deli offerings. Highly recommended items include the pastrami sandwich (particularly 'the delight' and the double meat version), BLTs, pancakes, tuna melts, and the 'lil Shonda' sandwich. While most feedback is positive, one user felt the portions were "skimpy these days."
"Highly recommended dishes include the pastrami sandwich, BLT, pancakes, tuna melt, and the 'lil Shonda' sandwich. The Cherry Lime Rickey is also a notable drink."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards S&P Lunch, praising its classic American diner feel and specific dishes like pastrami sandwiches and pancakes. Some minor feedback mentions portion sizes being perceived as small by one user.
Important Note
One user mentioned that portions might be a bit skimpy "these days."
"S&P has a breakfast sandwich called 'The Lil' Shonda' that the commenter is eager to try."
Neutral"S&P Lunch was recommended, with specific mentions of their Mel Brooks, Flatiron Delight, Ruben, and Tuna Melt sandwiches."
Positive"S&P was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"S&P is recommended for a tuna melt."
Positive"S&P is mentioned as a place to get a tuna melt."
Positive"This user seconded S&P for a melt, implying it's a good choice."
Positive"This user simply mentioned "S&P"."
Neutral"S&P Lunch is suggested as a place that fits the criteria, although most seating is at the bar."
Positive"This user recommended S&P as a good option in the Flatiron area."
Positive"The commenter recently discovered S&P and can't stop thinking about its special, making it a candidate for a final meal."
Positive"The commenter recently discovered S&P and can't stop thinking about its special, making it a candidate for a final meal."
Positive"The author commented that the distribution of onion on a bagel sandwich from S&P Lunch (Eisenberg's) was criminal."
Negative"The author loves S&P Lunch but wishes it were a little cheaper for more frequent visits."
Positive"The author stated that Eisenberg's has always been good, referring to S&P Lunch."
Positive"The author expressed approval for S&P Lunch."
Positive"The author recognized S&P Lunch as Eisenberg's and mentioned living there in the 1990s."
Positive"The author enjoyed everything at S&P Lunch, indicating no misses."
Positive"S&P Lunch is recommended for classic NY sandwiches."
Positive"The S&P club is recommended as a classic sandwich choice."
Positive"The author mentions S&P as a place with fantastic sandwiches, alongside Jewish delis like Katz's."
Positive
