Classic diner vibes meets exceptional sandwiches and fluffy pancakes, a true old-school NYC lunch counter experience.
This Flatiron establishment, a revival of the classic Eisenberg's, offers a nostalgic diner experience with a menu that balances traditional favorites and updated dishes. It's celebrated for its exceptional sandwiches, particularly the pastrami and Reuben, and its well-executed pancakes and egg creams. The retro ambiance, complete with counter seating, makes it a beloved spot for a quintessential New York meal.
S&P Lunch is highly regarded for its classic American and Jewish deli fare, with a particular emphasis on sandwiches, especially the pastrami and Reuben. Pancakes and egg creams are also frequently mentioned and recommended. While most feedback is positive, one user found the offerings 'skimpy'.
"Highly recommended dishes include the pastrami sandwich, Reuben, pancakes, egg cream, and tuna melt."
Customers generally have a positive view of S&P Lunch, praising its classic diner atmosphere and quality sandwiches, though one comment mentioned it being a bit skimpy.
Important Note
One user mentioned that the portions can be a bit skimpy these days.
"S&P is recommended for a tuna melt."
Positive"S&P is mentioned as a place to get a tuna melt."
Positive"This user seconded S&P for a melt, implying it's a good choice."
Positive"This user simply mentioned "S&P"."
Neutral"S&P Lunch is suggested as a place that fits the criteria, although most seating is at the bar."
Positive"This user recommended S&P as a good option in the Flatiron area."
Positive"The commenter recently discovered S&P and can't stop thinking about its special, making it a candidate for a final meal."
Positive"The commenter recently discovered S&P and can't stop thinking about its special, making it a candidate for a final meal."
Positive"The author commented that the distribution of onion on a bagel sandwich from S&P Lunch (Eisenberg's) was criminal."
Negative"The author loves S&P Lunch but wishes it were a little cheaper for more frequent visits."
Positive"The author stated that Eisenberg's has always been good, referring to S&P Lunch."
Positive"The author expressed approval for S&P Lunch."
Positive"The author recognized S&P Lunch as Eisenberg's and mentioned living there in the 1990s."
Positive"The author enjoyed everything at S&P Lunch, indicating no misses."
Positive"S&P Lunch is recommended for classic NY sandwiches."
Positive"The S&P club is recommended as a classic sandwich choice."
Positive"The author mentions S&P as a place with fantastic sandwiches, alongside Jewish delis like Katz's."
Positive"S&P is mentioned as a great sandwich spot."
Positive"S&P is mentioned as a good spot for sandwiches."
Positive"The original poster was unaware of the name change from Eisenberg to S&P. They plan to try a sandwich there and also mention liking the tuna melt."
Positive
