Old-school Jewish deli & luncheonette in Flatiron, serving classic fare like killer patty melts & latkes. Expect a line, but service is efficient [1].
S&P Lunch, a historic Jewish deli and luncheonette in Flatiron, maintains its old-school charm with classic dishes and a bustling counter-service atmosphere [1]. Known for its
S&P Lunch is celebrated for its classic deli fare, with particular acclaim for its tuna melt, described as 'freaking delicious' and a must-try [2]. The patty melt is also a standout, often cited as a benchmark for the dish in NYC, featuring a perfectly crisped rye bread and a well-balanced filling [1, 3]. Other recommended items include pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, egg creams, and latkes, which have been called the best in Manhattan [1, 2, 3]. The restaurant also offers a notable carrot cake, praised for its moist texture and flavor [4].
"Highly recommended dishes include the 'killer' patty melt, the 'freaking delicious' tuna melt, and the latkes, which are considered the best in Manhattan. The pastrami sandwich and carrot cake also receive strong endorsements."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards S&P Lunch, frequently praising specific dishes like the tuna melt and patty melt. The overall experience is described as excellent, with some visitors expressing a desire for more frequent visits if it were slightly more affordable [2].
Important Note
One user expressed a wish that S&P Lunch were a little cheaper for more frequent visits [2]. There can be a line, but service is noted as efficient [1].
"S&P Lunch was recommended, with the user stating they go there regularly and highlighting the tuna melt as a standout item."
Positive"S&P was listed as a place for soup."
Neutral"This user suggested S&P, noting they now serve lunch for dinner and that it would be a memorable experience."
Positive"This user contrasted Agi's and S&P's tuna melts, stating Agi's has better bread while S&P's mayo ratio is 'insane' when fresh. They further clarified that S&P is better for mayo-slathered bread, and Agi's if the bread flavor is prioritized."
Neutral"This user praised S&P's ability to achieve a golden-brown exterior on their bread without drying out the inside, calling it the 'whole trick' that most places mishandle."
Positive"This user stated that Agi's is solid but S&P's crispy bread hits harder. They later recommended S&P's, noting the cheese pull and better chips, and suggested it might be more enjoyable than Agi's if one isn't a huge tuna fan."
Positive"The commenter suggests S&P for a quick bite, implying it's a good option for a fast and potentially satisfying meal."
Positive"This user commented that Agi's is legit but S&P's crispy bread is superior. They later added that S&P achieves a golden-brown exterior without drying out the inside, which is a key trick many places fail at."
Positive"Both the patty melt and the tuna melt are described as exceptionally delicious."
Positive"A short, enthusiastic agreement with a previous positive comment about S&P Lunch."
Positive"This user stated that the tuna melt at S&P Lunch looked perfectly melty and that the cottage fries were a better choice than thin fries, which can become soggy."
Positive"A brief positive comment calling S&P Lunch the 'GOAT lunch'."
Positive"This commenter praised the carrot cake at S&P Lunch as life-changing, and later elaborated that it's 'ridiculously good' and they hesitate to spread the word widely."
Positive"The original poster confirmed that their tuna melt and cottage fries were from S&P Lunch and that they loved the cottage fries, even though they were unfamiliar with the term."
Positive"This commenter noted that S&P Lunch offers an open-face melt option upon request and expressed their love for the place."
Positive"This commenter noted that the pickle on the side was good and that cottage fries are a better choice for melts than thin fries which can become limp."
Positive"Replying to a comparison of tuna melts, this user stated that Agi's wins for its dessert program, while acknowledging S&P is loved for different reasons."
Neutral"This user expressed missing working near S&P Lunch, as they are no longer in the area when it's open."
Negative"This user observed that the tuna melt at S&P Lunch was properly prepared, with melted cheese and a perfectly golden crust on the bread, and that the thick-cut fries were a suitable accompaniment."
Positive"This user had the tuna melt for breakfast without fries and found it delicious. They compared the fries to waffle fries from Emily West Village, noting they were good."
Positive
