Next.js logo

S & P LUNCH

Updated

Phone: (646) 338-7632

Address: 174 5 AVENUE 10010

TLDR

Iconic Flatiron luncheonette serving elite tuna melts, perfected patty melts, and classic diner staples with old-school counter vibes.

Reddit Sentiment for S & P LUNCH(based on 110 Reddit opinions)

73% Positive26% Neutral1% Negative

Tags

american 36deli 10diner 7tuna melt 29sandwich 14burger 14View All

Neighborhoods

Flatiron District

Instagram Posts References

S&P Lunch is featured as a cozy, diner-style spot offering classic American lunch favorites. The video shows the charming interior with its warm lighting and counter seating. It then highlights two timeless sandwiches: a perfectly grilled tuna melt, oozing with melted cheese and flaky tuna, and a robust Reuben sandwich, packed with pastrami, sauerkraut, and cheese. The emphasis is on traditional, comforting flavors executed with care.

The post details a positive dining experience at S&P Lunch, also known as Eisenberg's, a historic New York City luncheonette established in 1928. The author specifically enjoyed the Turkey Club sandwich, describing it as fantastic. The restaurant is celebrated for its classic diner fare, old-fashioned favorites like chopped olive sandwiches and matzoh brei, and its iconic 24-seater marble lunch counter, which offers a prime view of the kitchen and faster service. The author expresses a desire to return weekly if they lived closer and strongly recommends the spot to anyone visiting NYC.

This post features a classic tuna melt from S&P Lunch in Flatiron. The sandwich appears to be generously filled and served with a pickle spear, embodying a traditional deli experience.

This establishment, referred to as 'S&P lunch', is noted for its classic deli fare. The featured items are a 'Tuna melt' ($17) and 'Matzoh ball soup' ($10), along with 'French fries' ($6). It's presented as a spot for comforting and reasonably priced lunch options.

S&P Lunch, also known as Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop, is highlighted as an old-school classic and a New York City institution in the Flatiron district. The reviewer found the tuna melt to be 'top-tier' with 'perfectly griddled' seeded rye bread and American cheese that melted just right upon biting into it, despite initial appearances. The cherry cola, described as a 'real fountain' soda, was deemed 'the best'. Although fries were unavailable, the potato latkes served as an exceptional replacement, being 'insane' and potentially 'the best latke' the reviewer had ever tasted, noted for its perfect saltiness. Overall, the experience at S&P Lunch was overwhelmingly positive, scratching the reviewer's itch for a classic diner meal.

S&P Lunch, formerly Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop, is highlighted as an iconic and historic New York City deli, praised for its authentic old-school, vintage atmosphere. Patrons can enjoy the classic experience of sitting at the counter and watching their sandwiches being prepared. The restaurant is noted for serving traditional deli fare, including a tuna melt that has garnered significant attention in the local food scene, as well as hearty pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, and egg creams, providing a nostalgic dining experience.

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
NYC Guide
very positive

An unexpected standout, S&P Lunch wins praise for an heirloom tomato sandwich elevated by a clever sprinkle of seasoning.

Bryan Kim • Aug 28, 2026
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
The Best New Food We’ve Encountered Six Months Into the Year
positive

T.T. reviews S&P's "big burger" offered during new dinner hours, featuring an eight-ounce patty with Muenster cheese, "pot roast" onions, and a special "Miami sauce" on a custom potato roll.

M.S. and T.T. • Jun 25, 2026
Read More →
Grubstreet
Mentioned In
New to the Hit List (June 2026)
positive

S&P Lunch in Flatiron is now open for early dinner and offers comforting classics like their famed tuna melt alongside dinner specials such as a shrimp cocktail sandwich and latkarella sticks.

Resy • Jun 1, 2026
Mentioned In
The Resy Hit List: The Restaurants to Know in New York This June
positive

Resy updates readers on S&P Lunch in Flatiron, noting their new daily dinner service and classic comfort food menu.

Resy • Jun 1, 2026
Mentioned In
Six Things Not to Miss in New York This Month
positive

The beloved lunch counter is now serving dinner, offering comfort food classics and new, inventive specials.

• Jun 1, 2026
Mentioned In
The Resy Hit List: May 2026
positive

S&P Lunch in Flatiron now offers early dinner service, expanding its menu beyond famed tuna melts to include dinner specials like a towering shrimp cocktail sandwich and latke-crusted mozzarella sticks.

Resy • May 1, 2026
Mentioned In
The Resy Hit List: The Restaurants You Need to Know in New York
positive

S&P Lunch now offers dinner service, continuing to serve their beloved, satisfying comfort food staples alongside new evening specials.

• May 1, 2026
Mentioned In
The 21 best diners in NYC
positive

In the former Eisenberg's space, S&P Lunch honors luncheonette tradition with classic dishes like matzo brei and chopped liver on rye, mixing old-school and new.

Rachel Pelz • Jun 24, 2024
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
The Best Brunches in NYC
positive

S&P Lunch, an old-school luncheonette and Jewish deli in Flatiron, offers greasy charm with a killer patty melt, latkes, and the 'Lil Shonda' sandwich. Expect a line.

Bryan Kim • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Located in the former home of Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop, this historic Flatiron luncheonette continues a tradition of classic New York diner fare [1]. While it maintains its vintage, old-school charm, the menu features elevated comfort food staples like acclaimed tuna melts and hearty pastrami sandwiches [2]. Recent updates have expanded their appeal with dinner service and creative specials such as latke-crusted mozzarella sticks [3].

Food Overview

This classic American diner specializes in expertly crafted sandwiches, with the tuna melt and patty melt frequently cited as some of the best in the city [2], [5]. Other standout items include exceptional latkes [2], pastrami reubens, and a recently introduced 'big burger' [3]. Diners also highly recommend their milkshakes, egg creams, and traditional breakfast options like pancakes [1], [6].

Highlights / Recommended

The tuna melt and patty melt are widely considered the benchmark for these dishes in NYC [2], [5]. Additionally, the latkes and 'latkarella' sticks are highly praised as standout, unique offerings [2], [3].

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise the establishment for its high-quality, nostalgic diner experience and consistently well-executed comfort food [2], [5]. While most patrons appreciate the classic counter seating, some have expressed minor uncertainty regarding table service consistency [6].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    tuna melt
    22 mentions
  • 02
    patty melt
    12 mentions
  • 03
    burger
    5 mentions
  • 04
    pastrami reuben
    5 mentions
  • 05
    pancakes
    4 mentions
  • 06
    egg cream
    3 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About S & P LUNCH

This thread is the definitive discussion on the restaurant's famous patty melt, with many calling it the best in the city and a benchmark for the dish.
A viral post that solidified the reputation of the tuna melt and sparked an interesting discussion on why cottage fries are the superior side for this sandwich.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Day Off Tomorrow What Should I Get That Usually

"Suggested for a visit."

Positive
Sep 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Day Off Tomorrow What Should I Get That Usually

"Mentioned for their tuna melt."

Neutral
Sep 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any

"Highly recommended lunch spot."

Positive
Sep 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: This Might Be One Of The Best Pastrami Sandwiches

"Recommended as a place to get sandwiches in the Flatiron area."

Positive
Sep 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Diners In Nyc Preferably Old School Style

"Recommended."

Positive
Aug 31, 2026View Comment →

Often mentioned with S & P Lunch

More in Flatiron District

See all

More American in NYC

See all