TLDR
Classic, old-school NYC pub vibe featuring a well-regarded, traditional cheeseburger. A reliable, historic spot for a solid burger and casual drinks.
Reddit Sentiment for PJ CLARKE'S OYSTER BAR & GRILLE LLC(based on 81 Reddit opinions)
Details
Known for its authentic, old-school NYC ambiance, this establishment is a reliable choice for the after-work crowd and those seeking a classic, no-frills meal [1]. While many fans celebrate its iconic status and solid pub fare, others debate whether it remains a top-tier destination compared to newer burger concepts [2], [3]. It serves as a convenient and steady option, especially for those looking to soak in a bit of city history alongside their meal [3].
Food Overview
The menu centers on classic American pub fare, with the cheeseburger being the most frequently discussed item [1], [3]. While some customers praise the burger for its flavor and temperature, others suggest that it has lost its edge in a competitive market, noting that better burger experiences can be found elsewhere in the city [2], [3]. Additional mentions include raw bar options, tomato soup, and martinis [3].
Highlights / Recommended
"The classic cheeseburger is the most widely discussed and frequently recommended staple [3]."
Customer Sentiment
Feedback is notably mixed; while many long-time patrons cherish the nostalgic atmosphere and consistent quality, others characterize it as overpriced and more of a tourist attraction than a culinary destination [3]. Despite these criticisms, it maintains a strong reputation as a dependable "safe bet" for a classic American meal [1], [3].
Caveats
Multiple diners emphasize that it is not necessarily a culinary 'destination' worth traveling across the city for, often suggesting it is better enjoyed if you are already in the immediate vicinity [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PJ CLARKE'S OYSTER BAR & GRILLE LLC
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Burger Or Elevated Bar Food Nearish Msg Happy
"Described as a decent, nearby option about a 4-minute walk from MSG."
NeutralFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Listed PJ Clarke's as a classic burger place."
PositiveFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Listed PJ Clarke's as a classic place for a good burger."
PositiveFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Recommended PJ Clarke's."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Classic Burger Between These
"This commenter lists PJ Clarkes as one of two truly elite CLASSIC burgers in the city."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Classic Burger Between These
"This commenter suggests PJ Clarkes as a place with a really classic burger."
PositiveFrom post: Help Need Dinner Recs Near Javits For Party Of 8
"PJ Clarke's on 33rd was suggested as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Favorite Crab Dish In Nyc
"Recommended the She Crab Soup at the Oyster Bar in Grand Central, noting it can be obtained from the takeout window but may not be available daily."
PositiveFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"As a long-time New Yorker who eats burgers frequently, the author considers P.J. Clarke's a classic American cheeseburger, with good temperature, flavor, fries, and old-school NYC ambiance, disagreeing with those who find it merely serviceable."
PositiveFrom post: Im Looking For The Cheesiest Cheeseburger In Nyc
"Considered to have one of the best classic American cheeseburgers, and can be ordered with extra cheese."
PositiveFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"Compares ordering a burger at P.J. Clarke's to ordering steak on a Caribbean island, implying it's not the best choice for that specific item."
NeutralFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"P.J. Clarke's is a good option for a meal, especially the Lincoln Center location, but not worth a special trip. The burger is solid."
NeutralFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"P.J. Clarke's is a good option for a generally good meal, but better burgers exist. A new location near Penn Station is also mentioned. Pastis and Gotham Social are suggested for burgers."
NeutralFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"Provides a link to NYC health inspection data for a restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"P.J. Clarke's is considered a tourist trap and not a destination restaurant, more for 'cosplaying' a 90s investment banker."
NegativeFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"The staff at P.J. Clarke's were nice, and the food was okay but not outstanding. A part of the order was missed, but the commenter doesn't heavily criticize it."
NeutralFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"The service at P.J. Clarke's is noted as being very slow."
NegativeFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"P.J. Clarke's is a liked spot but not a destination, with a sighting of Paul Shaffer who was very nice."
PositiveFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"The Peter Luger lunch burger in Great Neck and the original Emily burger are the only two burgers in NY worth traveling for, along with potentially PJ Clarke's."
NeutralFrom post: Pj Clarkesworth The Trip
"Donovan's Pub and Minetta Tavern are recommended."
Neutral