Step back to the 50s! Classic UES spot w/huge martinis, a nostalgic burger, & great bar scene. Steaks are diner-quality, but the pub fare shines.
Sonal Shah reviews Donohue's, an Upper East Side classic known for its supersized martinis and lively bar atmosphere. While a steakhouse by name, the reviewer suggests focusing on the burgers and other pub-like fare.
Jesse Hirsch reviews Donohue's Steak House, an Upper East Side institution that, after 76 years, is closing its doors. The article reflects on the restaurant's timeless ambiance, classic comfort food, and the impending bittersweet departure of its owner.
This Upper East Side institution, a true classic, transports diners back to the 1950s with its checkerboard floors and cozy red booths. While named a steakhouse, it's best experienced as a classic pub, renowned for its generously poured martinis and a burger that evokes a unique sense of nostalgia. The French onion soup is a standout, though be warned it can be quite salty. It's a place to soak in authentic, unvarnished New York history.
Donohue's is known for its classic American pub fare. While the steaks are often described as diner-quality, the Prime Chopped Beef Burger is a consistent favorite, offering a nostalgic and satisfying experience. The French Onion Soup is also a highlight, though some find it to be overly salty. The oversized martinis are a must-try, often served with a sidecar.
"The Prime Chopped Beef Burger is highly recommended as a satisfying bar burger. The oversized martinis are also a signature item that diners should try."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, particularly praising the classic bar atmosphere, large martinis, and the nostalgic burger. Some reviews note that while the steaks are considered diner-quality, other pub-style fare is highly recommended.
Important Note
The steaks are generally considered to be of diner quality. The French Onion Soup can be very salty.
"This user suggests Donohues, located at 64th and Lexington, as a place that might fit the desired vibe."
Positive"Donohue's was mentioned as a place that serves the martini and fries combination."
Positive"Donahues Steak is recommended for the Upper East area."
Positive"Donahues Steak is recommended for the Upper East area."
Positive"This user recommends the bar at Donohue's steak house, describing it as a 50s-style diner that makes classic drinks well. The clientele is noted to be mostly older neighborhood residents."
Positive
