Next.js logo

MARCO POLO RISTORANTE

Updated

Phone: (718) 852-5015

Address: 345 COURT STREET 11231

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Old-school Italian gem w/ authentic red-sauce & tableside pasta tossed in cheese wheels. A Brooklyn staple since the 80s.

Reddit Sentiment for MARCO POLO RISTORANTE(based on 12 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive8% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

italian 11italian-american 2pasta 5View All

Neighborhoods

Carroll Gardens

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
Caputo’s Bake Shop, a Brooklyn institution, closes after 122 years
lean negative

This long-standing Italian restaurant, a fixture in Carroll Gardens, relied on Caputo's bread for two decades and is now transitioning to another local bakery.

Chloe Harrison • Apr 30, 2026
Read More →
Grubstreet
Mentioned In
Where to eat Italian in NYC when you aren willing to settle.

Marco Polo is an enduring old-school Italian restaurant on Court Street, which has been a neighborhood fixture since the 1980s.

Bryan Kim, Neha Talreja, Willa Moore, Molly Fitzpatrick & Tiffany Yannetta • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
The Best Restaurants in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Neha Talreja, Bryan Kim, Willa Moore & Will Hartman • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

This enduring old-school Italian restaurant has been a neighborhood fixture on Court Street since the 1980s, offering a traditional dining experience. It's known for its classic red-sauce Italian-American cuisine and a unique pasta preparation where dishes are tossed in a cheese wheel tableside. This long-standing establishment continues to be a reliable spot for those seeking authentic Italian flavors.

Food Overview

The restaurant serves classic Italian-American red-sauce dishes, with a notable highlight being pasta tossed tableside in a large cheese wheel. This unique preparation, such as the 'Fettuccine Al Vino Rossa' or 'Gaia's bowl pasta,' is frequently mentioned and recommended by patrons. While most feedback is positive, one Reddit comment suggests that a proposal to dine here received negative community feedback.

Highlights / Recommended

"The pasta tossed tableside in a large cheese wheel is a standout, with 'Fettuccine Al Vino Rossa' specifically recommended as a unique and interesting dish. The carbonara is also noted as being very good."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment, frequently recommending the restaurant for its classic Italian-American dishes and unique pasta presentations, though one comment indicated negative community feedback on a suggestion.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MARCO POLO RISTORANTE

This is so dumb but I kind of want pasta that's tossed in a cheese wheel
Multiple users discuss the cheese wheel pasta preparation at Marco Polo, with one user specifically recalling having 'Gaia's bowl pasta' tossed in a cheese wheel. Another user recommends the 'Fettuccine Al Vino Rossa,' also tossed in a cheese wheel, as a unique and worthwhile dish.
Best Carbonara in the City?
Marco Polo Ristorante in Brooklyn is recommended for its carbonara, noted as a pasta dish that is very good.
NYC Traditional Italian recommendations?
This commenter recommends Marco Polo as a true old-school Italian joint with 'bullet-holes-and-all' authenticity, located on Court Street.
My brother wants to eat like Tony Soprano in NYC
Marco Polo in Carroll Gardens is suggested as a restaurant with authentic mob ties, drawing a comparison to Vesuvio and referencing a news article.
Italian restaurant (not pizzeria) in South Brooklyn?
Marco Polo was suggested as an option for Italian food, however, this suggestion reportedly received negative feedback from the community.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations

"This user recommended Marco Polo, located down the street from Frankie's Spuntino, as a true bullet-holes-and-all old school Italian joint."

Positive
Mar 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Carbonara In The City

"Marco Polo Ristorante in Brooklyn is recommended."

Positive
Mar 1, 2026View Comment →

From post: This Is So Dumb But I Kind Of Want Pasta Thats

"This user agrees with the recommendation for Marco Polo, stating it is very good."

Positive
Nov 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: This Is So Dumb But I Kind Of Want Pasta Thats

"Marco Polo continues to offer the cheese wheel pasta preparation, which the user has enjoyed over the past 25 years."

Positive
Nov 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: This Is So Dumb But I Kind Of Want Pasta Thats

"The Fettuccine Al Vino Rossa at Marco Polo, tossed in a cheese wheel, is worth trying and is a unique dish."

Positive
Nov 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: This Is So Dumb But I Kind Of Want Pasta Thats

"The user recalls having pasta tossed in Gaia's bowl at Marco Polo in Carroll Gardens on a previous visit."

Positive
Nov 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Good Spots In West Bk That Take Walk Ins

"Marco Polo was recommended as another great Italian restaurant."

Positive
Oct 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Italian Restaurant Not Pizzeria In South Brooklyn

"Marco Polo was suggested as a restaurant option for Italian food, though the suggestion received negative community feedback."

Neutral
Jun 21, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Brother Wants To Eat Like Tony Soprano In

"The commenter suggests Marco Polo in Carroll Gardens, stating it's similar to Vesuvio and has authentic mob ties, referencing a news article."

Positive
May 27, 2025View Comment →