NYC bagel institution – from Oreo cream cheese to lox & scallion. A must-try for classic bagel sandwiches & fresh bakes.
Experience the authentic taste of New York with Utopia Bagels, a beloved spot for freshly made bagels. Customers rave about their unique offerings, including the standout Oreo cream cheese and a variety of delicious bagel sandwiches. Whether you're craving a classic lox and cream cheese or a hearty breakfast sandwich, Utopia Bagels delivers a satisfying and classic NYC bagel experience.
Utopia Bagels is celebrated for its wide selection of fresh, house-made bagels, with many customers specifically recommending the Oreo cream cheese and various bagel sandwiches. While most feedback is positive, one reviewer found the Manhattan location's bagels to be too soft and less chewy than preferred, contrasting it with other renowned bagel shops.
"Customers frequently praise the unique Oreo cream cheese and recommend classic combinations like lox and scallion cream cheese, as well as various breakfast sandwiches on their fresh bagels."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Utopia Bagels for their delicious, freshly made bagels and unique cream cheese flavors. Many consider it a top-tier bagel spot in the city.
Important Note
One reviewer found the Manhattan location's bagels to be too soft and preferred the chewiness of other establishments.
"Utopia Bagels is listed as a suggestion for a bagel joint."
Positive"Utopia bagels is recommended."
Positive"This commenter recommended Utopia for bagels on East 34th Street."
Positive"Utopia Bagels is listed as having a store in Midtown."
Positive"Utopia Bagels is listed as having a store in Midtown."
Positive"This user suggested that the negative review of Utopia Bagels might be due to visiting a 'fake' location."
Neutral"This user reiterated their preference for Utopia, having tried many other places."
Positive"This user found Utopia Bagels' plain bagel to be the best at a bagel fest in 2024, but noted variability in previous years."
Positive"This user strongly vouches for Utopia Bagels, calling them 'goated'."
Positive"This user suggested that hole-in-the-wall bagel places are better than Utopia."
Negative"This user strongly disagrees, finding Utopia Bagels' bagels to be 'damn near perfect'."
Positive"This user finds Utopia Bagels to be good, but questions if they are truly the 'best' as often cited, noting inconsistency between the shop and fest offerings."
Neutral"This user found Utopia Bagels overrated due to long lines, small bagels, high prices, and a decline in quality."
Negative"This is a recommendation for Utopia Bagels as a breakfast spot."
Positive"This user has experience transporting bagels from Utopia bagels to other locations and finds freezing them upon arrival to be the easiest method."
Positive"This user suggests Utopia bagels might freeze better than Ess-a-Bagel due to being less doughy."
Positive"The user enthusiastically recommends Utopia Bagels, calling it amazing."
Positive"Mentions Utopia Bagels as a place to get bagels that can be frozen."
Positive"Utopia Bagels was included in a list of classic New York bagel places offering reasonable prices."
Positive"Utopia Bagels' chicken salad is highly liked by this commenter for being very finely shredded and not having gross chunks."
Positive
