Last Updated: 4 months ago
Phone: (212) 734-7441
Address: 1551 2 AVENUE 10028
NYC bagel institution w/ classic varieties, kettle-boiled & baked for a unique taste. Once legendary, now debated.
This establishment offers classic American deli fare, with a particular focus on bagels. While some patrons recall a legendary past, recent opinions suggest a decline in quality. The bagels, though kettle-boiled and baked, have received mixed reviews, with some finding them too heavy or not toasted enough. Despite some criticism, it remains a spot for those seeking a traditional New York bagel experience.
The food offering centers around bagels, with mentions of BECs (bagel, egg, and cheese) and sandwiches. While the traditional kettle-boiled and baked method is highlighted, customer feedback on the current quality of the bagels is mixed, with some finding them heavy and others believing the quality has declined since its original location closed. A frozen Long Island Iced Tea is also mentioned as a positive offering.
"While specific dishes receive mixed reviews, a BEC (bagel, egg, and cheese) on a bagel and a frozen Long Island Iced Tea were mentioned positively by users."
Customer sentiment is divided, with some reminiscing about past quality and others finding the current offerings to be mediocre or overpriced. There's a notable nostalgia for its historical reputation contrasted with present-day critiques.
Important Note
There is significant debate about the current quality of H&H Bagels, with many commenters suggesting that the quality has declined significantly since the closure of its original location. Some also find the prices to be high.
"The commenter tried the UES H&H Bagels, giving it the benefit of the doubt, but found it overpriced and mediocre."
Negative"This commenter agreed that H&H bagels are no longer good and stated they live close to the UES location but would not go there anymore, preferring other places."
Negative"In response to a comment calling H&H bagels 'crap', the author clarified that 'crap' would be more fitting for Dunkin' Donuts bagels."
Neutral"This commenter stated that the original H&H Bagels closed years ago and the current locations are not related in quality. They believe the current bagels are poor."
Negative"The author found the sandwiches from H&H Bagels to be good but heavy. They also noted that the bagels could have used more toasting time and that the prices were high, possibly due to the Upper East Side location."
Positive"This commenter suggested getting bagels and cream cheese from H&H Midtown."
Positive"This commenter suggested H&H on Metropolitan Ave for its great frozen Long Island Iced Tea."
Positive"H&H is recommended for a BEC on a bagel."
Positive
