Iconic NYC spot for dancing shrimp & martini specials, with a history near Carnegie Hall.
Red Eye Grill, located in Manhattan, is an American restaurant that has been a part of the city's dining scene for a considerable time. It's situated in a prime location near Carnegie Hall, which has historically contributed to its success, particularly for pre- and post-performance dining. The restaurant is known for its 'dancing shrimp,' a dish that garnered significant praise from former patrons and employees alike, who recall it being fantastic during the late 90s and early 2000s. Beyond the signature shrimp, Red Eye Grill also offers a 'Monday Martinis' special that has been highlighted by customers. While some patrons feel the restaurant's best days may be behind it, others acknowledge its enduring presence, possibly due to its affiliation with the Fireman group and its strategic location. The availability of private rooms also makes it a consideration for private events.
The food at Red Eye Grill is primarily American cuisine. Historically, the 'dancing shrimp' were a highly recommended and praised dish. The restaurant also offers a 'Monday Martinis' special which has received positive mentions. However, some customer feedback suggests that while the restaurant may have been a popular spot in the past, its current appeal might be diminishing. One user specifically inquired about the quality of the dancing shrimp and whether the restaurant's perceived emptiness impacted the food.
"The 'dancing shrimp' are historically a highly recommended dish, and their 'Monday Martinis' special is also noted positively."
Customers have mixed feelings about Red Eye Grill. While some recall positive experiences, particularly with their 'dancing shrimp' and 'Monday Martinis' special, others suggest the restaurant may have passed its prime. One user who worked there in the late 90s and early 2000s praised the dancing shrimp and noted the restaurant's past success and prime location near Carnegie Hall as reasons for its continued operation. Another user mentioned it as a good spot after Carnegie Hall shows in the past, but questioned its current relevance. The restaurant is also noted for having private rooms, making it a potential venue for events.
Important Note
Some customers suggest the restaurant might be past its prime, despite its historical popularity and good location.
"The Red Eye Grill is noted for having private rooms, making it a potential option for the user's gathering of 25 people."
Positive"Redeye Grill is mentioned for its 'Monday Martinis' special."
Positive"User replies that Redeye Grill is very good, although they haven't visited in a while."
Positive"User, who worked there from '98 to '03, confirms the dancing shrimp were fantastic back then and the restaurant was very successful ($15 million/year). They attribute its current survival to being part of the Fireman group and its location near Carnegie Hall."
Positive"User feels Redeye Grill, like Rue 57, used to be a good spot after Carnegie Hall shows, but its time has passed."
Neutral"User asks about the quality of Redeye Grill, noting it seems empty despite being open, and specifically inquires if the dancing shrimp are as good as claimed."
Neutral"User mentions working at Redeye Grill for quite a few years and notes its similarities to Rue 57."
Neutral"pescatarian"
Neutral"Red Eye Grill."
Neutral
