TLDR
Classic Midtown spot blending old-school lounge vibes with live music and a sprawling American menu. Perfect for those seeking a reliable, high-energy dining experience near the heart of the city.
Details
Located in the heart of Midtown, this vibrant establishment offers a versatile American menu paired with a lively, old-school cocktail lounge atmosphere featuring live music [5]. While it serves as a reliable destination for a varied dining experience, including seafood and sushi, it is frequently noted for its accessible layout [2]. Diners often find the pricing to be on the higher side, frequently attributed to its prime location and service style [2], [3].
Food Overview
The menu features a broad range of American staples alongside a dedicated sushi bar [2], with some customers specifically highlighting the seafood and the burger as viable options [1], [2]. However, the quality is often described as inconsistent, with some guests feeling it doesn't quite justify the cost [3], [6].
Caveats
Be aware that the restaurant is often perceived as pricey for the quality of food provided [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About RED EYE GRILL
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Lunch Time Deals During Weekdays
"This user mentioned Red Eye Grill in Midtown East for its $32 two-course lunch deal, and also provided a link to a list of weekday lunch deals in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Moody Restaurants Around Central Park For
"This user recommended Red Eye Grill as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Cocktail Bar Midtown Near Rock
"Red Eye Grill is a large restaurant with live lounge-style music that is good for cocktails, though the food is considered average. It's a short walk from the original request location and usually has reservation availability."
NeutralFrom post: Quiet Cocktail With Lowkey Jazz Playing
"Red Eye Grill features live piano and singing on Thursdays through Saturdays, offering an old-school cocktail lounge vibe that might appeal, though it's not strictly jazz."
NeutralFrom post: Solo Birthday Dinner Rec
"Red Eye Grill is a popular restaurant with a varied menu."
PositiveFrom post: Seafood Recommendations Near 55 5 Vicinity
"RedEye Grill is recommended as a great seafood option."
PositiveFrom post: Midtown Good Food Low Mobility
"This comment agrees that Red Eye Grill has pretty good food but notes it can be too pricey, likely due to its location and service."
NeutralFrom post: Midtown Good Food Low Mobility
"Red Eye Grill is suggested as a good option for moms, offering basic American food and a sushi bar with few stairs. The comment notes the $30 burger is good but pricey due to location and service."
Positive