Classic American spot w/ sushi bar, known for 'dancing shrimp' & cocktails. Live music adds to the old-school vibe.
This classic American establishment, a fixture in Midtown, offers a diverse menu that includes a sushi bar and traditional American fare. While some diners recall its past glory days, particularly praising the 'dancing shrimp,' recent feedback suggests the food can be average, though the cocktails are consistently well-regarded. The restaurant also boasts live lounge-style music on select nights, adding to its ambiance.
This American restaurant features a varied menu, including a sushi bar and classic American dishes. While the 'dancing shrimp' is a dish fondly remembered from the past, current reviews suggest the food quality can be inconsistent, with some finding it average. However, the cocktails are generally praised, and it's noted as a good option for those seeking seafood.
"The 'dancing shrimp' is a dish that has received positive mentions from the past. Additionally, the martinis and cocktails are frequently recommended."
Customers recall a fond past for this establishment, especially for its seafood. While the food is considered average by some, the cocktails and ambiance, including live music, are frequently highlighted positively.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that while the food quality may be average, the prices can be high, potentially due to its prime location and service.
"This user mentioned Red Eye Grill in Midtown East for its $32 two-course lunch deal, and also provided a link to a list of weekday lunch deals in NYC."
Positive"This user recommended Red Eye Grill as a dining option."
Neutral"Red Eye Grill is a large restaurant with live lounge-style music that is good for cocktails, though the food is considered average. It's a short walk from the original request location and usually has reservation availability."
Neutral"Red Eye Grill features live piano and singing on Thursdays through Saturdays, offering an old-school cocktail lounge vibe that might appeal, though it's not strictly jazz."
Neutral"Red Eye Grill is a popular restaurant with a varied menu."
Positive"RedEye Grill is recommended as a great seafood option."
Positive"This comment agrees that Red Eye Grill has pretty good food but notes it can be too pricey, likely due to its location and service."
Neutral"Red Eye Grill is suggested as a good option for moms, offering basic American food and a sushi bar with few stairs. The comment notes the $30 burger is good but pricey due to location and service."
Positive"The Red Eye Grill is noted for having private rooms, making it a potential option for the user's gathering of 25 people."
Positive"Redeye Grill is mentioned for its 'Monday Martinis' special."
Positive"User replies that Redeye Grill is very good, although they haven't visited in a while."
Positive"User, who worked there from '98 to '03, confirms the dancing shrimp were fantastic back then and the restaurant was very successful ($15 million/year). They attribute its current survival to being part of the Fireman group and its location near Carnegie Hall."
Positive"User feels Redeye Grill, like Rue 57, used to be a good spot after Carnegie Hall shows, but its time has passed."
Neutral"User asks about the quality of Redeye Grill, noting it seems empty despite being open, and specifically inquires if the dancing shrimp are as good as claimed."
Neutral"User mentions working at Redeye Grill for quite a few years and notes its similarities to Rue 57."
Neutral"pescatarian"
Neutral"Red Eye Grill."
Neutral
