Step into a 1920s time capsule w/ classic diner faves, egg creams & hand-mixed Cokes. A true old-school NYC gem.
Step back in time at this charming 1920s luncheonette, a beloved fixture on the Upper East Side. Known for its classic American diner fare, this spot also boasts nostalgic treats like egg creams and hand-mixed Cokes. It's a quintessential New York experience, attracting both long-time locals and those seeking a taste of old-school charm.
This classic American diner offers traditional fare such as burgers and tuna melts, alongside nostalgic soda fountain drinks like egg creams and lime rickeys. While some reviewers highly recommend dishes like blueberry pancakes and root beer floats, others have encountered issues with portion size, blandness, and even reported pest sightings.
"Customers specifically recommend the blueberry pancakes for their quality. The root beer float is also highlighted as a delicious treat, especially for those seeking classic soda fountain offerings."
Customer feedback is highly polarized, with some praising the nostalgic atmosphere and classic diner food, while others report significant issues including cleanliness concerns and poor food quality.
Important Note
Recent reviews suggest the restaurant might be overcrowded with tourists due to social media fame, potentially impacting the experience. There are also significant negative reviews concerning cleanliness and food quality that contrast sharply with positive nostalgic accounts.
"User describes Lexington Candy Shop as a vintage 1925 luncheonette that makes you feel like you've gone back in time."
Positive"User states the food at Lexington Candy Shop is bad and tourists have ruined the vibe."
Negative"User provides a map link for Lexington Candy Shop."
Positive"User provides a map link for Lexington Candy Shop."
Positive"This commenter enthusiastically recommended Lexington Candy Shop, stating 'Nothing Beats Lexington Candy Shop.'"
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop on the Upper East Side is highly recommended, coming in second only to Clinton Street Bakery. Their blueberry pancakes are specifically praised, and everything there is described as amazing."
Positive"This user clarified that Lexington Candy Shop has fountain soda but not homemade syrup."
Neutral"This place was recommended for authentic homemade root beer. While they have fountain soda, it's not made with homemade syrup. However, a root beer float here was delicious."
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop is recommended as an alternative brunch spot. The commenter notes that while they also don't take reservations, wait times are typically not too long."
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop is noted as having solid diner food but is considered way overpriced."
Neutral"Responding to a negative review, this user states they were there yesterday and still loved Lexington Candy Shop."
Positive"This user reports that the luncheonette at Lexington Candy Shop is no longer good, citing disappointment with recent visits, lack of home fries with breakfast, and calling it a 'tik tok tourist trap'."
Negative"This user echoes the recommendation for Lexington Candy Shop, calling it so good."
Positive"This user describes the Lexington Candy Shop on East 83rd as a good old-school diner with good food and amazing floats from an old soda fountain."
Positive"This user gives a neutral rating of 'eh' to Lexington Candy Shop."
Neutral"This user states that Lexington Candy Shop is their all-day recommendation."
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop is listed as a place that serves Cherry Lime Rickeys."
Positive"A user praises a list of recommended diners, noting they were also going to recommend Lexington Candy Shop."
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop is recommended."
Neutral"Lexington Candy Shop on the Upper East Side is described as a really cool and charming place."
Positive
