TLDR
Vintage 1925 luncheonette serving classic diner comfort food and nostalgic, hand-mixed fountain sodas in an authentic, time-capsule setting.
Reddit Sentiment for LEXINGTON CANDY SHOP LUNCHEONETTE(based on 33 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The video features the traditional method of making a Coca-Cola beverage at Lexington Candy Shop, showcasing the syrup and soda being mixed directly at the counter. A person is then seen enjoying the freshly prepared drink, which is rated 8/10.
The Lexington Candy Shop & Luncheonette is highlighted as an iconic New York City establishment renowned for its authentic, old-fashioned soda fountain experience. The post specifically features their Coca-Cola soda, prepared using traditional methods reminiscent of those from a century ago, involving a combination of Coca-Cola syrup, carbonated water, and a scoop of whipped cream or ice cream, creating a nostalgic beverage that draws visitors seeking a taste of classic Americana. The restaurant itself has been operating for over 100 years, maintaining its vintage charm and service style.
This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its classic American sweet treats and diner fare.
Details
Established in 1925, this Upper East Side institution remains a beloved working-class luncheonette that transports visitors back in time with its vintage decor [1, 2]. While it serves classic diner fare like tuna melts and pancakes [1, 2], the establishment is equally famous for its traditional soda fountain, churning out authentic egg creams and hand-mixed sodas [1, 2]. Despite its viral popularity, it retains a charm that keeps locals and travelers returning for a quintessential New York experience [2].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on traditional American diner staples such as tuna melts, burgers, and fluffy pancakes [1, 2]. The soda fountain is a primary draw, noted specifically for its egg creams, lime rickeys, and chocolate milkshakes [1, 2, 4]. While many consider the food amazing and nostalgic, some critics feel the items are overpriced for the quality provided [3].
Highlights / Recommended
"The blueberry pancakes, tuna melts, and traditional fountain-style milkshakes and egg creams are frequently cited as the must-try items [1, 2, 4]."
Customer Sentiment
Visitor sentiment is generally highly positive, with many diners praising the authentic atmosphere and classic treats [1, 2]. However, some recent feedback suggests that increased popularity and tourist traffic have occasionally impacted the food quality and overall vibe for some patrons [1, 3].
Caveats
The shop closes at 6:00 PM, making it unsuitable for dinner plans [1]. Some visitors have noted long queues due to its viral status, and there are mixed opinions regarding whether the food quality matches the price [2, 3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LEXINGTON CANDY SHOP LUNCHEONETTE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Help With Casual Spot For Dinner After The Met On
"The commenter suggests visiting only for the novelty of the soda, as other food is mediocre and service is poor."
NegativeFrom post: Help With Casual Spot For Dinner After The Met On
"The commenter notes the restaurant closes by 6pm, making it potentially unsuitable for dinner plans."
NeutralFrom post: Help With Casual Spot For Dinner After The Met On
"The commenter mentions the restaurant prepares soda using traditional methods."
PositiveFrom post: Help With Casual Spot For Dinner After The Met On
"The commenter notes that the restaurant has the best milkshakes."
PositiveFrom post: Any Pancake Recommendations On Uws Ues Or Midtown
"This commenter considers Lexington Candy Shop their second favorite place for pancakes in the city, after Clinton Street."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This comment recommended Lexington Candy Shop for its egg creams, noting it as a place for classic soda fountain drinks."
PositiveFrom post: Another Pancake Question I Know Dont Hate Me
"Lexington Candy Shop is ranked as the commenter's #2 choice for pancakes, with Clinton Street Baking being their #1 choice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Reiterates the recommendation for Lexington Candy Store, noting it's an old soda shop with original interior, similar to a place they lived near previously."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Also recommends the Lexington Candy Store."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Simply recommends the Lexington Candy Store."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"This user recommends Lexington Candy Store for a traditional chocolate milkshake, highlighting its old-fashioned soda shop atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: Best Restaurants Around Memorial Sloan Kettering
"Lexington Candy Shop was identified as the best spot for breakfast and lunch."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User describes Lexington Candy Shop as a vintage 1925 luncheonette that makes you feel like you've gone back in time."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User states the food at Lexington Candy Shop is bad and tourists have ruined the vibe."
NegativeFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User provides a map link for Lexington Candy Shop."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User provides a map link for Lexington Candy Shop."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch Ues
"This commenter enthusiastically recommended Lexington Candy Shop, stating 'Nothing Beats Lexington Candy Shop.'"
PositiveFrom post: Very Good Pancakes Recommendation
"Lexington Candy Shop on the Upper East Side is highly recommended, coming in second only to Clinton Street Bakery. Their blueberry pancakes are specifically praised, and everything there is described as amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Homemade Root Beer In Nyc
"This user clarified that Lexington Candy Shop has fountain soda but not homemade syrup."
NeutralFrom post: Homemade Root Beer In Nyc
"This place was recommended for authentic homemade root beer. While they have fountain soda, it's not made with homemade syrup. However, a root beer float here was delicious."
Positive