Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 288-0057
Address: 1226 LEXINGTON AVENUE 10028
Old-school NYC luncheonette, soda fountain vibes, egg creams & lime rickeys galore. Cash-only, cash-register lottery tix.
Step back in time at this classic Upper East Side luncheonette, a true relic of old New York. It's a no-frills spot with a cash register that doubles as a lottery ticket vendor, serving up diner staples alongside nostalgic treats like lime rickeys and egg creams. While it might attract a TikTok crowd, it remains a working-class haven with a charmingly retro atmosphere.
This American diner offers classic fare like burgers and tuna melts, with a particular emphasis on old-fashioned soda fountain drinks such as lime rickeys and egg creams. While some customers find the food bland and portions small, others enjoy the nostalgic drinks and traditional diner experience. There are concerning reports of pest sightings and overall declining quality.
"The diner is noted for its old-fashioned soda fountain drinks like lime rickeys and egg creams, with the floats specifically described as 'amazing'."
Customer feedback is highly polarized, with some praising its nostalgic charm and classic diner fare, while others report significant issues including a cockroach sighting, bland food, and poor service.
Important Note
There are serious, recent negative reviews citing cockroach sightings, bland food, small portions, and a generally unpleasant experience. It's also described as a 'TikTok tourist trap' by some.
"Responding to a negative review, this user states they were there yesterday and still loved Lexington Candy Shop."
Positive"This user reports that the luncheonette at Lexington Candy Shop is no longer good, citing disappointment with recent visits, lack of home fries with breakfast, and calling it a 'tik tok tourist trap'."
Negative"This user echoes the recommendation for Lexington Candy Shop, calling it so good."
Positive"This user describes the Lexington Candy Shop on East 83rd as a good old-school diner with good food and amazing floats from an old soda fountain."
Positive"This user gives a neutral rating of 'eh' to Lexington Candy Shop."
Neutral"This user states that Lexington Candy Shop is their all-day recommendation."
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop is listed as a place that serves Cherry Lime Rickeys."
Positive"A user praises a list of recommended diners, noting they were also going to recommend Lexington Candy Shop."
Positive"Lexington Candy Shop is recommended."
Neutral"Lexington Candy Shop on the Upper East Side is described as a really cool and charming place."
Positive"The commenter confirms the presence of roaches at Lex Candy Shop and describes the place as nasty and overpriced."
Negative"The commenter states that the owner of Lexington Soda Shop is a "dickhead.""
Negative"The reviewer suggests to "absolute skip" this place, citing a cockroach sighting while eating, small portions, and bland food."
Negative"A commenter recommends Lexington Candy Shop on the Upper East Side, highlighting its well-maintained nostalgic atmosphere based on its website description."
Positive"Recommends Lexington Candy Shop (three blocks from the Met) as a cool, old-school soda fountain. Warns it might be crowded due to TikTok fame."
Positive"Mentions Lexington Candy Shop, a diner, is located near the Met."
Neutral
