Beloved neighborhood diner w/ a loyal following, known for standout pancakes & chili cheese onion omelets. A reliable spot for classic American breakfast.
This classic American diner is a beloved neighborhood staple, praised for its consistently good food and warm, familial atmosphere. Many patrons feel a strong connection to the staff, with some noting their visits span years and special occasions. It's a go-to spot for breakfast, offering reliable diner fare.
This American diner offers classic comfort food, with particular praise for its pancakes, waffles, and fries. The chili cheese onion omelet is frequently recommended, though some comments suggest omelets can sometimes be overcooked and dry. The Corned Beef Hash Benedict is also noted as a good option.
"Customers highly recommend the pancakes, waffles, and fries. The chili cheese onion omelet is also a popular choice, though it's noted that omelets can occasionally be overcooked."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards the diner, appreciating its consistent quality and the welcoming, long-standing relationships they've built with the staff over time.
Important Note
While many dishes are praised, one comment suggests that omelets can sometimes be overcooked and dry.
"Murray Hill Diner is suggested for its spinach pie, which is considered better than that found at most Greek restaurants."
Positive"Murray Hill Diner was suggested for a great classic diner breakfast."
Positive"Murray Hill Diner was listed as a recommendation for breakfast."
Neutral"This commenter expressed amusement at the idea of Murray Hill Diner being difficult to get into, humorously picturing a velvet rope and long reservation times."
Neutral"The author found Murray Hill Diner to be a convenient option for good, average diner food, specifically mentioning the Corned Beef Hash Benedict."
Positive"The commenter agrees that American diners often overcook omelets but specifies that the chili cheese onion omelet at Murray Hill Diner is the only one they've found to be well-balanced."
Neutral"While appreciating Murray Hill Diner as a friendly neighborhood option, the commenter notes that their omelets are generally overcooked, resulting in dry, browned eggs."
Neutral"After trying Murray Hill Diner based on recommendations, the commenter agrees that the pancakes are excellent."
Positive"Supporting a previous comment, the user affirms that not only their pancakes, but also their waffles and fries are excellent."
Positive"The commenter finds the description of the diner lovely and specifically notes that the chili cheese onion omelet sounds very good."
Positive"The commenter highly praises the pancakes at Murray Hill Diner, stating that no other restaurant can replicate their taste and implying they would "gatekeep" this secret."
Positive"This neighborhood diner is a beloved weekend ritual, offering a warm atmosphere where the staff has seen the commenter's family grow over time."
Positive"Murray Hill Diner is recommended."
Neutral"Murray Hill Diner is listed as a recommended diner."
Neutral"A user liked Murray Hill Diner, contrasting it with a very negative experience at Remedy Diner."
Positive"Murray Hill Diner on Lexington Sq. is praised as a great spot, with a user having visited three consecutive mornings during a week in December."
Positive"A commenter recommended Murray Hill Diner as one of the diner options in the Midtown/Murray Hill area for a picky eater."
Positive
