Iconic high tea and a beautiful bar, known for its Eloise-themed charm and upscale ambiance. A classic NYC experience, though food reviews are mixed.
Indulge in a classic New York experience with high tea at The Plaza. While some find the food to be subpar, the ambiance and themed attractions, particularly the Eloise experience for children, are often highlighted. It's a place for a beautiful bar with quality cocktails, or a spot for people-watching, though be prepared for premium pricing.
While some past reviews suggest the food at The Plaza is not good, particularly for casual dining, the high tea service in the Palm Court receives more positive mentions for its presentation and classic offerings like tea sandwiches and scones. However, the price point for these experiences is noted as being quite high.
"The high tea service, including tea sandwiches and scones, is frequently mentioned as a worthwhile experience, as are the cocktails at the bar."
Customer sentiment is divided, with praise for the ambiance and unique experiences like Eloise tea, but significant criticism regarding the quality and value of the food.
Important Note
The food at The Plaza has received negative reviews from some patrons, and prices for experiences like high tea are notably high.
"The commenter is addressing a question about attire for afternoon tea at The Plaza. They advise that the hotel will not prohibit entry based on walking shoes, but suggest bringing alternative shoes to enhance the elegant experience."
Neutral"A brief comment assuring the original poster that they will not have any issues with their shoes at The Plaza."
Neutral"The Plaza Hotel offers a Grand Imperial Afternoon Tea experience which includes a five-tier display of finger sandwiches, scones, Devonshire cream, and champagne."
Positive"The Plaza Food Hall was a favorite spot for showing visitors NYC, offering a way to have 'tea at the Plaza' without excessive cost, and previously housed Ladurée."
Positive"Recalling a mentorship breakfast at the Plaza Food Hall years ago, this user was impressed by the experience and the cost, spending $80 for two people."
Positive"This user mentions the 'Plaza food hall' as a past recommendation."
Neutral"The tea service at The Plaza is noted to be significantly more expensive now. Past experiences included a price around $130, with champagne at $25 extra. The menu structure was similar to previous ones, with tea sandwiches, scones, and a sweets layer. The food was fresh and the servers were helpful, and guests did not feel rushed."
Positive"The Plaza's tea service in the Palm Court is described as delightful, with a good tea selection. While currently more expensive, past experiences included tea sandwiches, scones, and sweets, and guests did not leave hungry. The food was fresh and the servers were helpful, with no feeling of being rushed."
Positive"The Palm Court at The Plaza was mentioned as a place that might be good for people-watching, especially after the holidays."
Positive"This user, who has done jobs at The Plaza's ballroom, also mentions ordering food from nearby places instead of the hotel's offerings."
Negative"This user, who previously worked at a nearby luxury hotel, corroborates the negative sentiment about The Plaza Hotel's food. They mention that guests from The Plaza would sometimes get to-go meals from their hotel."
Negative"This user states that the food at The Plaza Hotel is not good. This comment is in response to a post about the hotel's dining."
Negative"The original poster suggested afternoon tea at The Plaza as a gift idea."
Neutral"The bar at The Plaza was recommended for its beautiful ambiance and quality cocktails, though the user cautioned about the price."
Positive"The commenter suggests that doing a high tea in the city could be a cute activity for teens, citing the classic option at The Plaza Hotel."
Positive"The Palm Court at the Plaza is suggested as a beautiful bar option, with a prompt to 'look up'."
Positive"In a comment about Clark's Diner, the user mentioned that Clark's is 'better than Park Plaza.' This implies that Park Plaza is considered to be of lower quality than Clark's (which itself received mixed to negative reviews)."
Negative"The Plaza has Eloise-themed attractions and high tea, although the commenter questions its suitability for boys."
Neutral"The commenter recommends The Plaza only if the user is with kids for the Eloise experience. Otherwise, they suggest The Whitby Hotel or Bergdorf Goodman."
Neutral"The user is considering The Plaza for tea but questions if it's worth it, having found breakfast at Tiffany's (presumably at The Plaza) to be just okay."
Neutral
