TLDR
Unexpectedly great cheesesteaks & solid Italian-American fare w/ excellent pizza & apps. An underrated gem.
Details
This Brooklyn Italian spot offers a surprising take on classic comfort food. While known for its Italian-American fare, it's also surprisingly praised for its elevated yet unpretentious cheesesteaks. Customers have had a range of experiences, with some noting it as just 'ok' while others rave about their pizzas and appetizers.
Food Overview
This Italian-American restaurant is noted for its pizzas and appetizers, with some customers having great experiences. Interestingly, it also receives praise for its cheesesteaks, which are described as high-quality without being overly fancy. However, not all reviews are positive, with one mentioning the restaurant as just 'ok'.
Caveats
One review describes the restaurant as 'just ok,' indicating that experiences may vary.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PEPPINO'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Italian American Spots
"This user stated they had a great pizza and a few appetizers at Peppino's in Bay Ridge during an annual trip."
PositiveFrom post: Italian American Spots
"This user mentioned Peppino's in Bay Ridge and described it as just 'ok'. However, another user later mentioned having a great pizza and a few appetizers there."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For The Best Ny Style Pizza In
"Recommends Peppino's on 5th as an underrated option, especially if visiting Green-wood Cemetery."
Positive