TLDR
Old-school Italian bakery in the West Village known for its authentic, high-value cannoli, cookies, and citrus-scented black and white cookies.
Reddit Sentiment for PASTICCERIA ROCCO(based on 15 Reddit opinions)
Details
Since 1974, this West Village institution has served as a go-to destination for authentic Italian pastries and desserts [1]. Often praised as a superior, higher-value alternative to tourist-heavy spots, the bakery offers an extensive selection of classic treats [2], [3]. While most patrons consider it a reliable staple for sweets, experiences can occasionally be inconsistent [4].
Food Overview
This classic bakery specializes in traditional Italian desserts, with standout items including cannoli, tiramisu, and various cookies sold by the pound [1], [2], [6]. Diners specifically recommend the stracciatella gelato, chocolate cannoli, and the unique, citrus-scented black and white cookie [1], [3], [7]. While the bakery is widely celebrated for its quality, one customer felt the offerings did not meet their personal standards [2].
Highly recommended items include the chocolate cannoli, sfogliatella, stracciatella gelato, and their signature citrus-scented black and white cookie [1], [3], [7]. Customers also frequently suggest purchasing an assortment of Italian cookies by the pound [6].
Overall sentiment is highly positive, with many diners championing the shop as a local staple for quality Italian sweets [2], [5]. However, some visitors have reported mixed experiences regarding service and product consistency [4].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01cannoli2 mentions
- 02black and white cookie2 mentions
Caveats
Some visitors report that service can be inconsistent, and at least one customer noted the overall quality did not meet their expectations [2], [4]. Additionally, it remains unclear if all cannoli are filled strictly to order [8].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PASTICCERIA ROCCO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Nyc Little Italy Restaurant And Pastry Shop
"Recommended specifically for Italian desserts."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Little Italy Restaurant And Pastry Shop
"Suggested as a great alternative to East Side dessert shops for those in the West Village/W4 area."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find Good Italian Bakery Cookies In
"The user believes Rocco's does not meet the level of quality they desire."
NegativeFrom post: Where Can I Find Good Italian Bakery Cookies In
"The user specifically praises their gelato."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find Good Italian Bakery Cookies In
"Mentions Rocco's as a commonly recommended spot."
Positive