Next.js logo

THE PENNY FARTHING

Updated

Phone: (212) 387-7300

Address: 103 3 AVENUE 10003

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Seafood mecca w/ bar seating! Rave reviews for oysters & razor clams, though some say it's pricey. Ideal for solo diners.

Reddit Sentiment for THE PENNY FARTHING(based on 16 Reddit opinions)

63% Positive25% Neutral13% Negative

Tags

american 6seafood 4modern american 3seafood 10View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Details

This American restaurant is a celebrated spot for seafood lovers, with many patrons raving about their exceptional oyster selection and razor clams. While some find the experience a bit pricey for the portion sizes, others praise the fantastic service and delicious, well-prepared dishes. It's noted for its unique all-bar seating, which can be ideal for solo diners or those looking for a more interactive meal.

Food Overview

This establishment is highly recommended for its seafood offerings, with many guests specifically calling out the oysters and razor clams as standouts, some even declaring them the best they've ever had. While most feedback on food is positive, one reviewer felt the food wasn't unique enough to justify the cost, and another found it not suitable for a full sit-down dinner.

Highlights / Recommended

The oysters and razor clams are frequently highlighted as must-try dishes, with some patrons calling them the best they've ever had. Overall, the seafood selection is a strong point.

Customer Sentiment

Customers largely have a positive sentiment, praising the exceptional seafood, particularly oysters and razor clams, and commending the great service. However, a few find the prices high relative to portion sizes, and one review criticized the overall atmosphere and service.

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    oysters
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE PENNY FARTHING

Newish dinner that has blown you away range
Multiple users recommend this restaurant for a fantastic dining experience, with one specifically mentioning it was an excellent birthday dinner with the best oysters ever and fantastic service. Another user preferred it over a different establishment after pre-dinner drinks.
What are your favorite seafood dishes in NYC?
This restaurant is highly praised for its seafood, with one user specifically recommending the razor clams and stating that 'everything else they have' is also great. Another user declared the oysters served here as the best of their life.
Sunday night dinner, solo diner, bar seating
This restaurant is suggested as a great option for solo diners due to its exclusive bar seating, making it easy to get a spot. The commenter highlights its good lighting, interactive bar, and seafood selection.
For fish and chips, Dame or a Salt and Battery?
One user recommends this restaurant as a superior seafood option compared to Dame, implying it's a strong choice for seafood-focused dining.
The 25 Best Restaurants in NYC | The Infatuation
Opinions are mixed on this restaurant's inclusion on a 'best of' list. While one user had a very positive experience contrasting with others who found it over-hyped, another found the food overpriced for the portion size and not unique enough.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Seafood Recommendations Near 55 5 Vicinity

"Penny is suggested as a seafood dining option."

Positive
Sep 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where Are The Service Industry Peeps Dining

"This is listed as a recommendation."

Neutral
Sep 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Go To Repeat Restaurant

"This restaurant is listed as a repeat spot."

Positive
Aug 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Go To Repeat Restaurant

"This restaurant is mentioned."

Positive
Aug 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Seeking Birthday Restaurant Recommendations

"The user recommended Penny as a potential dining option."

Positive
Aug 16, 2025View Comment →

More in East Village

See all

More American in NYC

See all