TLDR
Innovative Jewish-inspired deli sandwiches and signature tahini coffee slushies in a vibrant, counter-service setting. Famous for creative takes on classics like the pastrami chopped cheese.
Reddit Sentiment for EDITH'S SANDWICH COUNTER(based on 82 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Edith's collaborated with Moonburger on a special chicken sandwich available for one day only on August 21st. The sandwich features their signature chicken breast tossed with zaatar and confit garlic mayo, served on a potato bun. The author implied a positive experience by rating it highly.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is highlighted as one of the best places for sandwiches in New York City, particularly for its highly anticipated summer specials available for a limited time. The video showcases the establishment's bustling counter-service atmosphere and its unique beverage offerings, emphasizing the quality and popularity of its seasonal menu items. The focus is on unique and high-quality ingredients, such as lobster flown in daily from Maine for the Lobster Club and heirloom tomatoes for the BLT, making it a must-visit destination for sandwich enthusiasts.
Edith's is presented as a creative sandwich counter offering unique and refreshing options. The video gives a peek at the counter and menu before showcasing an appealing iced coffee beverage. It then highlights two distinctive sandwiches: a vibrant BLT-style sandwich that includes bacon, lettuce, tomato, and an unexpected addition of corn, and a fresh lobster sandwich featuring generous chunks of lobster meat, avocado, and greens. The focus is on innovative twists to classic sandwiches.
Edith's Sandwich Counter in The West Village & Williamsburg is showcased for its tuna melt. The sandwich is generously filled and appears to be a delectable option for sandwich enthusiasts.
The post highlights a refreshing blended drink from Edith's, a sandwich counter located in NYC. The image prominently displays the restaurant's logo on the to-go cup. The drink itself appears to be a sweet and creamy beverage, garnished with a caramel-like drizzle and possibly cookie crumbles, making it an ideal treat for a hot day.
Edith's is a sandwich counter in The West Village, NYC, serving up a variety of popular sandwiches. The author specifically showcases 'The Edith' and the 'Chicken Schnitzel Club', noting their substantial fillings and appetizing presentation. The post implies a positive dining experience with these offerings.
Edith's offers a fulfilling Fried Chicken Caesar Wrap, combining crispy fried chicken pieces with fresh greens and a creamy Caesar dressing, all rolled into a convenient wrap. This option is perfect for those seeking a hearty and flavorful twist on the classic Caesar.
Edith's makes the shortlist with two distinct items: a creative pastrami chopped cheese sandwich and a refreshing iced cold brew slushie, showcasing its diverse menu of impressive offerings.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is included among the favorites for its tuna melt, implying a satisfying and well-prepared sandwich offering.
Edith's chocolate chip cookie is lauded as a very strong contender, coming exceptionally close to unseating the author's number one favorite. This indicates a superb quality and highly satisfying taste experience.
Will Hartman reviews Edith's Sandwich Counter, a West Village spot praised for its Jewish-inspired sandwiches like the standout Sephardi Breakfast Wrap and popular coffee slushies. The review highlights the flaky malawach flatbread as a unique base for breakfast options.
Details
Edith's Sandwich Counter, with locations in Williamsburg and the West Village, is a celebrated destination for creative, globally-influenced Jewish deli sandwiches [1]. Diners frequently rave about their unique menu items, such as the pastrami chopped cheese [11] and the seasonal corn BLT [36], alongside their signature tahini-infused coffee slushies [1], [11], [46]. While the restaurant is widely lauded for its high-quality ingredients and inventive flavor profiles [11], [21], [46], it does face occasional criticism regarding high price points [4], [23], [46] and some issues with sandwich structural integrity [1], [8], [46].
Food Overview
The cuisine centers on creative, elevated takes on Jewish deli traditions, with the Sephardi Breakfast Wrap [1], [21] and pastrami chopped cheese [11], [21] being frequent crowd favorites. Other highly recommended items include the tuna melt [21], [40], chicken schnitzel club [1], [21], and their distinctively thin, caramel-glazed chocolate chip cookies [39], [43]. Some guests express frustration with the construction of bagel-based sandwiches, often finding them difficult to eat [1], [8], [46].
Highlights / Recommended
"The pastrami chopped cheese [11], [37], Sephardi Breakfast Wrap [1], [46], and the signature tahini-infused coffee slushies are consistently highly recommended [11], [46]. The seasonal corn BLT and chicken schnitzel club also receive strong praise from regular visitors [1], [36], [46]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chicken schnitzel club(5)
- •tuna melt(4)
- •pastrami chopped cheese(3)
- •corn blt(3)
- •blt(3)
- •sephardi breakfast wrap(3)
- •iced cafe slushie(2)
- •sephardi wrap(2)
- •the carmela(2)
- •the edith(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is strongly positive, with many diners considering it a go-to spot for indulgent, flavorful meals [21], [46]. However, some patrons note that the high prices and occasional difficulties with the construction of certain sandwiches can impact the value proposition [4], [46].
Caveats
Several diners report that some sandwiches, particularly the bagel varieties, can be messy and difficult to consume [8], [46]. Additionally, some visitors find the price point high for the portion sizes [4], [23], [46].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EDITH'S SANDWICH COUNTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"Recommended for their current seasonal corn BLT."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"The user felt the sandwich was too greasy."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"Recommended spot for a sandwich."
NeutralFrom post: I Need A List Of Quintessential Nyc Drinks That
"Suggested for its tahini coffee slush or apple cider slush."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"This user agrees about the corn BLT, having eaten many of them when it's in season, despite the cost."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user eagerly anticipates Edith's seasonal corn BLT, calling it perfect and worth the high price."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"This user recommends trying the tuna melt at Edith's, finding it fantastic."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user agrees that the Sephardi breakfast wrap on malawach is excellent but acknowledges it's a pricey treat, echoing sentiments about the bagel sandwich's construction."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user finds the bagel sandwiches at Edith's difficult to eat due to their construction, and while breakfast wraps are good, they are considered expensive for the portion size."
NegativeFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user is looking forward to a future collaboration between Edith's and Turkey and the Wolf, but will be out of town during the event."
NeutralFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"This user finds Edith's breakfast sandwiches incredible but feels the lunch sandwiches are underwhelming compared to their appearance. They are looking forward to a future collaboration with Turkey and the Wolf."
NeutralFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user enjoyed the bulgogi cheesesteak collaboration at Edith's and was surprisingly impressed by their tahini oat coffee slushie, despite not usually liking tahini. They noted the locations are inconvenient and the prices are high."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"The original poster mentioned Edith's, noting that their coffee tahini slushie spiritually aligns with their interest in unique flavor combinations for shakes."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Have Any Chicken Cutlet Sandwich Recs Have
"Recommends the chicken schnitzel club at Edith's in the West Village, stating they have thoroughly enjoyed it."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Chicken Caesar Wrap
"This commenter expressed interest in trying the tahini caesar dressing from Edith's."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Chicken Caesar Wrap
"This commenter recommended Edith's Sandwich Counter for a less conventional but delicious and substantial chicken caesar wrap."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Chicken Caesar Wrap
"This commenter praised Edith's for a great chicken caesar wrap that includes tahini caesar dressing."
PositiveFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This commenter agrees that Edith's cookie is their single favorite dessert item in NYC and visits their West Village location multiple times a week just for the cookie."
PositiveFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This user identifies Edith's as the place they recently had an exceptional tahini chocolate chip cookie. However, they find it very expensive and think their bagels are bad, though the wrap bread is good."
NeutralFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This user highlights Edith's chocolate chip cookie as the best thing they serve, describing it as thin, melty, chewy, and having a unique brown butter caramel flavor that sets it apart."
Positive