TLDR
Jewish-inspired sandwiches and creative tahini-infused slushies served in a charming, counter-service setting. Known for unique flavor combinations like the pastrami chopped cheese and seasonal corn BLT.
Reddit Sentiment for EDITH'S SANDWICH COUNTER(based on 81 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The reviewer loved the drinks from Edith's Sandwich Counter, describing them as not too sweet, super refreshing, and unique due to the tahini, deeming them worth the hype. The cost was approximately $12.
Edith's collaborated with Moonburger on a special chicken sandwich available for one day only on August 21st. The sandwich features their signature chicken breast tossed with zaatar and confit garlic mayo, served on a potato bun. The author implied a positive experience by rating it highly.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is highlighted as one of the best places for sandwiches in New York City, particularly for its highly anticipated summer specials available for a limited time. The video showcases the establishment's bustling counter-service atmosphere and its unique beverage offerings, emphasizing the quality and popularity of its seasonal menu items. The focus is on unique and high-quality ingredients, such as lobster flown in daily from Maine for the Lobster Club and heirloom tomatoes for the BLT, making it a must-visit destination for sandwich enthusiasts.
Edith's is presented as a creative sandwich counter offering unique and refreshing options. The video gives a peek at the counter and menu before showcasing an appealing iced coffee beverage. It then highlights two distinctive sandwiches: a vibrant BLT-style sandwich that includes bacon, lettuce, tomato, and an unexpected addition of corn, and a fresh lobster sandwich featuring generous chunks of lobster meat, avocado, and greens. The focus is on innovative twists to classic sandwiches.
Edith's Sandwich Counter in The West Village & Williamsburg is showcased for its tuna melt. The sandwich is generously filled and appears to be a delectable option for sandwich enthusiasts.
The post highlights a refreshing blended drink from Edith's, a sandwich counter located in NYC. The image prominently displays the restaurant's logo on the to-go cup. The drink itself appears to be a sweet and creamy beverage, garnished with a caramel-like drizzle and possibly cookie crumbles, making it an ideal treat for a hot day.
Edith's is a sandwich counter in The West Village, NYC, serving up a variety of popular sandwiches. The author specifically showcases 'The Edith' and the 'Chicken Schnitzel Club', noting their substantial fillings and appetizing presentation. The post implies a positive dining experience with these offerings.
Edith's offers a fulfilling Fried Chicken Caesar Wrap, combining crispy fried chicken pieces with fresh greens and a creamy Caesar dressing, all rolled into a convenient wrap. This option is perfect for those seeking a hearty and flavorful twist on the classic Caesar.
Edith's makes the shortlist with two distinct items: a creative pastrami chopped cheese sandwich and a refreshing iced cold brew slushie, showcasing its diverse menu of impressive offerings.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is included among the favorites for its tuna melt, implying a satisfying and well-prepared sandwich offering.
Will Hartman reviews Edith's Sandwich Counter, a West Village spot praised for its Jewish-inspired sandwiches like the standout Sephardi Breakfast Wrap and popular coffee slushies. The review highlights the flaky malawach flatbread as a unique base for breakfast options.
Details
Edith's Sandwich Counter, with locations in Williamsburg and the West Village, is a celebrated destination for inventive sandwiches influenced by global Jewish traditions [1]. The menu features standout items like the pastrami chopped cheese [2], the Sephardi Breakfast Wrap on malawach [1], [5], and a unique seasonal corn BLT [3]. While the food receives widespread acclaim for its quality and flavor, some patrons note that the bagel sandwiches can be difficult to construct and that the restaurant is on the pricier side [4], [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Jewish-deli classics with a modern, international twist, offering items such as chicken schnitzel, reubens, and hearty breakfast wraps on Yemeni malawach [1], [5]. Highly recommended dishes include the pastrami chopped cheese, the Sephardi Breakfast Wrap, and the seasonal corn BLT [2], [3], [5], while the chocolate chip cookies and tahini slushies are frequently cited as must-try treats [2], [4], [5]. Some guests have found the standard bagels to be dense [1], [4] and occasional sandwiches, such as the BLT, can be perceived as overly greasy [3].
The pastrami chopped cheese is a frequent crowd favorite [2], [5], along with the Sephardi Breakfast Wrap [1], [5], the tuna melt [5], and the seasonal corn BLT [3]. For beverages and desserts, the tahini-based coffee slushie and chocolate chip cookies are highly recommended [2], [4], [5].
Overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with diners frequently praising the restaurant's high-quality ingredients and creative menu innovation [2], [5]. Some visitors express frustration regarding price points, occasional portion sizing, and the structural integrity of certain bagel-based sandwiches [4], [5].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01chicken schnitzel club5 mentions
- 02tuna melt4 mentions
- 03corn blt4 mentions
- 04blt4 mentions
- 05pastrami chopped cheese3 mentions
- 06sephardi breakfast wrap3 mentions
Caveats
Some diners find the sandwiches to be expensive [4], [5], and the construction of bagel-based sandwiches can make them messy to eat [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EDITH'S SANDWICH COUNTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: This Might Be One Of The Best Pastrami Sandwiches
"Recommended as a West Village spot for a modern take on Jewish deli classics."
PositiveFrom post: Its Tomato Season What Are Your Favorite Tomato
"A user expresses a mixed opinion on the BLT, noting the tomato quantity is high but the structural ratio of ingredients is off."
NeutralFrom post: Its Tomato Season What Are Your Favorite Tomato
"The BLT with corn mayo is a highly recommended and flavor-packed dish."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"Recommended for their current seasonal corn BLT."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Absolute Goated Blt In This Fine City
"The user felt the sandwich was too greasy."
Negative