TLDR
Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels featuring creative cream cheese spreads and standout French toast varieties.
Reddit Sentiment for TOMPKINS SQUARE BAGELS(based on 23 Reddit opinions)
Details
Celebrated for its consistently high-quality bagels and an imaginative selection of creative cream cheese flavors, this East Village destination is a must-visit spot [2]. The menu features traditional options like plain or pumpernickel, but truly shines with unique specialty offerings such as French toast and chocolate chip bagels [1]. Whether enjoyed on their own or customized into hearty sandwiches, the food here earns high praise from locals and visitors alike [1], [2].
Food Overview
Known for its reliably well-made bagels and extensive, inventive cream cheese selection, the shop is a standout for both traditionalists and those seeking flavor experimentation [1], [2]. Highly recommended items include the everything pumpernickel and bagels paired with lox and scallion cream cheese [1], [18], while the tofu schmears are noted as a solid choice for vegan options [4].
Caveats
Be prepared for significant wait times on weekends, which can range from 25 to 45 minutes, though the line generally moves at a steady pace [8], [9], [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TOMPKINS SQUARE BAGELS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Are The Best Bagels To Pair With A Spread
"This user strongly recommends Tompkins Square Bagels in the East Village as the best."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Bagels To Pair With A Spread
"This user notes that many people swear by Tompkins Square Bagels."
PositiveFrom post: Local Ny Birthday Food Crawl East Village And
"The commenter recommended Tompkins Square Bagels, specifically highlighting the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"The original poster is looking for bagel recommendations that freeze and deliver well, as they currently use Tompkins Square Bagels and are seeking variety."
NeutralFrom post: Best Meal Around Tompkins Square Before Meeting
"Tompkins Square Bagels is enthusiastically recommended."
PositiveFrom post: The 17 Best Bagels In New York City Right Now
"This user agreed that Tompkins Square Bagels are the best, particularly praising their bagels and cream cheese."
PositiveFrom post: Tompkins Square Bagels At 1 On A Saturday
"Responding to a question about bringing food into Lucinda's, this user believes the owners are laid back but is unsure about outside food policies. They mentioned the Ave A store is their favorite."
NeutralFrom post: The 17 Best Bagels In New York City Right Now
"This user expressed strong positive sentiment towards Tompkins Square Bagels, indicating it is a favorite location."
PositiveFrom post: Tompkins Square Bagels At 1 On A Saturday
"The manager of Tompkins Square Bagels (Ave A and 2 Ave locations) noted that wait times may be slightly shorter due to fewer students from nearby schools. They also mention that Union Sq and UES locations are always busy on weekends and invited the user to visit."
PositiveFrom post: Tompkins Square Bagels At 1 On A Saturday
"The user suggests that at 1 PM on a Saturday, the wait time at Tompkins Square Bagels should be around 15-20 minutes, as it moves fairly quickly."
NeutralFrom post: Tompkins Square Bagels At 1 On A Saturday
"This user is defending a previous comment about wait times at Tompkins Square Bagels, stating it is accurate for a weekend."
NeutralFrom post: Tompkins Square Bagels At 1 On A Saturday
"A user commented that there will be a line and a wait of at least 25-45 minutes for food at Tompkins Square Bagels on a weekend."
NegativeFrom post: Tompkins Square Bagels At 1 On A Saturday
"The user mentions that there will be a line at Tompkins Square Bagels, but it moves quickly enough to wait in."
NeutralFrom post: Delibagels In Lower Manhattan
"This user recounted an incident at Tompkins Square Bagels where an employee incorrectly charged them $55 for one bagel with lox."
NegativeFrom post: Delibagels In Lower Manhattan
"This user also really likes Tompkins Square Bagels."
PositiveFrom post: Delibagels In Lower Manhattan
"Tompkins Square Bagels is considered top-tier by this user, though they have experienced some rough customer service there."
PositiveFrom post: Budget Hacks
"Tompkins Square Bagel was listed as a good option for bagels and sandwiches, fitting a budget."
PositiveFrom post: Authenticold Fashioned Ny Restaurants With Vegan
"This user recommended Tompkins Square Bagels, specifically mentioning their tofu schmears as being pretty good."
PositiveFrom post: Pork Bacon Egg And Cheese
"A commenter recommended Tompkins Square Bagels, noting they have two locations in the East Village and apologized for unhelpful responses from others."
PositiveFrom post: Eating My Way Through Your City
"This commenter appreciates the detailed review but humorously reacts to the idea of a French toast bagel BEC with maple cream cheese."
Neutral