Old-school Midtown Italian w/ formal atmosphere & fantastic food. Considered the best Italian in the area by many.
Experience a taste of classic, old-school Italian dining in the heart of Midtown. This establishment is praised for its formal atmosphere and fantastic food, offering a traditional Northern Italian culinary journey. While some might find it a bit formal, it's considered by many to be the best Italian option in the area, perfect for those seeking an authentic and refined experience.
The food is consistently described as fantastic, with a focus on traditional Northern Italian cuisine. Dishes like Paglia Fieno and linguini vongole have been positively mentioned. It is widely considered one of the best Italian options in Midtown.
"Paglia Fieno and linguini vongole are specifically mentioned as positively received dishes."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, often recommending it for its old-school charm and excellent food, though some find it a bit too formal.
Important Note
Some find the atmosphere to be a bit too formal or potentially boring compared to other establishments. It is also described as an 'expense account place'.
"This commenter described Il Tinello as an 'expense account place' and also suggested Little Alley on 37th street for Chinese food."
Neutral"This commenter suggested Il Tinello."
Neutral"The commenter described Il Tinello as a classic, old-school, expensive, but very good Northern Italian restaurant. They noted it might be considered boring by some, contrasting it with Trattoria Dell'Arte for a more upbeat atmosphere."
Positive"Replying to a question about Il Tinello, the commenter agreed it is the best Italian right now in Midtown, referring specifically to the one in E46 (Midtown East)."
Positive"The commenter recommended Il Tinello as the best Italian option in Midtown, also mentioning Toscana 49 as good."
Positive"Paglia Fieno and linguini vongole at Il Tinello were mentioned positively."
Positive"The atmosphere at il Tinello is described as sedate, old school, and quiet. However, the commenter suggests considering Santi or Casa Lever as alternatives."
Neutral"Il Tinello is listed as an Italian restaurant suggestion."
Positive"Il Tinello is listed as an Italian restaurant suggestion."
Positive"Il Tinello is recommended for old-school Italian dining."
Positive"Il Tinello was suggested as a dinner option for a group meeting in NYC."
Neutral"Il Tinello is listed as a general recommendation."
Neutral"The commenter personally does not find Il Tinello, among other listed restaurants in the West 50s, to be very good."
Negative"The commenter sarcastically lists Il Tinello as 'crap' in the West 50s, humorously implying it is actually a good restaurant."
Positive"The commenter highly recommends Il Tinello for an old-school Midtown experience, describing its formal atmosphere and fantastic food."
Positive"The commenter prefers their other suggestions over Il Tinello."
Negative
