TLDR
Upscale Mexican-inspired tasting menus with generous portions and must-try churros. A high-value alternative to downtown dining that consistently exceeds expectations.
Details
Offering an upscale take on Mexican and Central American cuisine, this Brooklyn destination is widely celebrated for its high-value tasting menus [1], [2], [14]. Diners frequently highlight the restaurant's generous portions and impressive 10-course prix fixe options that provide exceptional quality for the price [3], [11], [13]. As the sister restaurant to the renowned Traif, it consistently wins over guests with its creative small plates and thoughtful cocktail program [7], [8], [16].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Mexican and Central American small plates, highlighted by a $55 ten-course tasting experience [13], [14]. Standout dishes include the osso bucco carnitas [13], a memorable large-format goat neck [17], and green tea churros served with passion fruit sauce [6], [20]. Diners appreciate the variety, though some note the consistency of the extensive tasting menu can vary slightly [13].
Customer Sentiment
Patrons generally view the experience as a high-value, memorable choice that frequently exceeds expectations [11], [21]. While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive regarding the food and drink, some diners note that the overall atmosphere could benefit from a decor refresh [4], [16].
Caveats
The churros are best enjoyed on-site rather than taken to-go for optimal quality [20]. Some visitors feel the interior decor is ready for an update [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About XIXA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Restaurant In Nyc You Can Find A Table On
"Mentioned as a restaurant in South Williamsburg."
NeutralFrom post: My 1 Year Anniversary Is Coming Up And I Want To
"Similar to Traif, it is casual but fits the budget well."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"This user lists Xixa as a place that exceeded expectations."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Spanish Style Churros
"This user suggested Xixa for great churros, but noted that they must be eaten at the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Havent Been In Nyc Since 2020 Michelin Quality
"Xixa is recommended as one of many great options outside of lower Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Havent Been In Nyc Since 2020 Michelin Quality
"Xixa is recommended as one of many great options outside of lower Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: The Highs And Lows Of Eating Goat In New York
"This user recalled Xixa having a great and memorable large format goat neck dish, though they are unsure if it was a special or is still on the menu."
PositiveFrom post: Noksu Vs Traif Corima Or Third Option
"Xixa has a better cocktail menu than Traif if drinks are a priority. While Traif is found to be better overall, Xixa still offers good food."
PositiveFrom post: Noksu Vs Traif Corima Or Third Option
"Xixa, the sister restaurant to Traif, is considered slightly better by the commenter."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting From Toronto What Are The Most New York
"Xixa is mentioned as an upscale option for Mexican and Central American cuisine in NYC, recommended for those looking to explore this food category."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Mexican Food Sit Down Restaurant
"Xixa offers a 10-course prix fixe menu with a large amount of food for $55, though not all dishes were spectacular, the osso bucco carnitas was highly praised."
NeutralFrom post: Recs For Fusionethnic Small Plates
"The commenter listed Xixa as one of many restaurant recommendations."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Trip Itinerary
"Xixa is the recommended choice over Traif, offering a great deal with its set menu, and the portions are generous."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Trip Itinerary
"Xixa is recommended over Traif as it is the sister restaurant and considered better by the commenter."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Find Passion Fruit Dessert In Brooklyn
"Xixa is recommended for its green tea churro, which comes with two sauces including passion fruit."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Dining Experiences Like Traif Under 100
"The user simply recommends Xixa."
NeutralFrom post: Restaurant Dining Experiences Like Traif Under 100
"The user suggests Xixa, Traif's sister restaurant, noting it offers similar pricing but with more Mexican-inspired dishes."
NeutralFrom post: Restaurant Dining Experiences Like Traif Under 100
"The user recommends Xixa as another restaurant by the same owners as Traif."
NeutralFrom post: Williamsburg And Greenpoint Dining Solo Eat
"Xixa is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: A Nice Dinner For Some Reasonably Broke College
"Xixa is mentioned alongside Traif as potentially offering the best course menu deals in NYC."
Positive