A legendary Brooklyn Italian gem, famed for its exquisite pasta, chic ambiance, and sought-after reservations.
Bryan Kim reviews Lilia, an Italian restaurant in Williamsburg, praising its enduring popularity and evolution into a neighborhood favorite. The review highlights standout dishes like agnolotti and focaccia, and notes the restaurant's increasingly accessible reservations.
Lilia in Williamsburg is a highly successful Italian restaurant celebrated for its excellent pasta program, casually elegant ambiance, and standout dishes like spaghetti with anchovies.
Lilia, a celebrated Italian restaurant in Brooklyn, has solidified its reputation as a beloved neighborhood spot with an exceptional pasta program. The casually elegant ambiance, coupled with an open kitchen, consistently delivers memorable dishes like the signature agnolotti and focaccia. While reservations were once notoriously difficult, Lilia has become more accessible, making its acclaimed cuisine and inviting atmosphere available to more diners.
Lilia is highly acclaimed for its Italian cuisine, particularly its pasta dishes, with many considering them among the best in the city. Specific recommendations include the Agnolotti, French Onion Ravioli, and various other pasta creations. Some reviewers mention that while pasta is a highlight, other dishes like grilled items and desserts also receive positive remarks. A few negative comments exist, with one user finding key pasta dishes to be misses and another labeling the restaurant as overhyped.
"Lilia is highly recommended for its pasta, with the Agnolotti, French Onion Ravioli, and Mafaldini being frequently mentioned as must-tries. The focaccia, grilled lamb, and a unique olive oil gelato are also popular choices."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Lilia, frequently praising its exceptional pasta dishes and overall dining experience. While many find it a must-visit, a few have noted it didn't live up to expectations or found some dishes to be uninspired.
Important Note
Securing a reservation at Lilia can be challenging, with some users reporting difficulty even for unpopular times. One user also noted that the restaurant can sometimes lack consistency.
"The user likes Lilia's soft serve, specifically mentioning the combination with olive oil, honey, and sea salt."
Positive"The author recommends Lilia's "Italian Job" soft serve, which is also available at Lilia Caffè."
Positive"This is described as a legendary Italian restaurant famous for its pastas, and one of the hardest reservations to get in Brooklyn."
Positive"Lilia is recommended as a solid dining choice. The user is seeking a comparison between Lilia and Misi."
Positive"This user mentioned that getting a reservation at Lilia is very difficult. They have tried Misi and found it good but not spectacular."
Neutral"The user is arguing that Misi is more vegetarian-friendly than Lilia."
Negative"Lilia is listed among restaurants known for some of the best pasta in the city, although reservations can be difficult."
Positive"Lilia is listed as a recommended restaurant."
Neutral"Lilia is recommended as a great option for dining."
Positive"The sheep's milk agnolotti at Lilia was mentioned as a dish that prompted a return visit."
Positive"Lilias bakery is listed as a place to get soft serve."
Neutral"Lilia has many vegetarian appetizers and pastas, providing ample options for vegetarians."
Positive"The commenter would have the cured sardine roast, lamb steak with fennel salad, and sheep's cheese agnolotti from Lilia, citing nostalgia from a first date, but also mentioned JG Melon for personal reasons."
Positive"Lilia was listed as a favorite Italian restaurant."
Positive"Lilia was recommended for its pasta dishes, including the agnolotti, and other items like fritelle and broccoli, suggesting it has options for picky eaters."
Positive"Lilia was mentioned as an Italian option for pasta, though the commenter personally had not enjoyed their meals there, noting that others seem to like it."
Neutral"Lilia in Brooklyn is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"Lilia is recommended for its vibes, food, and drinks and is noted as being easily walkable on a Tuesday."
Positive"Lilia in Williamsburg is mentioned as one of the user's upscale favorites."
Positive"Lilia is listed as a place with good mortadella."
Positive
