Iconic Italian-American bakery w/ must-try cannolis, cheesecake & rainbow cake. Can be touristy.
Step into a world of sweet delights at this renowned bakery, celebrated for its authentic Italian-American pastries and cakes. While it's a popular spot for classics like cheesecake and cannolis, be prepared for a potential tourist trap vibe according to some. Despite mixed reviews on its overall appeal, the vibrant rainbow cake and rich cheesecake are frequently highlighted as must-try items.
This bakery specializes in Italian-American desserts, with cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake being frequently recommended. However, some reviews suggest it leans towards being a touristy spot, potentially detracting from the overall experience.
"Customers frequently recommend the cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake."
Customer sentiment is mixed, with some highly recommending classic Italian-American pastries like cheesecake and cannolis, while others caution that it can be a tourist trap.
Important Note
The establishment has been described by some as a tourist trap.
"Santi was listed as a good new opening."
Neutral"B The bread and noodles were noted as possibly better than the UWS original location."
Positive"Carlo's Bakery is identified as one of the worst touristy bakeries in the city."
Negative"This user recommends cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake from Carlo's Bake Shop."
Positive"This user recommends Carlo's Bake Shop."
Positive
