Next.js logo

CARLO'S BAKE SHOP

Last Updated: ~2 months ago

Phone: (201) 240-0506

Address: 625 8 AVENUE 10018

TLDR

Iconic Italian-American pastries w/ rave reviews for cheesecake, cannolis & rainbow cake, but beware: labeled by some as a top tourist trap!

Sentiment Overview(Based on 6 Reddit comments)

67% Positive17% Neutral17% Negative

Tags

italian-american 2bakery 4pastries 2cake 2View All

Neighborhoods

Hell's Kitchen

Details

Step into a world of Italian-American sweetness at Carlo's Bake Shop, a place that sparks strong opinions. While many rave about their delectable cheesecake, authentic cannolis, and vibrant rainbow cake, it's not without its critics. Some diners feel it leans heavily into the 'touristy' category, earning it a reputation as one of the city's less desirable spots for those in the know. Come for the classic treats, but be prepared for a potentially mixed experience.

Food Overview

Carlo's Bake Shop is an Italian-American bakery famous for its wide array of pastries and cakes. Customers specifically recommend the cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake. Despite these recommendations, a strong negative sentiment labels it as a highly touristy establishment and one of the worst of its kind in the city.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers highly recommend the cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake."

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is polarized, with some strongly recommending Carlo's Bake Shop for its Italian-American pastries like cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake. However, others identify it as one of the worst touristy bakeries in the city.

Reddit References

Recent Mentions

From post: Best Openings Of 2025 So Far

"Santi was listed as a good new opening."

Neutral
Jun 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Openings Of 2025 So Far

"B The bread and noodles were noted as possibly better than the UWS original location."

Positive
Jun 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Food In Nyc Are Not The Hype Ones

"Carlo's Bakery is identified as one of the worst touristy bakeries in the city."

Negative
May 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: As Someone With A Huge Sweet Tooth Which Bakeries

"This user recommends cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake from Carlo's Bake Shop."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: As Someone With A Huge Sweet Tooth Which Bakeries

"This user recommends Carlo's Bake Shop."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Jambonbeurres In Nyc

"Recommends Bakeri."

Positive
Apr 17, 2025View Comment →