Next.js logo

CARLO'S BAKE SHOP

Updated

Phone: (201) 240-0506

Address: 625 8 AVENUE 10018

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Iconic Italian-American bakery w/ must-try cannolis, cheesecake & rainbow cake. Can be touristy.

Reddit Sentiment for CARLO'S BAKE SHOP(based on 5 Reddit opinions)

60% Positive20% Neutral20% Negative

Tags

italian-american 2bakery 4pastries 2cake 2View All

Neighborhoods

Hell's Kitchen

Details

Step into a world of sweet delights at this renowned bakery, celebrated for its authentic Italian-American pastries and cakes. While it's a popular spot for classics like cheesecake and cannolis, be prepared for a potential tourist trap vibe according to some. Despite mixed reviews on its overall appeal, the vibrant rainbow cake and rich cheesecake are frequently highlighted as must-try items.

Food Overview

This bakery specializes in Italian-American desserts, with cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake being frequently recommended. However, some reviews suggest it leans towards being a touristy spot, potentially detracting from the overall experience.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers frequently recommend the cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake."

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is mixed, with some highly recommending classic Italian-American pastries like cheesecake and cannolis, while others caution that it can be a tourist trap.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CARLO'S BAKE SHOP

As someone with a huge sweet tooth, which bakeries are a must?
This user specifically recommends the cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake from Carlo's Bake Shop, highlighting them as must-try items.
As someone with a huge sweet tooth, which bakeries are a must?
A user mentions Carlo's Bake Shop as a recommendation for those with a sweet tooth, noting it as a place for bakery items, pastries, and cake.
Best food in NYC are not the hype ones.
This comment identifies Carlo's Bakery as a potentially overrated and touristy bakery in the city.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Openings Of 2025 So Far

"Santi was listed as a good new opening."

Neutral
Jun 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Openings Of 2025 So Far

"B The bread and noodles were noted as possibly better than the UWS original location."

Positive
Jun 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Food In Nyc Are Not The Hype Ones

"Carlo's Bakery is identified as one of the worst touristy bakeries in the city."

Negative
May 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: As Someone With A Huge Sweet Tooth Which Bakeries

"This user recommends cheesecake, cannolis, and rainbow cake from Carlo's Bake Shop."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: As Someone With A Huge Sweet Tooth Which Bakeries

"This user recommends Carlo's Bake Shop."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →