Next.js logo

MERMAID OYSTER BAR

Updated

Phone: (212) 260-0100

Address: 89 MACDOUGAL STREET 10012

TLDR

A must-visit seafood haven, known for its top-tier oysters and memorable fried seafood dishes [1].

Reddit Sentiment for MERMAID OYSTER BAR(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

43% Positive29% Neutral29% Negative

Neighborhoods

Greenwich Village

Details

This seafood spot in Manhattan offers a fresh take on classic oyster bar fare. While reminiscing about a similar establishment, customers have specifically praised dishes like fried oysters and Caesar salad [1]. It's a notable destination for those seeking quality seafood in a lively setting.

Food Overview

The seafood here, particularly oysters, receives mentions. Fried oysters and Caesar salad have been specifically highlighted by patrons [1]. The establishment is often discussed in comparison to the former Pearl Oyster Bar, with some users fondly recalling its fries and other dishes.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers have fondly recalled specific dishes such as fried oysters and Caesar salad from similar establishments, suggesting a preference for these types of classic seafood preparations [1]."

Customer Sentiment

Customers have fond memories of dishes like fried oysters and Caesar salad, though the restaurant is often compared to a now-closed favorite.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MERMAID OYSTER BAR

This user suggested Mermaid Oyster Bar as a good option for reasonably priced sit-down seafood.
In a discussion comparing lobster rolls and other seafood, several users brought up the former Pearl Oyster Bar, mentioning its fried oysters, fries, and Caesar salad in the context of high-quality seafood.
One user recalled the Caesar salad at the now-closed Pearl Oyster Bar as the best example of the style they were looking for, noting it did not survive the COVID-19 pandemic.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Caesar Salad With A Vinaigrettey Dressing In

"The Pearl Oyster Bar's Caesar salad was considered the best version of the desired style, but the establishment did not survive the COVID-19 pandemic."

Negative
May 22, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Lobster Rolls Comparable With Maines

"The author states they loved the fried oysters at Pearl Oyster Bar."

Positive
Mar 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Lobster Rolls Comparable With Maines

"The author states that Pearl Oyster Bar had the best fried oysters they ever had, but notes unfortunately it has closed."

Positive
Mar 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Lobster Rolls Comparable With Maines

"Pearl Oyster Bar is mentioned as a potential place for lobster rolls."

Neutral
Mar 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Lobster Rolls Comparable With Maines

"In response to the mention of Pearl Oyster Bar closing, the author fondly remembers their shoestring fries as heavenly."

Positive
Mar 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Lobster Rolls Comparable With Maines

"The comment expresses sadness over the closing of Pearl Oyster Bar, referring to it as 'RIP Pearl'."

Negative
Mar 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Good Reasonably Priced Sitdown Kind Of Seafood

"This user suggests Mermaid Oyster Bar as a potential option."

Neutral
Feb 25, 2026View Comment →