Phenomenal sandwiches, esp. seasonal BLTs [2] & turkey club [12]! Recovered its excellence post-pandemic [7].
This establishment is renowned for its exceptional sandwiches, with a particular emphasis on a seasonal BLT that has garnered significant praise [2]. After a period of decline, it has notably recovered its former excellence, especially at the Village location [7]. Beyond the BLT, other highly recommended options include the 'Clean Turkey' sandwich, the turkey club, and various vegetarian choices like the 'Ollie' and the 'Reuben broc.' [11, 12, 15, 31]. The restaurant also offers 'cosmopolitan' sandwiches and is noted for its catering services [4, 1].
The restaurant is highly regarded for its sandwiches, with a standout seasonal BLT and a praised turkey club [2, 12]. They also offer a 'Clean Turkey' sandwich and are known for 'cosmopolitan' and vegetarian options like the 'Ollie,' 'Uncle Grandpa,' and 'Reuben broc' [11, 15, 31]. Their catering services have also received enthusiastic recommendations [1].
"The seasonal BLT and the turkey club are highly recommended, as is the 'Clean Turkey' sandwich. For vegetarian options, the 'Ollie,' 'Uncle Grandpa,' and 'Reuben broc' are notable choices."
Customers rave about the quality and variety of sandwiches, with specific mentions of the BLT and turkey club [2, 12]. There's also positive feedback on their catering services and a noted recovery in quality post-pandemic [1, 7].
Important Note
One user mentioned they weren't overly impressed on a previous visit but planned to give it another try [18]. There was also a discussion about the ingredients of the 'Vegetalian' sandwich, with some confusion regarding the presence of sweet potatoes versus butternut squash [26, 27, 28].
"The original poster looked at Court Street Grocers and found many yummy-looking veggie subs, expressing an intent to try them."
Positive"Court Street Grocers has an "insanely good" vegetarian Italian sub."
Positive"This user emphatically agreed with a previous positive statement about Court Street Grocers."
Positive"This user expressed agreement with a previous positive comment about Court Street Grocers."
Positive"This commenter simply stated "Uncle chucky!", likely referring to a sandwich or item from Court Street Grocers."
Neutral"This user responded to a comment about the sandwich ingredients, suggesting that the previous mention of sweet potatoes might have been a seasonal variation."
Neutral"This user provided the detailed ingredient list for the "VEGITALIAN" sandwich, including roasted sweet potato, swiss, mozzarella, pecorino, hoagie spread, arugula, white onion, and mayo on a seeded hero."
Neutral"In response to an inquiry about ingredients, the user clarified that the "vegetalian" sandwich contains butternut squash, not sweet potatoes."
Neutral"In response to a question about what they've tried, the user stated they have only tried Court Street Grocer's offerings, in addition to various eggplant parm heroes."
Neutral"The user inquired if the "vegetalian" sandwich contains sweet potatoes, as they were underwhelmed by a previous tuna sandwich with sweet potatoes from the establishment."
Neutral"This commenter agrees with the recommendation for Court Street Grocers, specifically highlighting the broccoli Rueben as an excellent choice."
Positive"This commenter simply stated "this.", indicating agreement with a prior positive comment about Court Street Grocers."
Positive"The user listed several vegetarian sandwich options from various places, including Court Street Grocers, mentioning their "Olliflower" and "veg Italian" sandwiches, as well as the "Reuben broc.""
Positive"The user highly recommends the "vegetalian" sandwich. They also mentioned the broccoli Rueben as an awesome option."
Positive"The original poster mentions Court Street Grocers as a place to get their tomato fix, implying it's an alternative for a good BLT after the disappointment with Daily Provisions."
Positive"The turkey reuben from Court Street Grocers is highlighted as a good option."
Positive"This commenter states their favorite turkey sandwich is from BKLYN Larder, but they plan to try Court Street Grocers soon to compare."
Neutral"This user confirms that the 'Ollie' sandwich at Court Street Grocers is a good choice."
Positive"This user has been continuously thinking about the turkey club from Court Street Grocers after having it once."
Positive"This commenter recommends the 'Uncle Grandpa' or the 'Ollie' sandwich from Court Street Grocers."
Positive
