TLDR
Top-tier, entirely gluten-free and dairy-free baked goods. An allergy-conscious haven for cakes and pastries that impress even those without dietary restrictions.
Reddit Sentiment for BY THE WAY BAKERY(based on 18 Reddit opinions)
Details
This bakery is a standout destination for those seeking high-quality, allergy-conscious treats that are entirely gluten-free and dairy-free [3], [5], [12]. Renowned for its impressive selection of cakes and pastries, the shop is frequently recommended for special occasions like weddings and birthdays [13], [17]. Even diners without dietary restrictions often find the items exceptionally delicious [9], [13], [18], though patrons should be aware that many products contain eggs [2], [3].
Food Overview
Specializing in American-style baked goods, the menu is strictly gluten-free and dairy-free with minimal soy usage [3], [12], [13]. While highly praised for its inclusivity, the shop is not vegan as many items contain eggs [2], [3], [18]. Highly recommended items include their lemon cake, coconut cake, and whoopie pies [5], [9], [14].
Highlights / Recommended
"The lemon cake and coconut cake are consistently highlighted as standout, exceptionally delicious choices [9], [14]. Whoopie pies are also frequently noted as a popular dessert option [5]."
Customer Sentiment
The overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with customers frequently praising the bakery as a top destination for inclusive, high-quality desserts [13], [17]. While the bakery is a favorite for allergy-friendly needs, some patrons occasionally express confusion regarding the presence of eggs in their products [2], [3].
Caveats
While the bakery is entirely gluten-free and dairy-free, it is not vegan as many products contain eggs [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BY THE WAY BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Gluten Free Cakesdesserts That Are
"The commenter notes that they eat gluten and still find the items here to be tasty; they mention the products are dairy-free but contain eggs."
PositiveFrom post: Gluten And Dairy Free Cakes Restaurant
"This bakery is frequently recommended as a good option for those needing allergy-friendly baked goods."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Any Gluten Free Cakes And Desert
"A recommendation for By the Way Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Any Gluten Free Cakes And Desert
"A specific coconut cake from By The Way Bakery is exceptionally good."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Any Gluten Free Cakes And Desert
"This bakery is highly recommended for gluten-free options, even for those who are not gluten-free. They offer wedding cakes and other desserts."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Any Gluten Free Cakes And Desert
"By the Way Bakery is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Gluten Freecoeliac Safe CaféS In Nyc Looking For
"By the Way Bakery, primarily located uptown, is entirely gluten-free and is recommended for its offerings."
PositiveFrom post: Light Lemon Cake
"This commenter agrees with the recommendation for By the Way bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Light Lemon Cake
"The commenter highly recommends By the Way bakery's lemon cake, stating they get it for their birthday every year and find it exceptionally delicious, even though they do not follow gluten-free or dairy-free diets."
PositiveFrom post: Gluten Free Bakeries
"This user recommended By the Way bakery when asked about gluten-free birthday cakes in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Spots With Gluten Free Food In Manhattan
"By The Way Bakery is highlighted as the best option for gluten-free bakery items."
PositiveFrom post: Gluten Free Bakery Delivery
"This commenter listed By the Way Bakery as a preferred option."
PositiveFrom post: Gluten Free Bakery Delivery
"By the Way Bakery can be delivered through DoorDash and opens around 8 AM, making it a suitable option for early morning meetings."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Vegan Eggless Cakes For Birthday In
"This user recommends By The Way Bakery as an amazing option for vegan/eggless cakes."
PositiveFrom post: Rich Doublechocolate Cookies With White Cream In
"By the Way Bakery is suggested as a place that makes whoopie pies, fitting the description of the dessert the original poster is seeking. They are noted as being a gluten-free and dairy-free establishment."
NeutralFrom post: Dairygluteneggsoy Free Dishes In Manhattan
"By the Way Bakery was noted as being completely dairy and gluten-free, using minimal soy, but commonly uses eggs, and is considered allergy-competent."
PositiveFrom post: Eggless Cake For 1st Birthday Of Child With Egg
"This user clarified that By the Way Bakery is delicious but not vegan, as it contains egg in most items, though it is gluten and dairy-free."
NegativeFrom post: Eggless Cake For 1st Birthday Of Child With Egg
"The user listed By the Way Bakery as another favorite among their vegan friends, noting it's also dairy-free and often easier to find vegan than strictly eggless cakes."
Positive