Next.js logo

BY THE WAY BAKERY

Updated

Phone: (914) 318-9385

Address: 1236 LEXINGTON AVENUE 10028

TLDR

Top-tier GF/DF bakery specializing in delicious, allergy-friendly cakes and pastries. Ideal for inclusive desserts that everyone can enjoy, regardless of dietary needs.

Reddit Sentiment for BY THE WAY BAKERY(based on 19 Reddit opinions)

84% Positive16% Neutral

Tags

american 6bakery 3bakery 7cakes 5cake 4View All

Neighborhoods

Upper East Side

Instagram Posts References

A new bakery is opening on Lexington Avenue, taking over the space formerly occupied by a bookstore. This establishment, which already has three Manhattan locations, will open its first branch north of 59th Street. The bakery is known for sourdough and cardamom buns, indicating a focus on artisanal baked goods.

Details

A go-to destination for high-quality, allergy-conscious treats, this bakery specializes in entirely gluten-free and dairy-free baked goods that remain flavorful for all diners [1], [2]. While the menu is inclusive, patrons should note that many items contain eggs [1], [3]. Known for being a top choice for special occasions like birthdays and weddings, the bakery is highly regarded for its consistent quality and inclusive approach [4], [5], [6].

Food Overview

This bakery offers an entirely gluten-free and dairy-free menu that is noted for its high quality and flavor [3], [5]. While many items are vegan-friendly, it is important to note that many products contain eggs [1], [3]. Popular offerings frequently cited include their lemon cake, coconut cake, and honey cake, all of which are highly recommended for celebrations [4], [6], [7].

Customer Sentiment

Customers consistently praise the establishment for its exceptional, inclusive baked goods that satisfy both allergy-conscious diners and those without dietary restrictions [3], [4]. No negative feedback regarding service or quality has been reported, highlighting a high level of overall satisfaction [5], [6].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About BY THE WAY BAKERY

This post contains numerous recommendations for the bakery, specifically highlighting their coconut cake and wedding cake options.
Users discuss why the lemon cake is a standout choice for birthday celebrations, even for non-gluten-free diners.
Provides a helpful breakdown of the bakery's allergy profile, noting it is dairy and gluten-free but often uses eggs.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Ultra Dense And Chocolatey Chocolate Cake In

"Mentioned as a general recommendation for cakes."

Neutral
Sep 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Favorite Jewish Bakeries Selling Honey Cake Not

"The bakery is recommended for its excellent gluten-free honey cake."

Positive
Sep 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For Gluten Free Cakesdesserts That Are

"The commenter notes that they eat gluten and still find the items here to be tasty; they mention the products are dairy-free but contain eggs."

Positive
Aug 13, 2026View Comment →

From post: Gluten And Dairy Free Cakes Restaurant

"This bakery is frequently recommended as a good option for those needing allergy-friendly baked goods."

Positive
Jul 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Anyone Know Any Gluten Free Cakes And Desert

"A recommendation for By the Way Bakery."

Positive
Apr 20, 2026View Comment →

More in Upper East Side

See all

More American in NYC

See all