Next.js logo

THE SMITH

Last Updated: 24 days ago

Phone: (212) 685-4500

Address: 1150 BROADWAY 10001

TLDR

A reliable, non-adventurous American brasserie, perfect for family and business meals. Known for its lively atmosphere and broad appeal.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 84 Reddit comments)

24% Positive25% Neutral51% Negative

Tags

american 37british 2american 17brunch 11oysters 10View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

This American brasserie is a popular choice for those seeking a reliably good meal without venturing into adventurous territory. It's often recommended for family outings and business lunches due to its broad menu and accommodating atmosphere. While some find it to be a bit generic, others appreciate its consistent quality and lively ambiance.

Food Overview

This American brasserie offers a wide-ranging menu that caters to a variety of tastes, making it a safe bet for groups. While some dishes like the sticky toffee pudding and Caesar salad receive praise, others find the food to be unremarkable or even greasy, with some comparisons to chain restaurants.

Highlights / Recommended

"The sticky toffee pudding and the little gem Caesar salad have been specifically recommended. The Smith burger is also noted as a good option when dining at the bar."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • sticky toffee pudding(2)
  • croissant(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is divided, with some praising its consistency and suitability for diverse palates, while others criticize it as generic, loud, and overpriced.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

Multiple commenters strongly advise against dining here due to its ownership by the Sackler family and criticize its loud atmosphere and generic food, comparing it to 'business lunch Applebee's'.
This restaurant is suggested as a fitting choice for taking family out to eat, especially for picky eaters, as it's described as not too adventurous or super expensive.
The sticky toffee pudding here is highlighted as a must-try dessert, with one user being 'absolutely obsessed' with it and another calling it 'pretty fire.'
This spot is frequently mentioned as a practical and reliable choice for business lunches, accommodating diverse preferences and offering efficient service, though some question its high ranking and value.
Several users strongly recommend avoiding this restaurant, citing its generic chain-like quality and, more significantly, its ownership by the Sackler family.
Despite general negative sentiment towards the restaurant, its little gem Caesar salad is specifically praised as 'fantastic.'
Initially overlooked, this place is now recommended near Lincoln Center, with a specific mention of enjoying the Smith burger when seated at the bar.

Recent Mentions

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Secretly enjoys The Smith."

Positive
Jan 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Acknowledges enjoying The Smith for its consistency and service but will stop going due to ownership."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Complains about the excessive noise level inside The Smith, attributing it to the tiled decor."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Critiques The Smith's interior design, comparing it to a bathroom."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"States that The Smith serves a greasy and disgusting burger."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Suggests The Smith's appeal might stem from its ability to accommodate dietary restrictions well."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Describes The Smith as 'business lunch Applebee's' with a broad menu suitable for diverse preferences and efficient service."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"States directly that The Smith is bad."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Questions The Smith's popularity, citing poor food quality and wondering if anyone genuinely likes it."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Categorizes The Smith as a corporate, PE-backed restaurant, advising avoidance."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Expresses dissatisfaction with The Smith, recalling a poorly prepared steak served cold."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Advises to avoid The Smith due to its ownership by Sackler."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In

"This user recommended The Smith, stating they have a great croissant."

Positive
Jan 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In

"This user recommended The Smith, stating they have a great croissant."

Positive
Jan 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sunday Birthday Brunch Recs

"The user suggests The Smith as a go-to spot for brunch."

Positive
Nov 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant

"This comment lists The Smith as a restaurant."

Neutral
Nov 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: 1st Time In Usa And Nyc

"The Smith was suggested as an excellent option for Thanksgiving dinner, though it is noted as being on the pricier side at $88 per person."

Positive
Nov 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: 1st Time In Usa And Nyc

"The Smith was mentioned as a potential option for Thanksgiving dinner, with a link provided to their menu."

Neutral
Nov 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Mightiest Steakhouses In Nyc Keens Next

"The commenter states that 'The Smith' has no substance and is all flash."

Negative
Oct 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Birthday Dinner With Foodie Parents

"A commenter recommended The Smith as a place to consider for a birthday dinner when asked for restaurant suggestions in NYC."

Neutral
Oct 12, 2025View Comment →