A crowd-pleasing American brasserie known for its reliable service & broad menu. Indulge in their "pretty fire" sticky toffee pudding [1] or a solid Caesar salad [2], though some find it "loud" & "business lunch Applebee's" [3, 4].
This American brasserie is a popular choice for its reliable and accommodating dining experience, suitable for various occasions from family visits to business lunches. While some find its food to be "pretty fire," particularly the sticky toffee pudding [1] and little gem Caesar salad [2], others feel it's a "business lunch Applebee's" with unremarkable food quality [3]. The restaurant's large space and broad menu make it a convenient option for groups, though its lively atmosphere can be perceived as "crazy loud" due to poor acoustics [4].
The Smith offers an American brasserie menu with some standout dishes, including a highly praised sticky toffee pudding [1] and a well-regarded little gem Caesar salad [2]. However, opinions on the food are mixed, with some describing it as "pretty fire" [1] and others deeming it "mediocre" or "glorified diner food" [3, 5]. It's often seen as a safe choice for accommodating diverse tastes, though not necessarily a gourmet destination.
"The sticky toffee pudding is a standout dessert that some users are "absolutely obsessed" with [1]. The little gem Caesar salad is also recommended as being fantastic [2]."
Customer sentiment is divided; many praise specific dishes like the sticky toffee pudding [1] and little gem Caesar salad [2], viewing it as a reliable choice for groups and business lunches. However, a significant portion of feedback criticizes the food as mediocre, calling it "business lunch Applebee's" [3], and many find the restaurant "crazy loud" with poor acoustics [4].
Important Note
The Smith faces significant criticism due to its ownership by a member of the Sackler family [1, 2, 3]. Additionally, many patrons find the restaurant to be "crazy loud" with poor acoustics, making conversation difficult [4, 5].
"This user called The Smith 'NY Appellees', comparing it to TGI Fridays."
Neutral"This user pointed out that The Smith is owned by the Sackler family and advised against giving them money."
Negative"This commenter thanked another user for the information about The Smith being owned by the Sackler family."
Neutral"This user described The Smith as a fantastic TGI Fridays."
Neutral"This commenter seconded The Smith, mentioning it's great for last-minute groups and they were able to get a table for 12 with a short wait on a Friday night."
Positive"The Smith was recommended."
Positive"This user remarked that whenever they pass The Smith, they think 'Parents' Weekend'."
Neutral"This user alerted others to the fact that The Smith is owned by the Sackler family, advising against supporting them."
Negative"The Smith was recommended."
Positive"The Smith was recommended for American cuisine, alongside Patsy's for Italian."
Positive"The Smith was recommended."
Positive"This user felt The Smith captured the Cheesecake Factory vibe with its diverse menu, including bibimbap, shrimp scampi, and steaks, all tasting decent."
Positive"The Smith was recommended as a good option."
Positive"The Smith was listed among several other restaurant suggestions."
Neutral"This user suggested The Smith as an alternative to Hillstone."
Neutral"This commenter stated that The Smith is the correct answer."
Positive"The Smith was recommended as the correct answer for the original post."
Positive"Describes The Smith as a reliable, accommodating, and generally satisfactory dining option in NYC that can always handle reservations, even if not a standout favorite."
Neutral"Suggests The Smith as a potential option for a group of 14 due to its size and availability, noting that it can stay under $100 per person with appetizers, entrees, and drinks."
Neutral"The original poster is considering various options for their first beef experience, including burgers and sandwiches, while deliberately excluding steak."
Neutral
