Reliable American fare, perfect for picky eaters & families, but expect a lively, loud scene.
This American brasserie aims to be a reliable choice, often described as a safe bet for those seeking familiar flavors without culinary risks. While some patrons find it to be a decent option for family outings or business lunches, others feel it falls short of expectations, comparing it to generic chain restaurants and noting its loud atmosphere.
The American cuisine at The Smith is generally seen as safe and unadventurous, making it a suitable choice for those with simpler palates or families. While some dishes like the sticky toffee pudding and Caesar salad receive praise, the overall food quality is often debated, with comparisons to chain restaurants like Applebee's and Ruby Tuesday.
"The sticky toffee pudding and the little gem Caesar salad have been highlighted as particularly good dishes. The Smith burger is also recommended, especially when dining at the bar."
Customer sentiment is divided, with some praising it as a dependable choice for unadventurous eaters and families, while others criticize it as generic, loud, and overpriced.
Important Note
The restaurant is frequently described as very loud, which can detract from the dining experience for some. Additionally, there are recurring comments about the ownership and its ethical implications, with some patrons choosing to avoid the establishment for this reason.
"The Smith is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"A commenter advises against patronizing The Smith due to its association with the Sackler family."
Negative"The commenter initially avoided The Smith but now considers it a top choice for dining near Lincoln Center, specifically recommending the Smith burger when sitting at the bar."
Positive"This restaurant was recommended as a potential option for a large group dinner."
Neutral"The user described The Smith as having poor sound design, comparing the reverberation to dining inside an empty pool."
Negative"The Smith is listed as a very loud restaurant, with poor acoustics."
Negative"The Smith is listed as a very loud restaurant, with poor acoustics."
Negative"The Smith is listed as a very loud restaurant, with poor acoustics."
Negative"Following up on the previous comment, this user stated they did not know about the ownership and that "nuf said.""
Negative"This user added that The Smith is also problematic because the Sackler family are owners."
Negative"The user simply stated "The Smith" in response to the question about loud restaurants."
Negative"The Smith is humorously recommended for taking someone you don't want to hear."
Negative"The user states that The Smith, across any location, is loud."
Negative"The Smith on 2nd Ave is described as "crazy loud" due to the prevalence of tile."
Negative"The user states that The Smith is a practical choice for a business lunch, as it can easily satisfy a group with diverse preferences."
Positive"The user found a meal at The Smith to be a waste of money, even on a company card, and felt the food was unremarkable. They believe the restaurant occupies valuable real estate without offering a great dining experience."
Negative"Responding to the 'fancy Applebee's' comparison, the user explains that The Smith is a safe choice for business meals, especially for those with limited budgets who want to please a group. They clarify that the owners are not deeply connected to the Sacklers, refuting a common rumor."
Positive"The user compares The Smith to 'fancy Applebee's' and questions its high ranking on expense lists, suggesting it might be due to its ease of use for business lunches. They also bring up a rumor about the owners' connections."
Negative"The user acknowledges that some wealthy individuals have questionable taste and that Ramp is a rapidly growing company in the tech sector. They note that The Smith is a good option for business meals, even for those not seeking ultra-luxury."
Neutral"The user suggests that The Smith has multiple locations, and its high ranking on the list might be due to combining expenses from all of them."
Neutral
