Next.js logo

THE SMITH

Last Updated: 8 days ago

Phone: (212) 685-4500

Address: 1150 BROADWAY 10001

TLDR

Lively American brasserie known for its consistent, non-adventurous fare, ideal for groups & business diners.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 89 Reddit comments)

24% Positive28% Neutral48% Negative

Tags

american 37british 2american 17brunch 11oysters 10View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

This American brasserie is a popular choice for its lively atmosphere and diverse menu, making it a reliable spot for various occasions. While some find it to be a consistently good option that avoids extremes in flavor or price, others have noted a decline in quality over the years, with some even comparing it unfavorably to chain restaurants.

Food Overview

The cuisine is primarily American, with mentions of dishes like burgers and a highly recommended sticky toffee pudding. However, some diners express disappointment, with comparisons to chain restaurants and criticisms of food quality, including a greasy burger and a poorly prepared steak.

Highlights / Recommended

"The sticky toffee pudding is frequently highlighted as a must-try dessert. The Smith burger and the little gem Caesar salad have also received positive mentions."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • sticky toffee pudding(2)
  • croissant(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is divided, with some praising its reliability and suitability for various diners, while others criticize its perceived generic quality and decline over time.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

Multiple commenters express strong negative sentiments towards The Smith, citing its ownership by the Sackler family, loud atmosphere due to tiled decor, and general poor quality, with some calling it 'bad' or 'business lunch Applebee's'.
The Smith is suggested as a good option for taking family out, particularly for picky eaters, as it's described as non-adventurous and not too expensive.
A significant number of users strongly advise avoiding The Smith, with some comparing it to chains like Ruby Tuesdays, mentioning its ownership by the Sackler family, and describing it as loud and basic.
Several comments discuss The Smith's high ranking on expense lists, with some defending it as a reliable and accommodating choice for business meals, while others criticize it as overpriced and unremarkable.
The sticky toffee pudding at The Smith is highly praised by multiple users, with one user being 'absolutely obsessed' and another calling it 'pretty fire.'
The Smith is recommended as a suitable option for someone with a simple palate, described as 'super basic' by one commenter, while another warns against it due to its ownership.
Despite general negative sentiment towards The Smith, one user finds their little gem Caesar salad to be 'fantastic.'

Recent Mentions

From post: Wheelchair Friendly Monday Night Manhattan

"The original poster expressed fondness for The Smith and confirmed its known accessibility, although her husband is not its biggest fan."

Positive
Feb 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For A Crossgenerational Crowd Pleaser

"The Smith is recommended as a dining option."

Neutral
Feb 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Wheelchair Friendly Monday Night Manhattan

"The Smith was recommended as a possible restaurant for the birthday dinner."

Neutral
Feb 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For A Crossgenerational Crowd Pleaser

"The Smith is listed as a restaurant option."

Neutral
Feb 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Good Brunch Spots For Group Of 1015

"This restaurant was recommended as a spot that could accommodate a large group for brunch."

Neutral
Feb 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Secretly enjoys The Smith."

Positive
Jan 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Acknowledges enjoying The Smith for its consistency and service but will stop going due to ownership."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Complains about the excessive noise level inside The Smith, attributing it to the tiled decor."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Critiques The Smith's interior design, comparing it to a bathroom."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"States that The Smith serves a greasy and disgusting burger."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Suggests The Smith's appeal might stem from its ability to accommodate dietary restrictions well."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Describes The Smith as 'business lunch Applebee's' with a broad menu suitable for diverse preferences and efficient service."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"States directly that The Smith is bad."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Questions The Smith's popularity, citing poor food quality and wondering if anyone genuinely likes it."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Categorizes The Smith as a corporate, PE-backed restaurant, advising avoidance."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Expresses dissatisfaction with The Smith, recalling a poorly prepared steak served cold."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Vc And Private Equity Owned Spots

"Advises to avoid The Smith due to its ownership by Sackler."

Negative
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In

"This user recommended The Smith, stating they have a great croissant."

Positive
Jan 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In

"This user recommended The Smith, stating they have a great croissant."

Positive
Jan 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sunday Birthday Brunch Recs

"The user suggests The Smith as a go-to spot for brunch."

Positive
Nov 30, 2025View Comment →