TLDR
A go-to for large groups and business lunches needing consistency. Known for solid American brasserie staples in a famously loud, high-energy space.
Instagram Posts References
The Smith is a restaurant in NYC that is recommended for brunch, especially when a group is struggling to decide where to eat. It's characterized as a well-put-together version of a diner, providing solid food without causing stress. The reviewer highlights several dishes including chips and dip, the Smith Burger, a French dip sandwich, and a Caesar salad with a large parmesan crisp. The overall sentiment is that while the food isn't revolutionary, it's consistently good, and diners are advised to upgrade their fries.
This post highlights Sand Lunch, a restaurant located in the Flatiron district of New York City. The user enjoyed a comfort meal, specifically mentioning Potato Latkes with sour cream and apple sauce, a Tuna Melt, French Fries, and a Banana Split. The imagery showcases these classic diner-style dishes, suggesting a satisfying and nostalgic dining experience.
Details
Known as a versatile American brasserie, this spot is frequently praised as a reliable and accommodating choice for large groups and business lunches [1]. However, it faces significant criticism regarding its loud, tile-heavy atmosphere [2] and negative perceptions surrounding its corporate ownership [3]. While some diners enjoy the consistent food quality, others describe it as overpriced, average-quality fare [4].
Food Overview
The menu offers a broad range of American comfort food, with dishes like the Smith burger, moules frites, and tuna on crispy rice receiving positive mentions [5], [6]. Conversely, some diners find the food unremarkable or 'mid,' occasionally complaining about issues like cold steaks or greasy burgers [4], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE SMITH
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where To Take Picky Parents Out To Brunch Dinner
"Described as an upscale diner with a wide variety of options, making it a very safe bet for picky eaters."
PositiveFrom post: Grocery And Family Friendly Restaurants Near
"Recommended as the best option for a picky child in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Good Midtown Reservation Choices For 40yo Mom And
"Mentioned as falling into the same category as other solid, consistent, fuss-free staples in the area."
NeutralFrom post: The Summer I Gained Fifty Pounds Late June Thru
"User states they cannot personally endorse The Smith."
NegativeFrom post: The Summer I Gained Fifty Pounds Late June Thru
"The author visited twice and felt it was a solid backup restaurant, noting they preferred the shrimp scampi over the steak."
Neutral