Lively American brasserie, a go-to for non-adventurous eaters & business lunches. Consistency w/ a wide menu, though can be loud & some find it generic.
This American brasserie is a popular choice for both locals and tourists, offering a lively atmosphere and a diverse menu that aims to please a wide range of palates. While it's lauded for its consistency and ability to cater to various dietary needs, some diners find it to be a bit too generic or loud. Despite mixed reviews, it remains a go-to for business lunches and family gatherings.
The food is generally described as American cuisine, with mentions of a good burger and a fantastic Caesar salad. However, some reviews criticize the food quality, calling it 'mid' or 'greasy.' The sticky toffee pudding receives specific praise, while oysters and brunch are also mentioned. A notable point of contention for many is the restaurant's ownership, which leads some to actively avoid it.
"The sticky toffee pudding is a standout dessert that has garnered significant praise. The 'little gem' Caesar salad is also noted as being fantastic, and the bar steak is described as consistently solid and reasonably priced."
Customer sentiment is divided. While many appreciate its consistency, broad menu, and suitability for business or family gatherings, a significant portion finds it overly loud, generic, and overpriced, with some also boycotting it due to ownership.
Important Note
The restaurant is frequently described as being very loud, which can detract from the dining experience for some. Additionally, there is significant controversy surrounding its ownership by members of the Sackler family, leading many to boycott the establishment.
"This commenter adds that the father of the owner of The Smith was one of Epstein's attorneys, further reinforcing negative sentiment towards the establishment."
Negative"This commenter strongly advises against eating at The Smith because it is owned by the Sackler family."
Negative"The original poster expresses a desire not to go to The Smith again."
Negative"In response to a query about 'millennial restaurants' in NYC, this user stated that The Smith perfectly fits the description. They also mentioned Hillstone as similar but perceived as 'cooler'."
Neutral"A user asked if a restaurant fitting the description of a 'millennial restaurant' with high prices and a specific aesthetic exists in NYC. This user suggested The Smith might fit this description."
Neutral"The commenter had a delicious ribeye at The Smith recently."
Positive"The bar steak at The Smith is consistently solid and reasonably priced."
Positive"The Smith in Nomad was recommended as a popular American brasserie with a large space, suitable for team dinners."
Positive"This user prefers cinnamon rolls that are soft, pillowy, and gooey, similar to Cinnabon, and dislikes laminated cinnamon buns."
Neutral"This user had an extremely good experience with the moules frites at The Smith in Nomad, noting the large portion size and reasonable price."
Positive"The original poster expressed fondness for The Smith and confirmed its known accessibility, although her husband is not its biggest fan."
Positive"The Smith is recommended as a dining option."
Neutral"The Smith was recommended as a possible restaurant for the birthday dinner."
Neutral"The Smith is listed as a restaurant option."
Neutral"This restaurant was recommended as a spot that could accommodate a large group for brunch."
Neutral"Secretly enjoys The Smith."
Positive"Acknowledges enjoying The Smith for its consistency and service but will stop going due to ownership."
Neutral"Complains about the excessive noise level inside The Smith, attributing it to the tiled decor."
Negative"Critiques The Smith's interior design, comparing it to a bathroom."
Negative"States that The Smith serves a greasy and disgusting burger."
Negative
