Next.js logo

BROOKLYN PIZZA CREW

Updated

Phone: (718) 363-1122

Address: 758 NOSTRAND AVENUE 11216

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Must-try pizza spot w/ an epic Cup & Char Pepperoni Grandma slice. Consistently great quality & size.

Reddit Sentiment for BROOKLYN PIZZA CREW(based on 3 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive33% Neutral

Tags

italian-american 3pizza 3View All

Neighborhoods

Crown Heights

Details

This Brooklyn-based pizzeria offers a fantastic slice of New York-style pizza, with a standout Cup & Char Pepperoni Grandma Pizza that's worth the splurge. Customers praise its generous size and consistent quality, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal that reheats well.

Food Overview

The restaurant is celebrated for its New York-style pizzas, with a particular recommendation for the Cup & Char Pepperoni Grandma Pizza. This dish is praised for its size and the quality of its cheese and pepperoni, noted as being excellent even when reheated.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Cup & Char Pepperoni Grandma Pizza is highly recommended for its quality and size, even for reheating."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the pizza, often highlighting the quality and generous portion sizes of specific pies.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About BROOKLYN PIZZA CREW

Shoutout to the unhyped independent neighborhood spots!
This post recommends Brooklyn Pizza Crew in Crown Heights as a great, unhyped neighborhood spot for pizza.
Best cheap pizza in or near Crown Heights?
A commenter recommended the Cup & Char Pepperoni Grandma Pizza, noting its large size and consistent satisfaction, despite the $30 price tag.
Any actually good vegan pepperoni NY slices? (no chains)
A user mentioned that BK Pizza Crew offers a vegan pepperoni option, describing it as a fine and unfussy choice.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Cheap Pizza In Or Near Crown Heights

"The commenter recommended the Cup & Char Pepperoni Grandma Pizza from Brooklyn Pizza Crew, noting that while it costs $30, it's a large pizza that can be reheated. They praised the quality of the cheese and pepperoni, stating it consistently satisfies."

Positive
Feb 14, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Actually Good Vegan Pepperoni Ny Slices No

"The user mentioned BK Pizza Crew as a place that offers a vegan pepperoni option, describing it as fine and unfussy at best."

Neutral
Oct 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Shoutout To The Unhyped Independent Neighborhood

"A commenter recommended Brooklyn Pizza Crew in Crown Heights as 'great'."

Positive
Mar 24, 2025View Comment →

More in Crown Heights

See all

More italian-american in NYC

See all