TLDR
Reliable seafood rolls and a go-to benchmark for city pricing. Perfect for a quick, consistent bite or keto-friendly options.
Details
Known for its signature seafood rolls, this establishment often serves as a primary benchmark for quality and pricing in the city [7]. While some patrons appreciate the consistent, non-gummy texture of the lobster [4], others note a perceived decline in quality since the brand expanded into a larger chain [2]. Despite mixed reviews on its signature items, some seasonal offerings like the crab and chile crisp sandwich have received high praise [6].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American-style seafood, primarily known for lobster rolls that some describe as excellent and buttery [9], though they are frequently compared—sometimes unfavorably—to those found in Maine [1], [3]. While lobster remains the standard, seasonal items like the crab and chile crisp sandwich have been highlighted as exceptional [6]. The restaurant is also noted as a viable option for those following a keto diet [10].
The buttery lobster roll is frequently cited as excellent [9], and the seasonal crab and chile crisp sandwich comes highly recommended [6].
Feedback is divided, with some customers praising the consistent quality of the rolls [4], [8], [9] while others feel the chain's expansion has led to a decline in value and overall experience [1], [2], [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01lobster roll3 mentions
Caveats
Some visitors consider the establishment overpriced compared to its quality, often finding it inferior to other local lobster roll competitors [1], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LUKE'S LOBSTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Keto Friendly Dishes Restaurants Share Your
"Recommended as a seafood spot that works for a keto diet."
PositiveFrom post: Lobster That Will Convince Me Theres Any Point To
"The author tried an excellent buttery lobster roll here, though they personally prefer shrimp or crab."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Specials At Dim Sum Palace On Division
"The commenter uses this place as a price benchmark for seafood rolls."
NeutralFrom post: Any Suggestions For A Manhattan Seafood Lunch
"Explicit fan of the rolls."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Crab Dish In Nyc
"Mentioned that Luke's Lobster had a crab and chile crisp sandwich that was amazing, and to look out for it next year as it might be seasonal."
Positive