TLDR
Beloved NYC bakery famous for rich red velvet cake and sugary, indulgent cupcakes. Multiple convenient locations across Manhattan make it a go-to for casual dessert runs.
Reddit Sentiment for BUTTERCUP BAKESHOP(based on 23 Reddit opinions)
Details
A go-to destination for high-quality American-style baked goods, this bakery is widely praised for its diverse selection of cakes and pastries [3], [16]. Patrons frequently describe themselves as "addicted" to the offerings, often noting the excellent value with treats priced under $12 [5]. While generally celebrated for their iconic buttercream frosting, some visitors occasionally find the cupcakes to be on the sweeter side [12], [20].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American baked goods, with a heavy emphasis on cakes, cupcakes, and pastries [4], [5], [16]. The red velvet cake and funfetti cupcakes are specific fan favorites [2], [9], [16], though the buttercream frosting is a constant topic of conversation, being both highly praised for its flavor and occasionally critiqued for its high sugar content [12], [20].
Caveats
Some customers find the cupcakes and frosting to be quite sweet, noting that the icing is more sugar-forward than buttery [12].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BUTTERCUP BAKESHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Bakerycake Shop Recos Within Manhattan Where I
"The user is currently enjoying one of their campfire bars."
PositiveFrom post: Bakerycake Shop Recos Within Manhattan Where I
"Recommended as a place to find cakes."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cupcakes In Ktown Or Soho For Today
"Recommended as a spot for cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Red Velvet With Cream Cheese Frosting
"A user simply stated 'Buttercup bake shop!!!' as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Best Red Velvet With Cream Cheese Frosting
"A user recalled liking Buttercup Bakery in the past and wondered if it is still good."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user confirms Buttercup Bakery has red velvet cheesecake and states they are addicted to their frosting."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user seconds Buttercup Bakery and asks if they also offer a red velvet cheesecake."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user confirms Buttercup Bakery uses buttercream frosting and finds it delicious."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user asks if Buttercup Bakery uses buttercream frosting, as they find cream cheese frosting too sweet."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user's favorite place to get a red velvet cake slice is Buttercup Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user believes Buttercup Bake Shop's cupcakes are very sweet and cakelike, with icing that is more sugar than butter, contrasting with the original poster's preference for a less sweet, more buttery frosting."
NegativeFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user expresses a passion for finding beautifully decorated cupcakes with American buttercream and mentions Buttercup Bake Shop, indicating they will be looking for them when they visit the city soon. They also discuss different types of buttercream."
NeutralFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user mentions enjoying the cake slices from Buttercup Bake Shop, describing them as a special treat they had annually when working in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user suggests Buttercup Bake Shop as a place that might have cupcakes with buttercream frosting similar to what the original poster is looking for."
NeutralFrom post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"Buttercup Bake Shop was mentioned as a place that offers funfetti cupcakes."
NeutralFrom post: Seeking Snickerdoodle Cookie Anywhere In 5
"The user recommends Buttercup Bake Shop, mentioning they have a couple of locations in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Most Fudgy And Dense Cake
"The user recommended Buttercup Bake Shop for a casual dining experience, specifically for cake."
PositiveFrom post: Chocolate Birthday Cake
"Buttercup bakeshop is noted as being really good and having multiple locations in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Yellow Cake With Chocolate Frosting
"This user recommends Buttercup Bake Shop."
PositiveFrom post: Cake Slice Rec
"Responding to Buttercup Bakeshop, this user stated they are 'addicted' to the shop's offerings and that two items are usually under $12."
Positive