TLDR
Iconic NYC donut shop w/ pillowy-light, hand-cut donuts made fresh all day. Classic glazed & nostalgic vibe.
Reddit Sentiment for PETER PAN DONUT & PASTRY SHOP(based on 86 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The post spotlights Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop as a longstanding New York institution, proudly operating since 1953 and adhering to its original recipes. It is highly praised for its fresh, hand-cut donuts, which are consistently made throughout the day and described as 'pillowy light,' with a particular emphasis on its classic glazed varieties. The establishment is also noted for its distinctive vintage counters and for successfully preserving a nostalgic neighborhood charm, which has cemented its reputation as one of New York City's most cherished donut shops.
Peter Pan Donuts is a classic New York donut shop known for its traditional offerings. The menu includes a variety of donuts, muffins, and bagels, as well as coffee and hot chocolate. The ambiance appears to be a no-frills, cash-only establishment, reflecting its long-standing presence in the community.
The video features the exterior of the classic donut shop, a display case filled with various donuts, and shows freshly fried donuts being covered in a thick white glaze before showcasing a box of assorted, colorful donuts. It captures the fresh preparation and appealing variety.
Details
A classic New York institution since 1953, this donut shop is celebrated for its fresh, hand-cut donuts made throughout the day using original recipes [1]. Known for their pillowy light texture and nostalgic neighborhood charm, they offer a variety of classic glazed options and other baked goods [1]. The establishment maintains a no-frills, cash-only atmosphere, reflecting its long-standing presence in the community [2].
Food Overview
This bakery is renowned for its fresh, hand-cut donuts, with specific mentions of honey glazed yeast donuts, apple fritters, and sour cream donuts receiving high praise [2]. While most reviews are positive, some found certain cake donuts to be a bit hard and yeasted donuts less appealing [3]. The shop also offers other items like bagels and pastries, and their iced coffee has been noted as surprisingly good and cheap [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The honey glazed yeast donuts and apple fritters are frequently recommended as favorites [2]. The sour cream donut is also highlighted as an exceptional choice, with some calling it the best they've ever had [3], [4]. Additionally, the BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese) sandwich on a flagel is noted as a must-try item [5]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •apple fritter(4)
- •sour cream donut(3)
- •honey glazed yeast donuts(2)
- •apple fritters(2)
- •donuts(2)
- •cake donuts(2)
- •coffee cake(2)
- •crullers(2)
- •old fashioned donuts(2)
- •yeasted donuts(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly recommend this donut shop, praising its classic offerings and the unique experience it provides, though some note its cash-only policy and compare it to competitors [2].
Caveats
While generally praised, some users have noted that cake donuts can be a bit hard and yeasted donuts are not as favored [3]. There is also a mention of a 'thin blue line' sticker displayed, which may be a consideration for some patrons [5]. The establishment is strictly cash-only [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PETER PAN DONUT & PASTRY SHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Visited For My Sisters Wedding Had 25 Days To
"Described as 'nice,' the honey dip donut was exceptionally soft, and the sour cream donut was incredible. It's a cash-only establishment with decent prices."
PositiveFrom post: Iced Coffee Recommendations Not Cold Brew
"Following up on the Peter Pan Donut & Coffee Shop recommendation, the commenter notes that the iced coffee is also very cheap."
PositiveFrom post: Iced Coffee Recommendations Not Cold Brew
"The commenter had an iced coffee at Peter Pan Donut & Coffee Shop in Greenpoint and found it to be surprisingly good in a 'trashy' way."
PositiveFrom post: Six Days In Nyc Wa Schmo And A Vegetarian A Food
"This user commented that as long as a great donut was acquired, everything else is fine, and expressed love for NYC donuts from places like Peter Pan."
PositiveFrom post: Six Days In Nyc Wa Schmo And A Vegetarian A Food
"The user found the chocolate cake donut from Peter Pan's to be 'rapturous,' stating it was the first good donut they'd had in 26 years."
PositiveFrom post: Lastyle Sugar Raised Donuts
"The original poster mentioned Peter Pan but did not find their donuts to be similar in taste or texture to LA-style sugar raised donuts."
NegativeFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"This commenter suggested arriving by 9 AM to Peter Pan Donuts for a potentially better experience with fewer lines, as the area becomes busier around 11 AM."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter stated that Peter Pan Donuts continuously brings out new items and expressed fondness for the place."
PositiveFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter mentioned performing a comparison of main donut types from both Peter Pan Donuts and Mo's a couple of weeks prior, and provided a link to the comparison."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter advised having a backup plan if Peter Pan Donuts is too crowded and recommended trying the apple fritter."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter expressed a personal preference for the blueberry donuts at Peter Pan Donuts, relating it to a childhood fondness for Dunkin' Donuts."
PositiveFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"This commenter found Mo's to be virtually indistinguishable from Peter Pan Donuts in taste, but noted that Mo's has a less appealing atmosphere."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"This commenter expressed strong positive feelings for Mo's."
PositiveFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"This user stated their preference for Mo's over Peter Pan Donuts."
NegativeFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter stated that everything at Peter Pan Donuts is good and they shouldn't worry about items being sold out. However, they did note that it would be very busy at the time OP was planning to visit."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"This user believes Mo's is not better than Peter Pan Donuts."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter disagreed that Mo's is better than Peter Pan Donuts but appreciated that Mo's accepts credit cards."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"This commenter stated that Mo's Doughs typically has a shorter line and better donuts than Peter Pan Donuts."
NegativeFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The commenter confirmed that Sundays are usually busy at Peter Pan Donuts and suggested trying Mo's Doughs as an alternative, noting that Sunday at 11 AM is prime time for both establishments."
NeutralFrom post: Peter Pan Donuts On February Sunday
"The original poster visited Peter Pan Donuts and found the classic glazed donut to be mediocre, but highly enjoyed the apple fritter, coconut creme, and apple crumb donuts."
Negative